If you walk down Bond Street in NoHo and don’t instantly feel like you’ve accidentally tripped into a 19th-century Umbrian wine cellar, you might be at the wrong place. We're talking about Il Buco. It started as an antique shop in 1994. Honestly, you can still feel that vibe in the floorboards. But people don't go there for the rustic chairs anymore; they go for the il buco nyc menu, which manages to be both incredibly stubborn and wildly seasonal at the same time. It’s a tightrope walk.
The menu doesn't try to impress you with foam or molecular gastronomy. It’s loud. It’s olive oil-drenched. It’s essentially a love letter to the Mediterranean, written by people who clearly spend a lot of time in Italian farmhouse kitchens.
The Raw Truth About the Il Buco NYC Menu
You have to start with the bread. People overlook it. Don't. It’s served with their signature olive oil, which they actually import themselves from Sicily. It’s peppery. It hits the back of your throat in a way that tells you it’s the real deal, not the watered-down stuff you find at the grocery store.
The il buco nyc menu is famously split into the traditional Italian structure: stuzzichini (snacks), antipasti, primi, and secondi. But here’s the kicker—the daily specials often outshine the printed staples. Chef Justin Smillie really put this place on the map years ago, and while the kitchen has seen different hands since, that DNA of "respect the ingredient" hasn't budged an inch.
Take the Salsiccia. It’s house-made pork sausage. Sounds simple? It isn't. It’s usually paired with something bitter, like broccoli rabe or pickled peppers, to cut through the fat. It’s aggressive in its seasoning. You’ll want a glass of something red and funky from their massive wine list to wash it down.
Why the Crispy Artichokes Are a Non-Negotiable
If you look at the table next to you, they have the artichokes. The table behind you? Artichokes. They are fried alla Giudia style. Super crispy on the outside, almost like a potato chip, but the heart remains creamy. It’s a texture game.
They usually serve them with a squeeze of lemon and maybe some shaved bottarga if you’re lucky. It's one of those dishes that defines the il buco nyc menu experience. If they ever took it off, there would probably be a small riot on Bond Street.
The Pasta Problem (And How to Solve It)
Pasta at Il Buco is a serious affair. We aren't talking about huge bowls of spaghetti and meatballs. This is refined.
- Lasagnette: This isn't your grandma's lasagna. It’s often open-faced or loosely layered, featuring hand-torn pasta.
- The Risotto changes constantly. One week it’s earthy with porcini mushrooms; the next, it’s bright with Meyer lemon and bay scallops.
- Bigoli: A thick, extruded pasta that has some serious chew. They often do it with a duck ragu or a simple cacio e pepe variation that ruins all other versions for you.
The portion sizes are "European." That’s a polite way of saying they are smaller than the massive heaps you get at tourist traps in Little Italy. You’re paying for the quality of the flour and the precision of the cook. Each strand is coated, never drowning in sauce. It’s balanced. Basically, it’s how pasta is supposed to taste when the chef actually cares about the grain.
The Legend of the Roasted Short Ribs
Let’s talk about the heavy hitters on the il buco nyc menu. The roasted short ribs are legendary. They are slow-cooked until the collagen has basically turned into silk, then finished in the wood-burning oven to get that charred, crusty exterior.
It’s served family-style. Or you can eat it yourself if you’re having a particularly rough week. No judgment here. The meat just falls away from the bone with zero effort. It’s usually accompanied by something bright, like a gremolata or a sharp vinegar-based slaw, because let’s be honest, you need that acidity to survive the richness of the beef.
It’s expensive. You’re going to look at the check and blink twice. But then you remember the taste of that wood-fire smoke infused into the fat, and suddenly, the price makes sense. It’s one of the most consistent "big plates" in Manhattan.
Fish, Fire, and Salt
If you aren't in the mood for a meat coma, the whole roasted fish is the move. They typically use Mediterranean Bronzino or whatever is freshest at the Fulton Fish Market that morning. It’s stuffed with herbs—rosemary, thyme, lemon slices—and roasted whole.
👉 See also: The Maryland Crab Cake Recipe Most People Get Wrong
There is something visceral about picking meat off a whole fish in a room that looks like a medieval tavern. It feels right. The skin gets salty and blistered. The flesh stays moist because it’s cooked on the bone. It’s primitive and sophisticated at the same time.
Navigating the Wine List Without Looking Like an Amateur
The wine list at Il Buco is intimidating. It’s thick. It’s mostly Italian, focusing on small producers you’ve probably never heard of. You could try to guess, or you could just talk to the sommelier.
They have stuff hidden in that basement (which, by the way, is rumored to be the inspiration for Edgar Allan Poe’s "The Cask of Amontillado") that you can't find anywhere else. If you like orange wine, this is your Mecca. They were doing skin-contact whites way before it was trendy in Brooklyn.
Ask for something from Friuli. Or a bold Etna Rosso if you're having the short ribs. The staff actually knows their stuff—they aren't just reciting a script. They’ve tasted these bottles.
The Vibe vs. The Food
Let’s be real: part of why the il buco nyc menu tastes so good is the atmosphere. The lighting is dim. The candles are dripping. The tables are close together—sometimes uncomfortably so. You will hear the conversation of the fashion editors sitting next to you.
But that’s part of the New York charm. It’s intimate. It’s bustling. It feels like a secret, even though everyone knows about it. The service can be "relaxed," which is code for "don't expect to be in and out in an hour." This is a place for lingering. You start with a Negroni, you end with a Grappa, and somewhere in between, you lose track of time.
Dessert: Don’t Skip the Panna Cotta
Usually, dessert is an afterthought in Italian spots. Not here. The panna cotta is wobblier than a newborn calf. It’s barely held together, which is exactly how it should be. They top it with seasonal fruit—think balsamic-soaked strawberries in the summer or roasted pears in the winter. It’s a clean finish to a meal that is otherwise quite heavy on the olive oil and salt.
Practical Steps for Your Visit
- Reservations are a nightmare: If you want a prime-time slot on a Friday, you better be on Resy the moment they drop. Or, try going for a late lunch. The vibe is different—sunlight streaming through the front windows—but the food is just as good.
- The Wine Cellar: If you have a group, ask about the private dining in the wine cellar. It’s spooky, cool, and arguably the best dining room in the city.
- Dietary Restrictions: They are surprisingly accommodating for a place that loves gluten and meat. Just tell them. They’ll whip up a vegetable-centric version of a pasta that will make you forget the meat was ever an option.
- Order the Special: Seriously. If the server mentions a specific crudo or a limited-run pasta with truffles, get it. The kitchen uses the specials to play with ingredients that are at their absolute peak for like, forty-eight hours.
- Check the Olive Oil: You can often buy a bottle of the oil they serve at the start of the meal. It’s a great souvenir that actually gets used, unlike that "I Heart NY" shirt in your closet.
The il buco nyc menu isn't trying to reinvent the wheel. It’s just trying to show you how good the wheel can be when it’s made by hand and doused in top-tier fat. It’s a Bond Street staple for a reason. Go for the history, stay for the short ribs, and definitely, definitely don't skip the artichokes.