You’re driving up Route 414 on the east side of Seneca Lake, and honestly, it’s easy to get overwhelmed. The Finger Lakes region is basically a sea of tasting rooms. You see one barn, you’ve seen them all, right?
Not really.
There’s this spot called Idol Ridge Winery & Alder Creek Distillery in Lodi that sits high enough on the ridge to make you feel like you’re actually looking down on the rest of the world. It’s a massive timber-framed lodge. It feels less like a corporate tasting room and more like that wealthy uncle’s lake house—the one who actually has good taste in bourbon.
Most people pull in because they want a glass of Riesling with a view. They’re not wrong. But if you leave without seeing what’s happening on the distillery side, you’re missing the actual plot.
🔗 Read more: Anchorage Alaska Time Zone: Why Your Body Clock Is Probably Wrong
The Martin Family and the "Garage" Origins
It’s kinda wild to think this place started in a garage. Back in 1999, the Martin family wasn't even doing grapes; they were beekeepers making mead. That eventually turned into Montezuma Winery, and then in 2013, they opened Idol Ridge Winery.
They didn't just want to copy-paste their first success. They wanted something "vinifera-focused." That’s fancy talk for European-style grapes like Cabernet Franc and Chardonnay, which can be notoriously moody in the New York climate.
The Martins are still running the show. It’s a family business, and you can feel it in the service. You’ll probably run into someone like Nick—he’s a legend in the reviews for actually knowing his stuff without being a wine snob—who will walk you through why a 2022 Sparkling Riesling (their "String of Pearls") is a big deal.
Why Alder Creek Distillery is More Than a Side Quest
Most Finger Lakes wineries treat spirits like an afterthought. A dusty bottle of vodka in the corner. Alder Creek Distillery is different. It’s built into the same lodge, but it has its own identity.
They use locally farmed grains. That matters. When you’re sipping their Smoked Bourbon Whiskey, you’re tasting New York corn and rye that didn't travel halfway across the country.
- The Smoked Bourbon: It’s got that caramel and brown sugar nose, but the finish has a hit of smoke that isn't too aggressive. It’s perfect for a Manhattan, but honestly, just drink it on the rocks.
- Nashi Pear Brandy: This one is a sleeper hit. It’s won "Best of Class" before. It’s bright, clean, and smells exactly like a fresh pear—not that artificial candy scent.
- Bourbon Cream: Think of it as the local answer to Bailey’s, but made with New York State cream and their own bourbon.
The bottles have these cool wooden labels. It fits the whole lodge aesthetic perfectly. It’s the kind of bottle you actually want to keep on your bar cart after it’s empty.
The "Local Culture" Series: Getting Weird (in a Good Way)
Phil Plummer, the head winemaker, is a bit of a mad scientist. While they do the classic stuff really well—their Dry Riesling Smith Brothers Farm Reserve is a winner—the Local Culture series is where things get interesting.
They call it "Ferment to be Wild."
This is their playground for natural-inspired wines. We're talking wild-fermented series, Pinot Noir Pét-Nat, and Ramato. If you’re used to grocery store wine, this might taste "funky" at first. That’s the point. It’s raw, it’s adventurous, and it’s a direct reflection of what the Finger Lakes can do when you stop trying to make it taste like California.
What to Actually Expect When You Show Up
Look, 2026 has changed how some places operate, but Idol Ridge Winery & Alder Creek Distillery keeps it pretty straightforward. They’re open daily from 11:00 AM to 5:00 PM.
Don't just walk in with a group of 15 people and expect a seat. If you have 12 or more, you must call ahead. It’s just common courtesy, plus they need to set up the space.
💡 You might also like: Weather for Orlando Florida April: What Most People Get Wrong
The Tasting Experience:
A standard wine tasting is usually six samples. It’s about $10.00, which is a steal considering the view you’re getting. But the pro move? The flights.
- Mimosa Flights: Huge hit for the brunch crowd.
- Cocktail Flights: Using the Alder Creek spirits.
- Wine Slushies: Yes, they have them. No, they aren't "too sweet" if you get the right one.
They also do this thing with homemade fudge and "Cheeky Monkey" tomato garlic oil. It sounds like a weird combo, but once you start dipping crackers into that oil while sipping a dry red, you’ll get it.
Staying Overnight: The Cabins
One thing people often overlook is that you can actually sleep here. They have these private Airbnb cabins on-site.
Imagine waking up, walking out onto a porch, and seeing Seneca Lake before the mist has even cleared. You’re right on the ridge. You’re 20 minutes north of Watkins Glen, so you’re close enough to the gorge trails to be a "hiker," but far enough away to avoid the tourist trap noise.
Is it Pet Friendly?
Yes. Very.
Unlike some places that make you tie your dog to a tree outside, Idol Ridge is famously pet-friendly inside the tasting room. Just make sure your dog isn't a jerk. If they’re well-behaved and leashed, they’re welcome to hang out while you work your way through a flight of spirits.
📖 Related: Kimpton Fitzroy London Russell Square London UK: Why This Hotel Is Actually Worth the Hype
Common Misconceptions
Some people think because they have fruit wines (under the Fossenvue brand) and fudge, they aren't "serious" about wine.
That’s a mistake.
Their 10 Years Rooted Blanc de Noir pulled a 90-point rating from Wine Enthusiast. They take the technical side of winemaking very seriously. They just don't think you should have to be miserable or bored while you drink it. It’s a "mostly fun" atmosphere, but the liquid in the glass is high-tier.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
- Time it right: If you want the "Sunset Lakeview" experience, aim for late afternoon, but remember the tasting bar closes 15 minutes before the doors shut at 5:00 PM.
- Beyond the Riesling: Everyone drinks Riesling in the Finger Lakes. Try the Saperavi. It’s an ancient Georgian grape variety that thrives here. It’s deep, dark, and will stain your teeth, but it’s worth it.
- The Gift Shop is Legit: It’s not just cheesy magnets. They have local bites and unique gifts that actually make sense for the region.
- Check the Calendar: In early 2026, they’ve been running "Mocktail Month" events. Even if you’re the designated driver, they have high-quality non-alcoholic options that aren't just plain soda.
- Distance Check: It’s located at 9059 NY-414, Lodi, NY. If you’re staying in Geneva or Watkins Glen, it’s a straight shot, but the road can get deer-heavy at dusk. Drive slow.
The Finger Lakes wine trail is a long game. You can’t do it all in a day. But if you’re looking for the intersection of high-end spirits, experimental wines, and a view that actually justifies the phone storage you’ll use taking photos of it, this ridge is where you want to be.
Next Steps for Your Trip:
- Check Availability: If you're planning a weekend, check the Martin family website for cabin vacancies early—they fill up months in advance during the summer and fall.
- Reserve for Groups: Call (607) 582-7773 if you're bringing a crew of 12 or more to ensure you actually get a spot at the bar.
- Pick a "Hero" Bottle: When you visit, ask for the "Local Culture" series. It’s the best conversation starter to bring back to a dinner party.