Everyone has that one friend. You know, the one who shows up to the party with a crumpled piece of paper, a Sharpie, and a look of pure chaos in their eyes. They’re trying to draw a grid. It’s always crooked. They realize halfway through they only drew nine columns instead of ten. Honestly, it’s a mess. If you want to avoid being that person, you need a blank Super Bowl square sheet that actually works.
Squares are basically the lifeblood of a Super Bowl party. It doesn’t matter if you know the difference between a nickel defense and a dime package. You could think a "tight end" is just a result of hitting the gym too hard. It literally doesn't matter. Once those numbers are drawn, you’re locked in. You’re suddenly screaming at the TV because a missed extra point just landed you a hundred bucks. It's the great equalizer.
But here’s the thing: most people do it wrong. They print a sheet, they scribble some names, and then they realize they don’t actually know how the payout structure should work or why the numbers 2, 5, and 8 are basically the kiss of death.
Why the Grid Layout Actually Matters
A standard blank Super Bowl square sheet is a 10x10 grid. That’s 100 squares. Simple, right? One team takes the vertical axis, the other takes the horizontal. You sell the squares first—this is the golden rule. Never, ever draw the numbers before the squares are full. If you do, people will just cherry-pick the 7s and 0s, and you’ll be left holding a bunch of 5s that nobody wants to buy.
When you’re looking at a sheet, you need enough space in each box for a name. If the boxes are too small, and "Christopher" tries to squeeze his name in next to "Alexander," the whole thing becomes unreadable by the third quarter. I’ve seen fistfights start over whether a line passes through a "J" or a "T." Okay, maybe not fistfights, but definitely some very heated passive-aggressive comments over the bean dip.
The Psychology of Picking Your Spots
People have superstitions. Some folks like to "staircase" their picks diagonally. Others try to cluster them in the middle like they’re playing Battleship. Since the numbers are drawn randomly after the names are in, your physical position on the grid doesn't technically matter for your odds. However, there is a certain psychological comfort in being "in the corner." Don’t ask me why; it’s just a thing.
The Brutal Truth About the Numbers
Once the grid is full, you pull numbers 0 through 9 out of a hat (or a bowl, or a discarded beer cup) and assign them to the columns and rows. This is where the tension starts.
If you end up with 7 for the AFC team and 0 for the NFC team, you’re basically a king. Those are the prime numbers. Think about it. Touchdowns are 7 points with the kick. Field goals are 3. Scores like 7, 10, 14, 17, and 20 are common.
On the flip side, if you get 2 or 5, you’re probably toast. How often does a score end in a 2? A safety? A missed extra point followed by a very specific sequence of events? It’s rare. According to historical NFL data analyzed by sites like Pro Football Reference, the number 2 appears in final scores less than 4% of the time. It's the "dead zone" of the blank Super Bowl square sheet.
🔗 Read more: Ice Hockey on TV: Why It’s Suddenly So Hard to Find Your Favorite Team
But that’s the fun. It’s a gamble. You pay your five or ten bucks, and you pray you don't get the "bad" numbers.
Payout Structures That Don't Suck
The most common way to handle the pot is a 25/25/25/25 split. You pay out at the end of the first quarter, halftime, third quarter, and the final score.
Some people like to weight the final score more heavily. For example:
- 1st Quarter: 10%
- Halftime: 30%
- 3rd Quarter: 10%
- Final Score: 50%
This keeps the stakes high at the end. There’s nothing worse than the game going into overtime and the person who won the third quarter has already checked out because they know they aren't winning again.
Common Mistakes to Avoid Like the Plague
Don't use a pencil. Just don't. Someone will "accidentally" smudge a name or try to move their square when the host is in the kitchen getting more wings. Use a permanent marker.
Also, make sure the team names are clearly labeled. Are the 49ers the top row or the side column? Write it in big, bold letters. If you're using a blank Super Bowl square sheet from the internet, they usually have a spot for this. Use it.
