Auburn football is a pressure cooker. It’s a place where you can beat Nick Saban three times and still find yourself looking for a job on a random Sunday in December. Honestly, that's the weird paradox of the Gus Malzahn record at Auburn. To the outside world, he was the giant slayer who kept the Iron Bowl interesting. To the Plains, he was the guy who could never quite find a rhythm after that magical 2013 run.
He didn't just coach there; he was the identity of Auburn for nearly a decade.
The Raw Numbers vs. The Reality
If you just look at the raw win-loss column, Malzahn’s tenure looks solid. He finished his eight-year stint (2013–2020) with a 68-35 overall record. That’s a 66% winning percentage. In the SEC, he went 38-27.
Most programs would kill for those numbers. Seriously. But Auburn isn't "most programs." They share a state with the greatest dynasty in the history of the sport, and they share a border with a Georgia program that turned into a juggernaut under Kirby Smart.
Malzahn's record is basically a tale of two different coaches.
There was the 2013 version: a mad scientist who took a 3-9 team and turned them into SEC Champions with the "Kick Six" and the "Miracle at Jordan-Hare." Then there was the later version, where the offense felt stagnant and the road record became a massive albatross.
What Actually Happened in the Big Games?
People talk about the "Gus Bus" like it was always breaking down, but he had a weird knack for winning the games that mattered most—at least at home.
He is the only coach to beat Nick Saban three times while Saban was at Alabama. Let that sink in. Not Kirby, not Dabo, not Brian Kelly. Gus. He got him in 2013, 2017, and 2019.
The Home/Road Split
This is where the record gets ugly. Gus was 15-5 on the road against most teams, but when he traveled to Tuscaloosa, Athens, or Baton Rouge?
- Record: 0-12.
- Result: He never won a road game against Alabama, Georgia, or LSU.
That stat right there is basically why he was eventually fired. You can't be the head coach at Auburn and go nearly a decade without winning a rivalry game on the road. It just doesn't fly with the boosters.
The 2017 Tease
If you want to understand the frustration of the Auburn faithful, look at 2017. That year, Auburn was arguably the best team in the country for a three-week stretch. They absolutely dismantled #1 Georgia 40-17. Two weeks later, they beat #1 Alabama 26-14.
💡 You might also like: AP Offensive Player of the Year: Why It’s Actually Better Than Winning MVP
They were the first team to ever beat two different #1 ranked teams in the same season. But then, they had to play Georgia again in the SEC Championship. Kerryon Johnson was hurt, the offense sputtered, and they lost 28-7. They followed that up with a loss to UCF in the Peach Bowl.
That’s the Malzahn era in a nutshell. High highs that made you think a Natty was coming, followed by confusing losses that left you scratching your head.
The Offensive "Wizard" Problem
Malzahn arrived as the guy who invented the high-pace, no-huddle spread that took over college football. When he was the Offensive Coordinator for the 2010 National Championship team with Cam Newton, he was untouchable.
But as a head coach, his record suffered because he couldn't develop a quarterback. After Nick Marshall left, it was a revolving door. Jeremy Johnson, Sean White, Jarrett Stidham, Bo Nix. Stidham had a great 2017, but the consistency wasn't there.
Fans got tired of the "boom or bust" nature of the offense. One week they’d drop 50 on a ranked team; the next, they’d struggle to gain 200 yards against a mediocre defense.
Why the $21 Million Buyout Happened
Auburn fired Gus in 2020 after a 6-4 season. It was a COVID year. It was weird. But the decision-makers decided that "good" was no longer "good enough."
The Accomplishments:
💡 You might also like: What Was the Score for the Giants Game? The Real Story Behind the Latest Result
- SEC Championship: 2013
- BCS National Championship Appearance: 2013
- SEC West Titles: 2013, 2017
- Bowl Record: 2-5 (This was a major sore spot)
His bowl record was frankly abysmal. Losing to Minnesota in the Outback Bowl or getting throttled by Oklahoma in the Sugar Bowl didn't help his case. When you’re paying a guy top-five money, you expect top-five results.
The Verdict on the Malzahn Era
Was he a failure? Absolutely not. He's one of the winningest coaches in Auburn history. He stayed out of trouble, recruited well enough, and provided some of the greatest memories in the history of the SEC.
But he was also the victim of his own early success. By nearly winning it all in Year 1, he set a bar that was impossible to maintain without an elite, NFL-caliber quarterback every single year.
Actionable Insights for CFB Fans:
- Evaluate the "Why": When looking at coaching records, always check the strength of schedule. Malzahn played more games against #1 ranked teams than almost anyone in history.
- The Saban Factor: Any coach in the SEC West from 2007–2023 has to be graded on a curve. Malzahn's 3-5 record against Saban is actually elite compared to the rest of the conference.
- Watch the Road Stats: If you're betting on or analyzing a team, the home/road split in rivalry games is the truest indicator of a program's "ceiling."
If you want to see what life after Gus looks like, just look at the struggles Auburn has had since 2021. It turns out that winning 8 or 9 games a year in the SEC West is a lot harder than it looks.