If you’ve ever sat through a heated dinner table debate about immigration, you’ve probably heard two completely different stories. One side says undocumented people are a drain on the system. The other says they’re basically propping up our retirement. Honestly, the truth is tucked away in some pretty dry actuarial tables from the Social Security Administration (SSA), and it’s a lot more fascinating than the talking points suggest.
So, let's get into the nitty-gritty: how much do illegal immigrants pay into social security, and where does that money actually go?
The short answer is billions. Every single year. According to the most recent data from the American Immigration Council and the SSA's Chief Actuary, Stephen Goss, undocumented workers contributed roughly $26.2 billion to the Social Security Trust Fund in 2023 alone. If you widen the lens to include all federal, state, and local taxes, that number jumps to about $89.8 billion.
The Mystery of the "Earnings Suspense File"
You might be wondering: how do you even pay into a system if you don't have a legal Social Security Number (SSN)? It feels like a glitch in the matrix, but it's actually a massive, clerical reality called the Earnings Suspense File (ESF).
When an employer sends a W-2 to the SSA, the system tries to match the name and SSN to its records. If they don't match—maybe because the worker used a made-up number, a borrowed one, or an expired one—the money doesn't just vanish. The IRS still takes the tax. The SSA just puts the record into a "suspense file" because they can't figure out who it belongs to.
By 2022, this file had ballooned significantly. In fact, over the last decade, unauthorized workers have funneled over $100 billion into the Social Security system. Think about that for a second. That's a massive "donation" to a pot of money they’ll almost certainly never be able to touch.
How much do illegal immigrants pay into social security exactly?
The numbers have been climbing. Back in 2010, the estimate was around $12 billion. By 2022, it hit $25.7 billion. By 2023, as we mentioned, it reached $26.2 billion.
Why the jump?
✨ Don't miss: What Did The Federal Reserve Do Today: The Real Story Behind the Powell Headlines
- Inflation and Wages: As wages go up, the 6.2% payroll tax (and the 6.2% paid by the employer) results in a larger dollar amount.
- Labor Participation: Undocumented people are disproportionately of working age. While the U.S.-born population is getting older and heading toward retirement, these workers are right in the middle of their prime earning years.
- Compliance: Many use an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN) to file taxes. Even though an ITIN doesn't give you the right to work, the IRS wants its cut of any income earned on U.S. soil.
Basically, the system is designed to take the money first and ask questions about eligibility later. Or, in this case, never.
The Solvency Lifeline Nobody Talks About
We’ve all heard the warnings that Social Security is "going broke" by 2033 or 2034. It’s a terrifying thought for anyone planning to retire. But here's the twist: the SSA’s own actuaries admit that the system would be in even worse shape without the contributions of undocumented workers.
Stephen Goss, the guy who essentially runs the numbers for Social Security, has pointed out that the presence of "other-than-legal" immigrants has a net positive effect on the trust fund's health. Because these workers pay in but don't take out, they provide a "pure profit" margin for the system.
If you suddenly removed every undocumented worker from the economy, the Social Security Trust Fund would actually hit insolvency sooner. We’re talking years earlier. They are essentially subsidizing the retirements of U.S. citizens.
Can They Ever Get the Money Back?
This is where it gets kinda sad. For the vast majority: no.
🔗 Read more: Nasdaq Composite Index Ticker: Why This One Symbol Rules Your Portfolio (and Your Stress Levels)
To collect Social Security, you generally need 40 "credits" (about 10 years of work) and you must be a U.S. citizen or a "qualified alien" with legal status. Since undocumented immigrants don't have that status, the money they’ve paid in just stays in the fund. It pays for current retirees—your grandma, your neighbor, maybe your parents.
There are tiny exceptions. If someone later gains legal status, they can sometimes "reclaim" those earnings if they can prove they were the ones who did the work. But it’s a paperwork nightmare. Most people never even try. They just view the tax as the "cost of living" in the U.S. and a way to show "good moral character" in case there’s ever a path to citizenship in the future.
The Impact of 2025/2026 Policy Shifts
It's 2026 now, and the landscape is shifting. Increased enforcement and changes in immigration patterns are starting to show up in the data. If the number of undocumented workers drops significantly, that $26 billion annual boost starts to shrink.
For a system already teetering on the edge, losing a $26 billion-a-year "silent partner" is a big deal. It forces a conversation most politicians want to avoid: if we don't have this influx of payroll taxes, do we raise taxes on everyone else, or do we cut benefits for retirees?
What This Means for Your Retirement
It’s easy to get lost in the politics, but the economic reality is pretty cold and calculated. The Social Security system relies on a high ratio of workers to retirees. Currently, that ratio is shrinking. We have fewer kids, and the Baby Boomers are retiring in droves.
Undocumented workers are, ironically, one of the few things keeping that ratio from collapsing entirely. They are young, they work hard, and they don't draw benefits.
Actionable Insights for the Informed Citizen
If you're trying to make sense of the "drain vs. gain" argument, keep these points in your back pocket:
- Check the Suspense File: When people say immigrants don't pay taxes, they're usually ignoring the billions sitting in the SSA’s unmatched records.
- Solvency is a Math Problem: Immigration (both legal and illegal) is currently acting as a cushion for the 2033 insolvency deadline.
- The Benefit Gap: Remember that paying into the system is not the same as being eligible for it. The U.S. government is one of the few entities that can legally take "insurance premiums" and then deny the "claim" based on the applicant's status.
If you’re worried about the future of your own Social Security, the best thing you can do is stay on top of the annual Trustees Reports. These reports break down exactly how much the system is taking in versus paying out. Understanding that a significant chunk of that "taking in" comes from people who will never see a dime of it might just change how you look at the whole debate.
The next time you hear someone ask how much do illegal immigrants pay into social security, you can tell them the truth: they pay enough to keep the system breathing for a few more years, without ever asking for a receipt.