You probably have a pile of crewneck tees in your drawer. Everyone does. But honestly, most of them look like you just finished a gym session or rolled out of bed, especially after a few washes. That’s where the henley comes in. It is essentially the T-shirt’s more sophisticated, slightly more rugged older brother. If a polo is a bit too "country club" for your vibe and a T-shirt feels too lazy, henley shirts for men sit in that perfect middle ground.
The history of this shirt isn't just some marketing fluff. It’s functional. Originally, these were the standard uniform for rowers in the English town of Henley-on-Thames. The town has hosted the Royal Regatta since 1839. These athletes needed something breathable but without a collar that would flap in their faces while they were pulling oars. They needed a neckline they could pop open to vent heat. It was pure performance gear before "performance gear" was a buzzword.
Today, you see them everywhere from Ryan Gosling movies to the guy at the local coffee shop who actually looks like he tried. But there’s a trick to wearing them. If you get the fit or the fabric wrong, you end up looking like you’re wearing 19th-century long underwear. Nobody wants that.
What Actually Makes a Henley a Henley?
It’s all about the placket. That’s the little strip of fabric where the buttons live. Usually, you’ll see two to five buttons. Unlike a polo, there is no collar. It’s a clean, round neckline that provides a bit of visual interest that a standard crewneck just can't match.
💡 You might also like: University of Virginia Deadlines: How to Actually Get Your Application in on Time
When you’re looking at henley shirts for men, you’re basically choosing between two main camps: the base layer and the standalone piece. Some are thin, ribbed, and meant to stay under a flannel. Others are heavy, slub cotton or waffle knit, designed to be the star of the show. If you buy a paper-thin, tight white henley and wear it with nothing else, it’s going to look like an undershirt. That’s a mistake people make all the time.
The fabric matters more than the brand. You want something with "tooth."
The Fabric Breakdown (And Why It Matters)
Not all cotton is created equal.
Most cheap henleys use standard jersey cotton. It’s fine, but it’s flat. If you want to look like you know what you’re doing, look for slub cotton. Slub is woven with slight irregularities, giving it a textured, lived-in look. It catches the light differently. It feels premium.
Then there’s the waffle knit. This is the heavy hitter for fall and winter. The "waffle" texture creates little pockets of air that hold heat against your body. It’s incredibly masculine and hides a bit of a "dad bod" better than thin jersey does.
If you’re in a warmer climate, look for a linen-cotton blend. Linen is great for airflow, but 100% linen can be scratchy and wrinkle if you even look at it wrong. A blend gives you the breathability of linen with the structure of cotton.
Stop Buying the Wrong Size
Fit is where most guys fail. A henley should be "skimming," not "squeezing."
If the buttons are pulling and the fabric is gaping open between them, it’s too small. You look like you’re trying too hard. On the flip side, if the shoulder seams are drooping down your arms, you look sloppy. The seam should sit right on the corner of your shoulder bone.
The Sleeve Length Debate
You have two choices: short sleeve or long sleeve.
Short sleeve henleys are great for summer, but they can be tricky. They often look better on guys with a bit of arm definition. If the sleeves are too wide, your arms look like toothpicks. If you’re on the leaner side, long sleeves are actually your best friend. You can always push the sleeves up to your elbows. This creates a "bunched" look that adds bulk to your frame and looks effortlessly cool. Honestly, a long-sleeve henley with the sleeves pushed up is a top-tier look for almost any guy.
🔗 Read more: What Does Judeo Mean? Why This Little Prefix Is So Controversial Now
How to Style Henley Shirts for Men Without Looking Like a Pirate
There is a fine line between "rugged explorer" and "costume party."
The Casual Layer
Throw a long-sleeve henley under a denim jacket or a chore coat. Leave the top two buttons undone. It creates a "V" shape that draws the eye up to your face and makes your shoulders look broader. This is a classic move.
