You’ve probably seen the name. Maybe you were walking down Main Street in Santa Monica, or perhaps you were wandering through Mid-City New Orleans looking for a place to watch a Liverpool match at 7:00 AM. Sometimes it’s spelled Finn McCool’s, other times it’s Fionn MacCool’s, and occasionally just McCool’s.
It’s confusing.
Honestly, most people assume it’s one giant, soul-crushing corporate machine like a McDonald's but with more Guinness. That’s not actually the case. While there is a massive Canadian franchise under the "Fionn" spelling, many of the most famous Finn McCool’s locations across the United States and Australia are fiercely independent, family-owned, or part of tiny local groups. They share a name rooted in the same giant of Irish mythology—the guy who allegedly built the Giant’s Causeway—but the vibe in the New Orleans pub is lightyears away from the one on the Gold Coast.
The Santa Monica Legend and the Newry Connection
Take the Santa Monica spot. This isn't just a bar with some green paint. It was the brainchild of Geraldine Gilliland, a Belfast-born chef who basically decided she wanted a real piece of home in California.
🔗 Read more: Getting Around Freetown Sierra Leone Map: What Your GPS Won't Tell You
She didn't just decorate it. She bought an actual pub in Newry, County Down, had it disassembled, shipped the whole thing through the Panama Canal, and put it back together on Main Street in 2002. That’s dedication. Or maybe just a bit of Irish madness. You can feel it when you walk in; the wood has that specific, heavy history that you can't fake with a kit from a restaurant supply warehouse.
People go there for the fish and chips, which are famous for a reason. They use a specific batter that stays crispy even in the humid beach air. But the real draw is the "Build a Burger" menu. It’s a weirdly American touch in a very Irish setting, but it works because they use Black Angus sirloin.
New Orleans: Where Soccer and Guinness Collide
If you head over to Banks Street in Mid-City, New Orleans, the vibe shifts. Finn McCool’s Irish Pub here is the undisputed headquarters for soccer fans in the South.
It’s gritty. It’s loud. It’s perfect.
They open at ungodly hours for Premier League and Champions League games. If you’re a fan of Celtic or Liverpool, you’ve found your people. The Guinness pour here is widely cited as the best in the city—and yes, there is a "proper" way to do it that involves a two-part pour and about 119 seconds of waiting.
📖 Related: Rocking on the River: Why This Summer Concert Series Still Hits Different
They also do this thing called a "Bloody McCool." It’s a standard Bloody Mary, but they top it off with a float of Guinness. Sounds weird? It is. Does it work? Absolutely. The bitterness of the stout cuts through the tomato juice in a way that makes you wonder why everyone isn't doing it.
The Canadian Franchise Factor
Now, if you’re in Toronto or Vancouver, you’re likely walking into a Fionn MacCool’s. This is the franchise side of the coin. Started in Hamilton, Ontario back in 1996, it’s now part of the Foodtastic group.
Is it "authentic"?
Purists might scoff because it’s a chain, but they do a decent job of keeping the "craic" alive. For those who don't know, "craic" (pronounced crack) is just the Irish word for fun, gossip, and good times. The Canadian locations focus heavily on the "Social Hour" and live music. They’ve got a massive footprint now, even landing in airports like Pearson International.
Australia’s Take on the Giant
Down Under, the name pops up again in Fortitude Valley (Brisbane) and the Gold Coast. These spots lean heavily into the "modern craic" philosophy.
They are massive venues.
In Brisbane, the Finn McCool’s on Brunswick Street Mall is a multi-level beast. They’ve got the traditional Irish Sunday Roast—which is basically a hug in food form—but they also embrace Aussie pub culture with $20 Parmys on Tuesdays. It’s a hybrid. It reflects the Irish diaspora in Australia: half traditionalist, half sun-soaked local.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Name
The biggest misconception is that these bars are all owned by the same guy named Finn.
Finn McCool (Fionn mac Cumhaill) is a mythical hunter-warrior. He’s the one who accidentally tasted the Salmon of Knowledge. In the stories, he’s a giant. It’s a "public domain" name, which is why you see it everywhere from Belfast to Brisbane.
💡 You might also like: Johnstown Pennsylvania: Why This Resilient City is More Than Just Its Floods
Because of this, the quality can vary wildly.
- Independent Spots: Usually have more "soul," unique menus, and local regulars who have been sitting in the same stool since 2002.
- Franchise Spots: More consistent. You know the Shepherd’s Pie will taste exactly the same in Alberta as it does in Ontario.
- The "Irish Pub" Kit: Some bars buy "authentic Irish pub" interiors from companies in Ireland that specialize in shipping pre-made bars globally.
Why the "Proper Pour" Actually Matters
You’ll hear people complain about how long it takes to get a drink at a real Irish bar.
"It’s just a beer."
No. If you’re at a place like the New Orleans Finn McCool’s, they treat the nitrogen-carbon dioxide gas blend like a science. The glass has to be clean. The tilt has to be 45 degrees. They fill it three-quarters of the way, let it settle until the black and tan surge turns solid black, and then top it off.
If a bartender hands you a Guinness in 30 seconds with a giant fizzy head, leave. You’re in the wrong place.
Actionable Tips for Your Next Visit
If you're planning to hit up one of these spots, don't just walk in and order a Bud Light. That’s a waste of a trip.
First, check the schedule. If there’s a major rugby or soccer match on, the bar will be packed. If you aren't there for the game, you'll be miserable. If you are there for the game, get there an hour early.
Second, look for the "Traditional" section of the menu. At the Santa Monica location, the Boxty (a type of potato pancake) is a sleeper hit. In the independent pubs, the daily specials usually involve whatever the chef felt like cooking that morning—often a stew that’s been simmering for eight hours.
Third, bring cash for a tip. While most places take cards (and some even charge a 3% fee for it), the bartenders at these high-volume Irish spots move fast. A couple of bucks on the bar for every round goes a long way in getting you noticed when the place is three-deep at the rail.
Ultimately, whether you're at a Fionn's in a Canadian mall or a Finn's in a New Orleans neighborhood, the goal is the same. Find a seat, grab a pint, and stop checking your phone. The "craic" doesn't happen on a screen; it happens with the person sitting on the stool next to you.
Your Next Steps:
- Verify the Location: Check if the specific "Finn McCool's" you're visiting is an independent pub or part of the Fionn MacCool's franchise to set your expectations for the menu.
- Check the Match Day Schedule: If you're going to the New Orleans or Brisbane locations, look up the Premier League or AFL schedules to avoid (or join) the sports crowds.
- Scan for "Weekly Deals": Many of these bars run specific "Irish Thursday" or "Sunday Roast" specials that offer significantly better value than the standard everyday menu.