You've probably been doing them since second-grade gym class. The whistle blows, someone grabs your ankles, and you start cranking your torso up and down like a human hinge. It's the classic image of fitness. But honestly? Most people are just vibrating their hip flexors and straining their cervical spine while calling it an "ab workout." If you want to know how to do a sit up correctly, you have to forget almost everything you saw in those old Rocky montages.
It isn't just about getting your chest to your knees.
Actually, the sit up has fallen out of favor in many elite training circles. Dr. Stuart McGill, a world-renowned expert in spine biomechanics at the University of Waterloo, has famously pointed out that the repetitive flexing of the spine—especially with poor form—can put unnecessary "crushing" forces on your intervertebral discs. Think of it like bending a paperclip back and forth. Eventually, things might snap. But that doesn't mean the move is useless. It just means you've gotta be precise.
The Anatomy of a Movement That Actually Works
Most people think the "up" part of the sit up is the goal. It's not. The goal is controlled spinal flexion and hip hinge integration. When you lie flat on your back, your core is at its longest. As you begin to curl up, your rectus abdominis—that "six-pack" muscle—contracts to pull your ribcage toward your pelvis.
🔗 Read more: Kaiser Permanente Bayhill Medical Offices: What to Expect Before Your Appointment
But here is the catch.
Halfway through the movement, your abs actually stop being the primary mover. Once your lower back leaves the floor, your hip flexors (specifically the psoas and iliacus) take over to pull your torso toward your thighs. If you have a weak core and strong hip flexors, you'll likely "yank" yourself up using your legs, which arches your lower back and causes that nagging ache people complain about after a workout.
Setup is everything
Don't just flop down on the carpet. Find a surface with a bit of give, like a yoga mat. Lie down with your knees bent at roughly a 45-degree angle. If your feet are too close to your butt, you'll cramp up. Too far away? You won't have the leverage to finish the rep.
Now, let's talk about your hands. This is where everyone messes up. Please, for the love of your spine, do not interlace your fingers behind your head. When you get tired, you will instinctively pull on your skull. This forces your chin to your chest and puts a massive amount of strain on your neck. Instead, try lightly touching your temples with your fingertips, or better yet, cross your arms over your chest so your hands rest on opposite shoulders.
Why most people fail at doing a sit up correctly
The "ego" sit up is the enemy of progress. You know the one—where the person uses massive momentum, swinging their arms like they're trying to take flight, just to get their shoulders off the ground.
That's just physics, not fitness.
To do it right, you need to initiate the move from your sternum. Imagine there’s a string pulling your chest toward the ceiling, not toward your knees. Exhale forcefully as you rise. This "forced exhalation" engages the transverse abdominis, the deep internal corset of your core. If you hold your breath, you create internal pressure that can actually push your abdominal wall outward—the opposite of the flat, strong stomach most people are aiming for.
- The Initial Tuck: Before you even move, press your lower back into the floor. This "hollow body" start ensures your abs are "on" before the work begins.
- The Peel: Think of your spine like a roll of Scotch tape. You want to peel it off the floor, one vertebra at a time. Head first, then shoulders, then mid-back.
- The Pause: At the top, don't just relax. Keep the tension.
- The Descent: This is the most underrated part. Most people just gravity-drop back to the floor. Don't do that. Fight gravity. Lower yourself slowly. This eccentric phase—the lengthening of the muscle under tension—is where the real muscle growth happens.
Common Mistakes and How to Kill Them
You might feel a "click" in your hip. Or maybe your feet keep flying off the ground. These are signals.
👉 See also: Seaweed for Thyroid Health: What Most People Get Wrong About Iodine
If your feet keep lifting, it's a sign that your hip flexors are overactive and your deep core is sleeping on the job. Some trainers suggest tucking your feet under a heavy dumbbell or a couch. While this helps you finish the movement, it actually makes the "hip flexor dominance" problem worse. If you can’t do a sit up without anchoring your feet, you're better off practicing "crunches" or "dead bugs" until your core strength catches up.
Then there's the neck. If your neck hurts more than your abs, you're "leading with the chin." Keep a space about the size of a tennis ball between your chin and your chest throughout the entire range of motion.
Variation: The Butterfly Sit Up
Crossfitters love this one, and for good reason. By bringing the soles of your feet together and letting your knees fall outward (the butterfly position), you effectively "turn off" the hip flexors. This forces your abs to do almost 100% of the work. If you find standard sit ups too easy or if your hips are always tight, try this version. It's a humbling experience.
Is the Sit Up Actually Dangerous?
We have to talk about the "anti-sit up" movement in the fitness world. For about a decade, trainers were terrified of them because of the "spinal flexion" issue mentioned earlier. The fear was that the repetitive bending would lead to herniated discs.
Is it true? Sorta.
If you have a pre-existing lower back injury, or if you spend 8 hours a day slumped over a desk in a "C-shape," adding 100 sit ups to your day might be the straw that breaks the camel's back. In those cases, "spinal stability" exercises like planks or Bird-Dogs are objectively better. However, for a healthy person, the spine is meant to move. Flexion is a natural human movement. The key is volume and intensity. You don't need to do 500 reps. You need to do 15 reps that are so slow and controlled they make your muscles shake.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Core Session
Instead of just hitting the floor and praying for the best, follow this specific progression to master the movement.
Step 1: The Floor Press
Lie down. Press your lower back so hard into the floor that a friend couldn't slide a piece of paper under it. Hold that for 30 seconds. If you can't do this, you shouldn't be doing sit ups yet.
Step 2: The Negative-Only Sit Up
Start at the top (seated position). Slowly—and I mean over a count of 10 seconds—lower yourself to the floor. Focus on touching each part of your back to the mat individually. Use your hands to pull yourself back to the top and repeat. This builds the "eccentric" strength needed for the full move.
Step 3: The Janda Sit Up
This is the gold standard. Try to do a sit up while someone tries to pull your feet away from you, or while you actively try to dig your heels into the floor and pull them toward your butt. This creates "reciprocal inhibition," which basically tells your hip flexors to shut up so your abs can work.
Step 4: Integration
Incorporate the movement into a circuit, but never do it first. Warm up your core with planks or glute bridges. When you finally get to the sit ups, do 3 sets of 12-15 reps. Focus on the "peeling" sensation. If you feel your lower back arching, stop the set. The quality of the rep is the only thing that matters.
The sit up isn't dead. It's just been misunderstood. Stop treating your body like a pendulum and start treating your spine like a precision instrument. By slowing down and focusing on the "peel" rather than the "pull," you'll actually build the core strength you've been chasing without the morning-after back ache.
Next Training Phase
To truly round out your core, don't just work on "flexion" (the sit up). You also need to work on "rotation" (Russian twists) and "anti-extension" (planks). A balanced midsection is one that can both move and resist movement. Focus on mastering the slow-motion sit up for the next two weeks before adding any weight or speed to the movement. This builds the neurological pathways necessary for long-term spinal health.