Another huge mistake? Not collecting the money upfront. "I'll Venmo you later" is the biggest lie in the history of sports betting. By the time the fourth quarter rolls around and that person has lost, their motivation to send that $20 vanishes into thin air. Collect the cash or verify the Venmo before you even think about drawing those numbers.
What if You Don't Fill All 100 Squares?
This happens a lot, especially at smaller gatherings. You’ve got a blank Super Bowl square sheet and only 60 squares are sold. You have two choices.
One, you can let people buy multiple squares at a discount. "One for $5, three for $12." This usually clears the board fast.
Two, you can "black out" the unsold squares. If the score hits a blacked-out square at the end of a quarter, the money just rolls over to the next period. This can lead to a massive final payout, which honestly adds a lot of drama to the game. It’s kinda like a lottery rollover.
Digital vs. Paper: The Great Debate
In 2026, everyone wants to do things on their phones. There are plenty of apps where you can run a squares pool. They’re efficient. They do the math for you.
But honestly? They’re boring.
There is something tactile and nostalgic about a physical blank Super Bowl square sheet taped to the wall. It becomes a focal point of the party. People hover around it. They groan when a touchdown changes the "owner" of the current score. You can't get that same energy from a digital spreadsheet.
If you really want to be "tech-adjacent," print out a clean PDF version. Don't try to draw it by hand unless you have a ruler and a lot of patience. A printed sheet looks professional and keeps the "communal" feel alive.
Why This Tradition Won't Die
Super Bowl squares have been around for decades. It's one of the few forms of gambling that is socially acceptable in almost every circle. Your grandma might play. Your boss might play. It’s low-stakes (usually) and requires zero skill.
It also keeps people invested in boring games. If the score is 31-10 and the game is a total blowout, nobody cares about the fourth quarter. Except for the person who needs a field goal to change the score to 31-13 so they can win the final $50. It keeps the TV on.
Setting Up Your Sheet: A Step-by-Step Reality Check
First, get your sheet. You can find a blank Super Bowl square sheet online easily, or just make one in Excel and print it.
Next, set the price. Be realistic. If it's a casual party, $2 or $5 is plenty. If it's a high-roller situation, maybe $50 or $100. Just make sure everyone is comfortable.
Then, the names go in. No specific order. Just pick a box.
Once the boxes are full—and only then—draw the numbers. Use two sets of 0-9. One set for the top, one for the side.
Tale a photo of the completed sheet. This is crucial. It prevents any "discrepancies" later on. Post it in the group chat. Transparency is your friend here.
Handling the "Final Score" vs. "End of 4th Quarter"
This is a niche but important rule. If the game goes to overtime, does the "Final Score" winner get the prize, or does the "End of 4th Quarter" winner?
Usually, the "Final Score" includes overtime. If the game ends 24-24 and goes to OT, the person holding 4-4 for the 4th quarter gets nothing (unless you have a specific 4th quarter prize). The person holding the numbers for the final overtime score takes the pot. Clarify this before the game starts. It saves lives.
Actionable Steps for Your Party
- Print two copies. One for the wall, one for you to keep as a backup in case someone spills salsa on the main one.
- Bring a variety of markers. Different colors make it easier to distinguish names if you have a lot of players.
- Assign a "Banker." One person handles the money and the payouts. Don't let five different people touch the pot.
- Explain the rules once, loudly. Before the kickoff, explain when the payouts happen and how the numbers work.
- Watch the score, not just the game. Keep a running tally next to the sheet so people know who is currently "winning" throughout the quarter.
Getting a blank Super Bowl square sheet ready is the easiest way to make sure your party isn't just people eating chips in silence. It creates instant rivalries and instant heroes. Just remember: if you get the 2 and the 5, just enjoy the wings and accept your fate.
The most important part of the whole process isn't the gambling—it's the fact that everyone, even the people who don't know what a "first down" is, has a reason to scream at the television. That is the true spirit of the Super Bowl.
Check your printer ink now. Don't wait until Sunday morning when the stores are closed and you're stuck trying to draw 100 perfect squares with a leaking ballpoint pen.
Next step: download a high-quality PDF version of the grid, grab a clipboard, and start selling those squares as soon as your guests walk through the door.