If you walk toward the intersection of Bedford and Lorimer on a Saturday morning, you'll see it before you even smell the coffee. A swarm of people. Some are leaning against the brickwork of McCarren Park, others are checking their watches, but they’re all basically waiting for the same thing: a table at Five Leaves NYC. It’s been years—decades in "restaurant years"—and yet the momentum hasn't stopped.
Most places in Brooklyn burn bright for six months and then fade into the background of "just another bistro." Not this one.
The story of Five Leaves is inseparable from the late Heath Ledger. It’s common knowledge among locals that he was the visionary behind the project, working with Jud Mongell to create a space that felt like the nautical, sun-drenched cafes of Australia. He passed away before it opened in 2008, leaving a legacy that could have easily felt mournful or exploitative. Instead, it became a living tribute to a specific kind of laid-back, high-quality hospitality. Honestly, that’s why it works. It doesn’t feel like a "celebrity restaurant." It feels like a neighborhood anchor that just happens to be famous.
The Ricotta Pancake Myth and Reality
Let's talk about the pancakes. You’ve probably seen them on your feed. They’re thick. They’re topped with a massive honeycomb butter pat that looks like a small planet.
But are they actually good?
Yeah. They are. They’re fluffy in a way that feels structural, almost like a cake, yet they don't leave you feeling like you need a nap immediately afterward. The banana and maple syrup are standard, but the texture is where the kitchen earns its keep. People come to Five Leaves NYC specifically for this dish, and while food critics sometimes roll their eyes at "signature items," there is a reason this one hasn't left the menu. It's consistent.
But the real pro move? Skip the pancakes once. Try the Moroccan Scramble. It’s got that spicy merguez sausage and crushed avocado that hits a different note entirely. Or the Big Brekkie. It’s a massive plate of eggs, toast, hash browns, and mushrooms that reminds you why the Australian breakfast culture conquered the world. Australians don't just "do" breakfast; they treat it like an art form.
💡 You might also like: Exactly How Long Ago Was Feb 28th and Why Your Calendar Feels Weird
That Corner Location Is Everything
Geography is destiny in New York real estate. Five Leaves sits on a literal point, a triangular wedge where the streets converge. It’s got that European "piazza" vibe that is incredibly rare in the grid-heavy layout of Brooklyn.
Sit outside in the spring. You’ve got the park right there. You’ve got the foot traffic from the L and G trains. It’s the ultimate people-watching spot. But the interior is where the mood shifts. It’s cramped. It’s loud. It’s nautical. Think porthole windows, curved wood, and a marble bar that feels like it’s been there since the 1920s even though it hasn't. It’s cozy, but in that "I might accidentally elbow the person at the next table" kind of way. Some people hate that. In New York, we call it "atmosphere."
The Dinner Pivot
Most people think of this as a brunch spot. That’s a mistake.
When the sun goes down, the vibe changes completely. The lighting gets moody. The Five Leaves Burger—which comes with a fried egg and a slice of pineapple, because Australia—actually tastes better with a beer than a coffee. They use Grass-fed beef and a brioche bun that holds up under the weight of the beet and egg.
I’ve seen people complain about the pineapple. Look, it’s a polarizing choice. But if you’re going to eat at an Aussie-influenced spot, you have to embrace the fruit on the burger. It adds a hit of acidity that cuts through the fat of the beef. It works. Trust the process.
✨ Don't miss: The Pic of Rosa Parks on the Bus: What Most People Get Wrong About That Famous Photo
What Most People Get Wrong About the Wait Time
Here is the thing about the line at Five Leaves NYC: you can beat it.
If you show up at 11:15 AM on a Sunday, you’re looking at a 90-minute wait. Don't do that to yourself. The "sweet spot" is usually a random Tuesday at 10:00 AM or, surprisingly, very early on a weekend—around 8:30 AM.
The staff is seasoned. They’ve dealt with every kind of "influencer" and hungover local imaginable. They are efficient, even if they aren't always "bubbly." There’s a certain grit to the service that feels authentically New York. They aren't going to coddle you, but they will get your flat white to you faster than most places in the neighborhood.
The Cultural Impact on Greenpoint
Before Five Leaves, this specific corner of Greenpoint was pretty quiet. It was mostly Polish bakeries and quiet residential blocks.
When it opened, it acted as a catalyst. Now, you have places like Bernie's and various boutiques nearby, but Five Leaves was the pioneer. It shifted the center of gravity away from just the "main drags" of Manhattan Avenue and Franklin Street. It made the park the destination.
Is it "gentrified"? Of course. But it also feels like it has roots now. It’s survived the 2008 crash, the pandemic, and the constant churn of New York's fickle dining scene. That doesn't happen by accident. It happens because the food is actually seasoned correctly and the coffee—supplied by local roasters—is consistently top-tier.
Small Details That Matter
- The Flat White: Don't order a latte. Get the flat white. It’s the house specialty for a reason. Microfoam matters.
- The Oysters: They have a great raw bar selection that people overlook because they’re too focused on the truffle fries.
- The Bathroom: It’s tiny. It’s iconic. It’s part of the charm.
- The Bar: If you're a party of one, the bar is your best friend. You can usually skip the line entirely if a stool opens up.
The Verdict on the Hype
We live in an era where "TikTok food" often looks better than it tastes. Five Leaves is the antidote to that. It existed before TikTok. It existed before Instagram was the primary way people chose where to eat.
The hype is fueled by the history and the location, but the longevity is fueled by the kitchen. It’s a place where you can get a really good chopped salad or a heavy-duty burger and feel equally satisfied. It isn't trying to be "cutting edge" anymore. It’s trying to be a classic. And honestly? It’s basically achieved that status.
Whether you’re a tourist or someone who has lived in the 11222 zip code for a decade, there’s a comfort in knowing that the ricotta pancakes are going to taste exactly the same as they did five years ago.
How to Do Five Leaves Like a Local
If you want the best experience, forget the "perfect" brunch photo.
- Arrive early. I’m talking 8:45 AM. The light hitting the park is better then anyway.
- Order the Moroccan Scramble. Everyone else is getting the pancakes. Be the person with the savory, spicy eggs.
- Take a walk afterward. Loop around McCarren Park. Head down to the waterfront.
- Bring a book. If you’re sitting at the bar on a weekday, it’s one of the best places in the city to just "be."
- Watch the weather. If it’s slightly drizzling, the outdoor seating cleared out, but the awnings usually keep you dry. It’s the quietest the place ever gets.
The reality of Five Leaves NYC is that it’s a victim of its own success. It’s crowded because it’s good. It’s loud because people are happy to be there. If you can handle a bit of a wait and a tight seating arrangement, it remains one of the most essential dining experiences in Brooklyn. Just don't forget to tip your server well; they’re working harder than almost anyone else in the borough.