When the first teaser for the Wicked movie dropped, the internet basically had a collective meltdown over the vocals. But for those who had been following Cynthia Erivo for years, that earth-shattering riff at the end of "Defying Gravity" wasn't a surprise. It was an inevitability. To understand the shift in her career, you have to look at Cynthia before and after Wicked because we aren't just talking about a change in tax brackets. We are talking about the transition from a "prestige actor" to a "global icon."
It’s wild to think about now, but there was a time when Cynthia wasn't a household name. She was a powerhouse in the theater world, sure, but she wasn't someone whose face was plastered on popcorn buckets at every AMC in the country.
💡 You might also like: Black Dorothy Wizard of Oz: What Most People Get Wrong
The Broadway Blueprint: Cynthia Before Wicked
Cynthia Erivo didn't just appear out of thin air. Before she ever put on the green makeup, she was already halfway to an EGOT. Most people first really "met" her in 2015 when she arrived on Broadway for the revival of The Color Purple. She played Celie. If you saw it, you know. It wasn't just a performance; it was a spiritual experience. She won the Tony for Best Actress in a Musical in 2016, and honestly, the competition didn't stand a chance that year.
Before the Wicked machine took over her life, Cynthia was defined by a specific kind of grit. She took on roles that required immense physical and emotional stamina. Think about Harriet. Playing Harriet Tubman in 2019 earned her two Oscar nominations—one for acting and one for the song "Stand Up." She was the "serious" actress. The one you called when you needed someone to carry the weight of history on their shoulders.
But Hollywood is weird. Even with an Emmy, a Grammy, and a Tony, she was still in that "if you know, you know" category of stardom. She did Bad Times at the El Royale, which was a cult hit but didn't light the box office on fire. She did Genius: Aretha on National Geographic. She was consistently working at the highest level of her craft, yet she lacked that one massive, pop-culture-defining moment that turns a star into a supernova.
The Casting That Changed the Stakes
When Jon M. Chu announced she would be playing Elphaba, the vibe shifted. This wasn't just another movie role. This was the role. Wicked is a billion-dollar Broadway juggernaut. It’s a foundational text for theater nerds and casual fans alike. Casting a Black woman as Elphaba for the film adaptation was a massive statement, though fans of the stage show pointed out that the character has been played by many women of color over the years.
Still, the pressure was immense. Cynthia wasn't just following Idina Menzel; she was creating a version of Elphaba that had to live for decades on film. The transformation started long before the cameras rolled. She leaned into the physicality. If you follow her on social media, you saw the workouts. The strength training. The vocal maintenance. She treated Elphaba like an Olympic event.
The Green Era: Cynthia After Wicked
So, what does Cynthia after Wicked actually look like? It looks like total saturation.
📖 Related: Why City of Life and Death is the Most Brutal War Movie You've Probably Never Seen
The most obvious change is the scale. We’re seeing her move from mid-budget dramas to the center of a massive marketing machine. You can’t go into a Target without seeing her face. But it’s deeper than just merchandising. The "after" version of Cynthia Erivo is an actor who has finally fused her theater roots with blockbuster sensibilities.
One major shift is how the industry perceives her "bankability." Before this, there might have been questions about whether a Broadway star could anchor a massive franchise. Those questions are dead now. The success of Wicked—and the sheer gravity of her performance—has positioned her as a leading lady who can command a $150 million budget.
A Shift in Style and Presence
Her red carpet presence has also evolved. Cynthia has always been a fashion risk-taker—think of her 2020 Oscars dress or her penchant for incredible nail art. But during the Wicked press tour and the subsequent "after" period, her style became a form of storytelling. She stayed in "character" via her wardrobe, often sporting shades of green or architectural pieces that felt otherworldly.
She also became a more vocal advocate for representation in high-budget fantasy. In interviews following the film's release, she’s been candid about the importance of being a Black Elphaba. She’s talked about the nuances of the "outsider" narrative and how her own lived experience informed the character. This isn't just a "job" anymore; it’s a platform.
Why the "After" Matters for the Industry
The trajectory of Cynthia before and after Wicked serves as a blueprint for other Broadway stars. For a long time, there was a ceiling for "theater people" in Hollywood. You could be a great character actor, but you rarely got the keys to the kingdom.
🔗 Read more: Why The Evil Dead Still Terrifies Us Forty Years Later
Cynthia broke that.
By delivering a performance that was both technically perfect (those F5s were no joke) and emotionally grounded, she proved that theater-trained actors are actually the best equipped for the rigors of modern filmmaking. The "after" isn't just about her; it's about the doors opening for the next generation of stage performers.
- The EGOT Watch: She is now closer than ever to that elusive 'O'. With the momentum from Wicked, her next few projects are going to be under a microscope for awards season.
- Musical Renaissance: Her success has essentially greenlit more big-budget musical adaptations. Studios are looking for the "next Cynthia," but she’s a singular talent.
- The Voice: Expect a major solo album. While she has released music before, her "after" status gives her the kind of leverage with labels that most artists dream of.
The Reality of the Transition
It wasn't all easy. The transition involved dealing with the toxic corners of the internet that push back whenever a classic character is reimagined. Cynthia handled this with a level of grace that was frankly exhausting to watch. She didn't engage with the trolls; she just did the work.
In the "after" phase, she seems more protected but also more visible. It's a weird paradox. She’s more famous, which means she has more privacy needs, yet her influence on culture is at an all-time high.
Actionable Insights for Following Her Career
If you’re trying to track the long-term impact of this career shift, watch her production company, Edith’s Daughter. The real "after" story isn't just her acting; it’s the stories she chooses to produce. She is moving into a space where she isn't just waiting for the right role to come along—she’s creating them.
- Watch her indie picks: Usually, after a big franchise, actors do a "one for them, one for me" cycle. Look for her to return to gritty, small-scale dramas to flex her acting muscles.
- Pay attention to the nails: It sounds trivial, but Cynthia uses her nail art to signal themes of her upcoming projects. It’s a long-running Easter egg for fans.
- Listen to the arrangements: In future live performances, notice how she’s changed her vocal styling. The Elphaba role requires a specific kind of "belt" that often changes a singer’s technique permanently.
Cynthia Erivo has effectively reset the bar. The "before" was impressive. The "after" is legendary. She’s no longer just a Broadway star who made it to Hollywood; she’s a Hollywood titan who happens to have a Tony. And honestly? The industry is better for it.
To truly keep up with her evolution, monitor her upcoming collaborations with director Jon M. Chu and her forays into fashion. The Wicked era isn't a destination for her; it’s a launchpad. If you want to see where the next decade of film musicals is going, just follow Cynthia. You’ll find her exactly where she belongs: right at the center of the spotlight.
Next Steps for Fans:
- Revisit the Source: Watch the 2016 Tony Awards performance of "I'm Here" to see the raw power she had before the Hollywood polish.
- Track the Credits: Follow Edith’s Daughter (her production company) to see which stories she is prioritizing in this new chapter.
- Compare the Vocals: Listen to the Wicked soundtrack alongside her 2021 album Ch. 1 Vs. 1 to hear the technical growth in her voice.