Finding a place to crash in Manhattan is usually a nightmare of trade-offs. You either pay five hundred bucks a night to stay in a room the size of a walk-in closet near Times Square, or you end up so far uptown that you spend your entire vacation underground on the C train. But honestly, the Holiday Inn Midtown West New York—specifically the one sitting on 57th Street—occupies this weirdly perfect middle ground that most tourists just sort of drive past on their way to the bigger name hotels.
It’s not flashy. It’s not trying to be a boutique art gallery with a lobby that smells like expensive sandalwood and pretension.
It’s just a solid, predictable anchor in a neighborhood that is surprisingly quiet for being right in the middle of the chaos. If you’ve ever walked down 57th toward the Hudson River, you know the vibe changes. The frantic energy of Fifth Avenue starts to bleed into something more residential and "real." This hotel, formally known to the locals and frequent flyers as the Holiday Inn New York City - Midtown 57th Street, taps into that exact energy.
The Location Realities of 57th Street
People see "Midtown West" and they assume they’re going to be stepping over Elmo performers the second they walk out the front door. Not here. You’re actually tucked away closer to the border of Hell’s Kitchen and the Upper West Side.
Think about it.
You’re a ten-minute walk from Central Park. You’re also a ten-minute walk from the Lincoln Center. If you want to see a show or watch the Philharmonic, you aren't fighting the cross-town traffic that makes NYC drivers lose their minds. You just walk. It’s basically the ultimate "cheat code" for people who want the New York experience without the New York headache.
But let’s be real for a second. The 57th Street location is a bit of a hike from the subway. Most people don’t mention that. You’ve got the Columbus Circle station nearby—which is great because it’s a major hub with the A, B, C, D, and 1 trains—but you are going to be putting some miles on your sneakers. If you’re traveling with kids or someone who isn't a fan of walking ten blocks just to get to the platform, that’s something you have to weigh against the price.
What the Rooms are Actually Like
Don’t expect gold-plated faucets. This is a Holiday Inn. But it’s a New York Holiday Inn, which means the standards are generally higher than a roadside stop in the Midwest.
The rooms are surprisingly spacious for Manhattan. Seriously. In a city where "cozy" is code for "you can touch both walls at the same time," having enough floor space to actually open a suitcase is a luxury. Most rooms come with the standard setup: a desk, a flat-screen, and those pillows that are weirdly labeled "soft" and "firm" as if we can't tell the difference ourselves.
One thing that genuinely matters: the windows.
Because you’re a bit further west, some of the higher floors actually get a decent view of the city skyline or glimpses of the Hudson. It’s not the Top of the Rock, but it’s better than staring at a brick wall or an air conditioning duct, which is what you get at many "budget" hotels in the Theater District.
💡 You might also like: Queen Mary 2 Cruises: Why the World’s Last Ocean Liner Still Divides Travelers
The noise levels are also surprisingly manageable. Since 57th is a major thoroughfare, you’ll hear the occasional siren—it’s New York, after all—but you don’t get that constant, vibrating roar of Times Square. It’s more of a low-frequency hum.
Why Hell’s Kitchen is Your Best Friend
Staying at the Holiday Inn Midtown West New York means you are effectively a resident of Hell’s Kitchen for the week. This is arguably the best food neighborhood in the city right now. Forget the overpriced tourist traps on 7th Avenue.
Walk south.
Go to 9th Avenue. You’ll find everything from authentic Ethiopian at Addis to some of the best Thai food in the country at places like Pure Thai Cookhouse. You can eat like a king for twenty bucks. Most people staying at the fancy hotels in Midtown East are stuck eating $45 club sandwiches in their hotel lobbies because they’re too tired to find anything else. You? You’ve got a literal world of flavor three blocks away.
- Pro tip: Check out the local bakeries on 9th early in the morning. Sullivan Street Bakery isn't too far if you’re willing to walk, and their pizza bianca is worth the trek.
- The Coffee Situation: There’s a Starbucks nearby, obviously, but look for the smaller independent spots. The hotel coffee is... fine. It’s brown liquid that provides caffeine. But New York coffee is a whole different beast.
The Business Traveler’s Perspective
If you’re here for work, you’re probably looking at the proximity to the Javits Center or the various corporate towers on the West Side.