The Office-ish Look
Can you wear a henley to work? Maybe. If your office is "business casual," a high-quality, dark-colored henley (think navy, charcoal, or forest green) in a smooth pima cotton can work under a casual blazer. Just make sure the henley is crisp and not faded. If it looks like you slept in it, don't wear it to a meeting.
The Weekend Warrior
Pairs best with raw denim or olive chinos. Don't overthink it. A grey waffle-knit henley, some dark jeans, and a pair of leather boots is a foolproof outfit. It's been the "cool guy" uniform for decades because it works.
Color Theory for the Minimalist
You don't need a rainbow of colors. In fact, stick to the classics.
- Heather Grey: The most versatile. Shows off the texture of the fabric best.
- Navy: Slimming and looks a bit more "dressed up."
- Oatmeal/Off-White: Better than pure white. It looks more vintage and less like an undershirt.
- Olive Drab: Gives off a military/workwear vibe that looks great with blue jeans.
Avoid bright neon colors or overly saturated "mall brand" blues. They tend to make henleys look cheap.
The "Button Rule"
How many buttons should you actually undo?
One button is the safe bet. It looks relaxed. Two buttons is the "sweet spot" for most guys—it shows a bit of chest but keeps it tasteful. Three buttons? Now you’re entering romance novel territory. Unless you’re at the beach, keep the third button done up. And please, for the love of all things stylish, never button it all the way to the top unless you’re wearing it as a literal thermal undershirt under three other layers. It looks suffocating.
💡 You might also like: Fall Break Indiana University: Why the Timing Always Feels So Weird
Real Talk: Durability and Care
Henleys have more points of failure than T-shirts because of the placket. If you buy a cheap one, the neckline will sag after three washes, and the buttons will start hanging by a thread.
Pro tip: Always wash them on cold and, if you have the patience, lay them flat to dry. High heat in the dryer is the enemy of cotton. It shrinks the fabric unevenly, especially around the placket, which causes that annoying "waviness" where the buttons are. If you must use a dryer, use the lowest heat setting and take it out while it's still slightly damp.
What Most People Get Wrong
People think henleys are just for guys who spend eight hours a day in the gym. Not true.
Because of the vertical line created by the buttons, it actually has a slimming effect. It breaks up the vast expanse of fabric across the chest that you get with a T-shirt. If you have a larger midsection, a slightly heavier fabric like a thermal or waffle knit won't cling to your stomach the way a thin jersey tee does. It’s actually more flattering for a variety of body types than people realize.
The Premium vs. Budget Gap
Is it worth spending $80 on a shirt?
Sometimes. Brands like Buck Mason, Todd Snyder, or Merz b. Schwanen (who famously made the henley Bear wears in The Bear) use circular knitting machines or high-end slub fabrics. These shirts don't have side seams, which means they won't twist in the wash. They feel substantial.
However, you can find decent versions at places like J.Crew or even Gap if you're careful. The key is to check the weight of the fabric. If you can see your hand through the fabric when you hold it up to the light, keep moving. It won't last.
Moving Forward: Your Henley Action Plan
If you’re ready to upgrade your wardrobe and move past the basic tee, don't just go out and buy five of these at once. Start slow.
- Buy one mid-weight, long-sleeve henley in heather grey. It is the most forgiving color and style.
- Check the placket construction. Make sure the fabric behind the buttons feels reinforced. If it’s flimsy, the shirt will lose its shape.
- Experiment with layering. Try it under a flannel shirt or a bomber jacket. Leave the flannel unbuttoned to let the henley show.
- Mind the buttons. Practice the "two-button" rule and see how it changes your silhouette compared to a standard crewneck.
A good henley isn't just a shirt; it’s a tool. It makes you look like you put in effort without actually having to try that hard. It’s rugged, it’s historical, and honestly, it’s just more interesting than anything else in your casual rotation. Stop overcomplicating your style and let the buttons do the work for you.