Look, we've all been there. You’re scrolling through Netflix, it’s a Tuesday night, and you see Forest Whitaker’s face. You think, "Hey, he's great, this looks like a solid apocalyptic thriller." Then you hit play on How It Ends 2018, and two hours later, you’re staring at the credits feeling like you just got ghosted by a movie.
It’s been years, and people still talk about this film, but usually not because they loved it. They talk about it because the ending is essentially a giant middle finger to the audience. It’s a road trip movie that runs out of gas ten feet from the finish line.
Directed by David M. Rosenthal, the film dropped during that weird mid-2010s era where Netflix was greenlighting almost anything with a high-concept premise. The setup is actually decent. Theo James plays Will, a guy trying to get back to his pregnant wife, Sam, in Seattle after a mysterious "event" shuts down the electrical grid and causes massive seismic chaos. He’s joined by his father-in-law, Tom (played by Whitaker), who is a grumpy ex-military type who clearly hates Will.
What Actually Happens in How It Ends 2018?
The plot is a standard survivalist trek. They drive from Chicago to the Pacific Northwest. Along the way, they deal with the usual post-apocalyptic tropes: gas thieves, crooked cops, and the breakdown of social order. The chemistry between James and Whitaker is actually the best part of the movie. Whitaker brings a gravitas that the script honestly doesn't deserve.
But then, the movie starts to fray. Tom dies from injuries sustained during a shootout and a car crash. This is a huge turning point because Whitaker was carrying the emotional weight of the film. Once he’s gone, Will is left to finish the journey alone. He eventually makes it to Seattle, which is a smoking ruin. He finds Sam at a remote cabin with a neighbor named Jeremiah.
Here is where it gets weird. Jeremiah is clearly unhinged. He’s convinced the disaster wasn't natural—he’s talking about conspiracies, EMPs, and targeted attacks. He’s also clearly in love with Sam. Will realizes the threat isn't just the volcanoes or the earthquakes; it's the guy standing in the kitchen.
👉 See also: Lyrics Us Regina Spektor: Why This Song Still Hits Harder Than We Realized
Will kills Jeremiah in self-defense after a brief standoff. You think, "Okay, here we go, the final showdown with the elements." But no. A massive pyroclastic flow—essentially a wall of fire and ash—starts chasing them. They jump in the car, drive fast, and the screen fades to black.
That’s it.
Why the "Event" is Never Explained
One of the biggest frustrations with How It Ends 2018 is the total lack of world-building regarding the disaster itself. Was it an alien invasion? A series of tectonic shifts? A nuclear strike?
The movie stays strictly in Will’s perspective. While that can be a great narrative device (think Signs or War of the Worlds), it fails here because the characters don't seem to care about the "why" enough to make the audience care. We see flashes of news reports early on mentioning "seismic events," but the GPS stops working, the phones go dead, and the mystery just sits there, rotting.
Director Rosenthal has mentioned in interviews that the ambiguity was intentional. He wanted to focus on the "mystery and the unknown." But there’s a fine line between a "mysterious atmosphere" and "we didn't have the budget to show the monsters." The film leans heavily into the latter. It feels like a pilot for a TV show that never got picked up, leaving us with a prologue instead of a complete story.
The Production Reality vs. The Fan Theories
If you go down the Reddit rabbit hole, you’ll find some wild theories. Some people think the entire thing was a military experiment. Others suggest it was a pole shift.
The reality is likely more mundane. Screenwriter Brooks McLaren’s script was on the "Black List" (the industry list of the most liked unproduced scripts) back in 2010. Originally titled How It Ends, it was praised for its tension. But translated to the screen, that tension evaporates because there’s no payoff.
Critics were not kind. It sits with a dismal score on Rotten Tomatoes, mostly because of that ending. It’s a "Netflix Original" in the most pejorative sense of the term—high production values, recognizable stars, but a narrative vacuum at the center.
- The Budget: Estimated at around $20 million.
- The Location: Mostly filmed in Winnipeg, Canada, standing in for the American Midwest.
- The Cinematography: Peter Flinckenberg actually did a great job. The wide shots of the desolate highways are gorgeous.
Despite the technical competence, the movie feels hollow. It’s a movie about a journey where the destination doesn't matter, but the journey itself isn't interesting enough to justify the lack of a destination.
Breaking Down the Final Scene
In those final seconds, Will and Sam are driving away from a giant cloud of ash. Will says, "I'm not stopping," and she says, "I know."
It’s meant to be a moment of resilience. Love conquers the apocalypse, right? Wrong. It feels unearned. We don't know if they have enough gas. We don't know if the whole world is gone. We don't even know if their baby is going to be born into a world that can support life.
It’s an ending that tries to be "artistic" by being "abrupt." But usually, an abrupt ending works when the character’s internal journey is complete. Here, Will hasn't really changed. He started the movie wanting to save Sam, and he ended the movie... still trying to save Sam. There's no arc. There's just a car.
Why We Keep Watching These Movies
So why did How It Ends 2018 trend so hard when it came out? And why does it still pop up in "What to Watch" lists?
Netflix’s algorithm is a powerful beast. It knows we love survival stories. There is something primal about watching someone navigate a world without iPhones or Starbucks. We like to imagine what we would do. Would we be the guy with the gun, or the guy who gets his car stolen in the first ten minutes?
This movie preys on that "prepper" instinct. It gives us just enough detail—the water purification, the siphoning of gas, the choosing of backroads—to keep us engaged. It’s "competence porn" until it isn't.
But when a movie asks for two hours of your time and refuses to explain its own premise, it breaks the social contract between the filmmaker and the viewer. You can have an open ending, but you need to give the audience enough pieces to finish the puzzle in their own heads. Rosenthal didn't give us the pieces; he just threw the box away.
Is It Worth a Rewatch?
Honestly? No.
Unless you are using it as a case study for how to build tension without a payoff, there are better ways to spend your time. If you want a road trip apocalypse movie that actually has something to say, watch The Road. If you want a mystery that keeps you guessing, watch Leave the World Behind.
The latter is a great comparison. Leave the World Behind also has an ambiguous ending, but it works because the film is about the uncertainty itself. How It Ends 2018 tries to be an action-thriller and a philosophical meditation at the same time, and it fails at both.
Actionable Insights for the Frustrated Viewer
If you’ve already watched it and you’re feeling that lingering annoyance, here is how to process it:
- View it as a genre exercise: Look at the technical aspects. The sound design and the car stunt sequences are actually top-tier for a streaming movie.
- Read the Black List script: If you can find the 2010 script online, it offers a bit more context that didn't make the final cut.
- Check out David M. Rosenthal’s other work: He directed A Single Shot, which is a much tighter, better-paced thriller. It proves he has the chops, even if this specific project missed the mark.
- Accept the ambiguity: The "event" is likely a massive, multi-fault line seismic rupture coupled with volcanic activity. In the film’s logic, the "why" doesn't matter because the characters can't stop it anyway.
The legacy of this film isn't the story it told, but the conversation it started about how streaming services produce content. It’s the poster child for the "Netflix Middle," where a movie is just good enough to keep you from clicking away, but not good enough to remember fondly.
If you're looking for closure, you won't find it on the screen. The ending of How It Ends 2018 is simply that the world is messy, scary, and sometimes things just stop without a reason. Just like the movie.
To get the most out of your next sci-fi binge, try looking for films where the director has explicitly discussed the lore in post-release interviews. It helps fill the gaps that the budget couldn't cover. Alternatively, stick to limited series where the extra runtime allows for the world-building this movie so desperately needed.