The hotel has a business center, but honestly, the Wi-Fi is the real hero here. It’s generally reliable enough for Zoom calls, which isn't always a given in older NYC buildings. The "Midtown West" branding is a big draw for people attending conferences. You’re close enough to be convenient but far enough away that you can actually decompress after a day of networking and bad hors d'oeuvres.
🔗 Read more: Converting 200 US to Pounds: How Exchange Rates Actually Work When You Are Traveling
One thing that’s kinda cool: the rooftop pool.
Yes, a pool in Manhattan. It’s seasonal, obviously, because New York winters are brutal, but if you’re here in July or August, it is a lifesaver. It’s not an Olympic-sized lap pool. You aren't training for the trials here. It’s more of a "stand in the water with a drink and try not to melt" type of pool. Still, having that option in the middle of a concrete jungle is a massive flex.
Managing Your Expectations
Let’s talk about the "Holiday Inn" stigma. Some people think it’s basic.
It is.
But basic is good when you’re in a city as expensive and unpredictable as New York. You know the bed is going to be clean. You know there will be an iron in the closet. You know the staff is used to dealing with stressed-out travelers who lost their luggage at JFK.
There’s a certain comfort in the lack of surprises. When you stay at a "trendy" hotel, you might end up with a glass-walled bathroom or a light switch that requires a PhD to operate. At the Holiday Inn Midtown West, the light switch is on the wall. The shower works. The staff is efficient.
Sometimes, that’s exactly what you need after a six-hour flight.
Hidden Costs and Real Savings
New York will nickel and dime you to death. You’ve got the room rate, then the city tax, then the state tax, and then—the dreaded "destination fee" or "amenity fee."
🔗 Read more: Rota Northern Mariana Islands: Why You’ve Probably Never Heard of Nature’s Little Secret
Make sure you read the fine print when booking. Most hotels in this area have started tacking on these fees, which usually cover things like the gym, the pool, or a "credit" for the bar. It’s annoying, but it’s the industry standard now.
However, you save money here in ways you don’t realize. There’s a CVS and a few grocery stores nearby (like Westerly Market or Whole Foods at Columbus Circle). You can grab snacks, water, and breakfast items to keep in your room. If you’re at a hotel in the heart of Midtown, you’re paying $9 for a bottle of Evian. Here, you can live like a normal person.
Logistics You Need to Know:
- Parking: Just don't. Unless you absolutely have to, driving into Midtown West is a mistake. If you do bring a car, expect to pay a fortune for the garage. Use the apps like SpotHero to find a better deal nearby, but seriously, take the train or a cab.
- The Hudson River Park: If you’re a runner, this is the best part of staying west. You can run down to the water and have miles of uninterrupted path along the river. It’s the best view in the city and it's totally free.
- The Gym: It’s functional. It’s got a few treadmills and some free weights. It’s not Equinox, but it’ll get the job done if you’re trying to burn off that late-night pizza.
The Verdict on Holiday Inn Midtown West New York
Is it the most romantic hotel in the world? No.
Is it where you’d stay for a 50th-anniversary blowout? Probably not.
But for a family trip, a business hop, or a solo mission to see as many Broadway shows as humanly possible, it’s arguably one of the most practical choices on the map. You get the reliability of a global brand, the space of an older building, and a location that lets you see the "real" Manhattan without being trampled by a tour group.
It’s about balance. You’re trading the "prestige" of a Park Avenue address for the utility of 57th Street. And in a city that usually tries to take every dollar you have, that’s a trade most smart travelers are happy to make.
Next Steps for Your Trip:
- Check the Seasonal Schedule: If the rooftop pool is a dealbreaker for you, call the front desk directly to confirm opening dates. It’s usually Memorial Day to Labor Day, but weather can shift that.
- Map Your Transit: Download the MYmta app. Since you’re a bit of a walk from the major lines, knowing exactly when the M57 bus or the 1 train is coming will save you twenty minutes of standing on a windy corner.
- Book Direct or Compare: Check the IHG website against the major booking engines. Often, being an IHG One Rewards member (which is free) gets you a slightly better rate or at least late checkout, which is huge when you have a 6:00 PM flight.
- Explore West 57th: Don't just head toward Times Square. Walk toward the Pier 94 area or visit the Intrepid Sea, Air & Space Museum. It's much closer to your home base than you think.
Stay smart. Don't overpay for "vibes" when you can have comfort and a better location for half the price. New York is waiting outside the door—you just need a good place to sleep so you’re ready for it.