You’ve seen the headlines, or maybe just noticed your favorite Reese’s pack feels a little lighter while costing a couple of quarters more. For investors holding The Hershey Company (HSY), the last eighteen months have been less of a "moment of goodness" and more of a persistent, slow-burn headache.
Honestly, the Hershey stock drop analysis isn't just about one bad quarter. It’s a perfect storm. We're talking about a collision between a historic cocoa crisis, a weary consumer base, and the brutal reality of how a "recession-proof" snack company handles a 300% spike in raw material costs.
The Cocoa Crisis No One Saw Coming
Most people think chocolate is simple. You buy beans, you make bars. But in 2024 and through much of 2025, the cocoa market basically broke. Prices for cocoa futures, which usually hover around $2,500 per metric ton, skyrocketed to an insane peak of over **$12,000 in April 2024**.
Why? Bad weather in West Africa—specifically Ivory Coast and Ghana, where 70% of the world's cocoa grows—led to abysmal harvests. Then came the speculators. Hedge funds jumped in, pushing prices to levels that made the actual "physical" cocoa market look like a side show.
By the time Hershey reported its Q3 2025 results, the damage was visible on the balance sheet. Even though sales actually grew by 6.5% to about $3.18 billion, their adjusted earnings per share (EPS) plummeted by a staggering 44.4% to $1.30. That’s a massive hit for a company that usually moves with the predictability of a clock.
Why the Stock Actually Tanked
Investors hate uncertainty. When Michele Buck, Hershey’s CEO, had to admit that gross margins were getting squeezed by over 800 basis points in late 2025, Wall Street hit the sell button.
It wasn't just the price of beans. It was the "demand destruction." Hershey tried to fight back. They implemented double-digit price hikes—lower double-digits, sure, but enough to make a family of four think twice about that extra bag of Kisses. They also leaned into "price pack architecture." That's the corporate way of saying shrinkflation.
Basically, the bars got smaller or the bags got lighter, but the price stayed the same (or went up).
According to Jefferies analysts, chocolate has become one of the most "concerning" segments in the snack world. While people are still buying potato chips and pretzels at a decent clip, they’ve started pulling back on chocolate. It turns out, when gas and rent are high, a $2.50 candy bar starts to look like a luxury rather than a daily habit.
Hershey Stock Drop Analysis: The 2026 Outlook
So, is the floor in? As of early January 2026, the stock has shown some signs of stabilizing, but it's still trading significantly below its 52-week highs of $195.
Here is the weird part. Cocoa prices actually started to drop in late 2025, falling back toward the $5,000 to $6,000 range. But that doesn't mean Hershey's costs drop tomorrow. Because of how these big companies "hedge" their purchases—buying contracts months or years in advance—they are currently locked into some of the most expensive cocoa ever grown.
The C-Store Struggle
A huge chunk of Hershey's business happens in convenience stores. Think about those impulse buys at the checkout counter.
- Foot traffic is down: People are stopping at gas stations less or just heading straight to the pump without going inside.
- Alternative snacks: Brands like Sour Strips (which Hershey recently acquired) and salty snacks are doing okay, but they don't have the same profit margins as a classic Hershey bar.
- Competition: Smaller, "healthier" brands are nibbling away at the edges of the market share.
What Most People Get Wrong
There’s a common myth that Hershey is just "greedy" and using inflation as an excuse. The numbers don't back that up. When your operating margin compresses from 20% down to 13.3%, you aren't profiteering—you're surviving.
✨ Don't miss: New shekel to euro: Why the Israeli currency is defying the experts in 2026
The company is currently in the middle of a massive "transformation program." They are trying to find $300 million in productivity savings. They’ve upgraded their ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) systems—which, by the way, caused some inventory headaches in 2024—and they are shifting more of their marketing budget toward non-chocolate items.
The Dividend Safety Net
If there is a silver lining, it's the dividend. Hershey has a long history of paying out, recently announcing a dividend of $1.37 per share. For "income" investors, the stock is starting to look "tasty" again because the valuation has dropped so much. The Forward P/E ratio is currently around 18-19, which is much lower than its five-year average of 23.
Actionable Insights for Investors
If you're looking at Hershey right now, you have to decide if you believe the cocoa crisis is a "one-off" or the "new normal" due to climate change.
1. Watch the Gross Margin: Don't look at the total sales. Look at the gross margin in the Q4 2025 and Q1 2026 reports. If that number starts to tick back up toward 40%, the recovery is real.
2. Cocoa Harvest Reports: Keep an eye on weather reports in Cote d'Ivoire. If the 2026 "mid-crop" looks good, cocoa prices could slide further, providing a massive tailwind for Hershey's 2027 earnings.
3. The Salty Snack Pivot: Hershey isn't just a chocolate company anymore. Their success with Dot's Homestyle Pretzels and SkinnyPop is crucial. If these segments continue to grow at double digits, they can offset the weakness in chocolate.
4. Valuation Check: At $150–$160, the stock is arguably undervalued based on historical norms. However, at $190+, you’re paying for a recovery that hasn't fully arrived yet.
The bottom line? Hershey isn't going anywhere. It’s a 130-year-old titan. But the days of easy, "set it and forget it" growth are on pause until they can figure out how to sell chocolate to a cash-strapped public using the most expensive ingredients in history.
Monitor the upcoming February earnings call specifically for "2026 guidance." If management projects a double-digit EPS rebound, that could be the catalyst that finally breaks the downward trend. For now, it’s a game of patience and watching the rain in Africa.