The NFL offseason is a beautiful, expensive lie. We all buy into it. Every March, fans refresh their feeds every six seconds, waiting for that one "Schefter Bomb" that will supposedly save their franchise. We see the graphic of a star wide receiver in a new jersey and think, Yeah, that’s the missing piece. But if you actually look at the history of free agency NFL signings, you’ll realize that the "winners" of March are almost never the winners in February.
It's basically a high-stakes poker game where half the players are drunk on cap space. Teams like the New England Patriots or the Washington Commanders often find themselves with $80 million to burn and a desperate need to show the fan base they’re "trying." So they overpay. They give a 30-year-old cornerback $18 million a year because he had three interceptions the season before. Then, by October, that same player is a step slow, the scheme doesn't fit, and the GM is looking for a way to restructure the contract.
Honestly, the real skill in free agency isn't finding the best player. It’s finding the best value.
The Great 2025 Market Correction
If you want to understand how free agency nfl signings actually work, look at the 2025 cycle. It was a weird one. Usually, it's a "full-crested swell," as some analysts put it, but 2025 was more of a ripple. Why? Because the smart teams realized the market was top-heavy and shallow. Instead of chasing ghosts, they pivoted.
Take the Seattle Seahawks. They made a move that everyone hated at first: trading Geno Smith to the Raiders and signing Sam Darnold to a three-year, $100.5 million deal. People laughed. They called it a "bridge to nowhere." But look at what happened. Darnold, finally in a system that didn't ask him to be a superhero, led Seattle to a 12-3 mark and a No. 1 seed. He didn't just play; he galvanized.
Then you have the Los Angeles Rams. They lost Cooper Kupp but landed Davante Adams for a two-year, $46 million deal. That’s elite talent for less than market value because they caught the market at the right time. They saw a veteran who wanted to win and a situation that needed a spark.
On the flip side, we saw the Denver Broncos go "all in" on defense. They grabbed Talanoa Hufanga and Dre Greenlaw from the 49ers. On paper? Incredible. In reality? Both were coming off major injuries. It’s that classic free agency trap: you’re paying for what a player was in their old jersey, not what they will be in yours.
Why Most Signings Fail
There is a specific kind of "new team" tax that most people ignore. It’s not just the salary. It’s the scheme fit.
- The System Shock: A pass rusher who thrived in a 3-4 wide-9 scheme might struggle if you ask him to play head-up in a 4-3.
- The Motivation Factor: Once a player gets that $50 million guaranteed, does the hunger stay the same? Some guys are "contract year" wonders.
- Locker Room Gravity: You can't just drop a $20 million-per-year diva into a young locker room and expect "culture" to happen.
We saw this with the New York Giants and Daniel Jones. After the Colts signed him to a one-year, $14 million "prove it" deal in 2025, the contrast was hilarious. In Indy, under Shane Steichen, Jones was actually decent—8-5 in 13 starts before the Achilles injury. Meanwhile, back in New York, the ghost of his $160 million contract still haunted the cap. The lesson? A quarterback is only as good as the guy calling the plays.
The 2026 Free Agency Forecast
As we look toward the 2026 window, the names are huge. George Pickens, Trey Hendrickson, and even Breece Hall could be looking for new homes. This is where the desperate teams start to sweat.
The Dallas Cowboys have a massive decision with Pickens. He’s ultra-talented, but he’s also... George Pickens. Do you pay him $30 million a year and hope he stays focused? Or do you let him walk and take the compensatory pick? Most teams choose the former because the fear of losing talent is stronger than the fear of overpaying.
The Indianapolis Colts are in a similar spot. They’ve got Daniel Jones coming off a torn Achilles and Trey Hendrickson likely hitting the market. Their GM, Chris Ballard, is known for being conservative, but with the window closing, he might have to finally "burn the boats."
The "Bargain Bin" Strategy
The best free agency nfl signings aren't the ones on the first page of the newspaper. They’re the "Year 2" guys.
Look at what the New England Patriots did in 2025. They spent $65 million more than anyone else, but their best move was arguably taking a flyer on a veteran like Stefon Diggs. Coming off a torn ACL, Diggs was "washed" according to the internet. Instead, he gave Drake Maye a legitimate No. 1 target and helped the Pats go from 4-13 to 12-3. That’s not just a signing; that’s a franchise-altering move.
You also have to watch the trades that happen during free agency. The Washington Commanders trading for Laremy Tunsil in 2025 was a masterclass. They didn't just sign a tackle; they bought insurance for Jayden Daniels. Tunsil had 19 penalties the year before, which lowered his trade value, but his "wall" status remained. Washington capitalized on a "down" year for a star.
Managing the Cap: The Invisible Game
We talk about players, but free agency is really about math. The "salary cap" is a soft suggestion for teams that know how to use void years.
🔗 Read more: CC Sabathia: Why the Big Leaguer Still Matters in 2026
Teams like the Saints have been "bankrupt" for a decade, yet they still find ways to sign people. It's basically a credit card with no limit until the bill eventually comes due. When you see a team announce a "5-year, $100 million" deal, you have to ignore that number. The only number that matters is the guaranteed money in the first three years.
If a guy has $40 million guaranteed, he’s on the team for two years. Period. If he plays well, he stays for year three. If he doesn't, he's a "cap casualty." It's a brutal, cold-blooded business.
Misconceptions About "Winning" the Offseason
People think that if you sign the most Pro Bowlers, you’re the best team. Tell that to the 2011 "Dream Team" Eagles. Or the various versions of the Jets over the last decade.
True success in free agency nfl signings comes from:
- Filling Holes, Not Chasing Stars: If you need a right guard, sign a solid right guard. Don't sign a star receiver and hope the guard situation "figures itself out."
- Age Management: Signing a 29-year-old to a five-year deal is a death sentence. You’re paying for the decline.
- The "Comp Pick" Game: The best teams (Ravens, Packers) let their mid-tier free agents walk. They get a free draft pick in return. They essentially trade a veteran they can't afford for a rookie they can control for four years.
Real Examples of Impact
Let’s talk about 2024 for a second, because the ripples are still felt. Saquon Barkley going to the Eagles. That was a move that defied the "don't pay running backs" rule. Why did it work? Because it wasn't just about Barkley. It was about what he did to the box for Jalen Hurts. By signing Saquon, the Eagles forced defenses to stop playing two-high safeties.
That’s a strategic signing.
Contrast that with the Jaguars signing Evan Engram in 2022. He was a "bust" in New York. He couldn't catch. He was a liability. But Doug Pederson saw a "big slot" receiver masquerading as a tight end. Now? Engram is a cornerstone of that offense. That’s the "renovator" approach to free agency—finding someone else’s "trash" and realizing it’s actually a Ferrari.
Actionable Insights for the 2026 Cycle
If you’re a fan trying to figure out if your team just got better or just got poorer, look for these three things:
- The "Why" Behind the Deal: Did they sign this guy because he's a star, or because he specifically fits what the coordinator wants to do? If it’s the latter, get excited.
- The Structure: Check the "Dead Cap" hit for year three. If the team can't get out of the deal without losing $20 million in cap space, it’s a high-risk gamble.
- The Age/Injury Curve: Avoid players over 30 who rely on "burst." They don't get faster in their 30s.
The draft is for building a foundation, but free agency is for building a roof. If you try to build the foundation with free agents, the house is going to collapse eventually.
Keep an eye on the "quiet" signings this year. The 2-year, $12 million deals for interior defensive linemen or "boring" centers. Those are the moves that actually win divisions while everyone else is busy tweeting about where the star wideouts are going.
Next Steps for Following the Offseason
- Monitor the Legal Tampering Window: This is where the real deals happen. By the time free agency "officially" starts, the best players are already gone.
- Track the "Void Year" count: If your team is using five void years on a 32-year-old, start worrying about 2028.
- Watch the Waiver Wire: Sometimes the best "free agent" isn't a free agent at all, but a June 1st cut that nobody expected.
Free agency isn't about being the loudest person in the room. It’s about being the one who still has money left when the lights go out.