You’ve probably felt that weird, sinking feeling in your gut when you try to ask for a raise or pitch a new idea to a skeptical team. It’s that tiny voice in the back of your head whispering that you're being "pushy" or "manipulative." We've been conditioned to think that getting our way requires a silver tongue or some Machiavellian master plan. Honestly? That's total nonsense.
The truth is, influence is your superpower, but most of us treat it like a dusty relic we only pull out for "big moments." We act like it’s a finite resource or a dirty trick. In reality, influence is the undercurrent of every single human interaction you have, from convincing your toddler to eat broccoli to getting a Venture Capitalist to write a check for seven figures. If you aren't conscious of it, you aren't just "being humble"—you're being invisible.
The Resistance Myth and Why Logic Fails
Most people think that if they just present the best data, they’ll win. They bring spreadsheets to a knife fight.
Yale School of Management professor Zoe Chance, who literally wrote the book on how influence is your superpower, points out a massive flaw in how our brains process requests. She talks about the "Gator brain" versus the "Judge brain." Your Gator brain—that primal, reactive part of you—is the gatekeeper. It’s lazy. It wants to say "no" because "no" is safe and requires zero calories to process.
When you lead with heavy logic and 50-slide PowerPoints, you’re trying to talk to the Judge. But the Judge doesn’t even get a vote if the Gator has already slammed the door shut.
Have you ever noticed how some people just seem to get a "yes" without even trying? It’s not because they’re smarter. It’s because they stop triggering the "Resistance" reflex in others. They make the "yes" feel like the path of least resistance. It’s a subtle shift from pushing your agenda to pulling people toward a shared goal.
Think about the "Door-in-the-Face" technique. It’s a classic psychological phenomenon where you ask for something huge and ridiculous, get rejected, and then ask for what you actually wanted. The other person feels a subconscious need to concede because you "compromised." It sounds manipulative, but it’s actually just how human empathy and reciprocity are wired.
Why Your "Likeability" is Overrated
Being liked is great. It’s comfortable. But if you think being the "nice guy" at the office is the same as having influence, you’re in for a rude awakening.
Influence isn't about being a people-pleaser. In fact, people-pleasing often erodes your power because it signals that your opinion is for sale. Real influence comes from perceived competence and trustworthiness.
Take a look at the research by Amy Cuddy and Susan Fiske. They found that humans judge each other based on two traits: warmth and competence. If you’re high warmth but low competence, people like you but they don't follow you. They pity you. If you’re high competence but low warmth, they envy you and wait for you to fail. The superpower happens when you hit that sweet spot in the middle.
The Power of the "Pause" and Other Small Tweaks
Sometimes, the most influential thing you can do is absolutely nothing.
🔗 Read more: Lowe's Current Stock Price: What Most People Get Wrong
Silence is terrifying for most people. We feel the need to fill the gaps, to over-explain, to justify our existence. But in a negotiation, the person who speaks less usually holds the cards. When you make a request—say, asking for a specific budget—and then you stop talking, you force the other person to process the reality of that request.
If you start rambling ("...but I mean, if that's too much, we could also look at..."), you are literally negotiating against yourself. Stop doing that.
Another tiny tweak? Change your "buts" to "ands."
"I hear what you're saying, but we don't have the budget" sounds like a dead end. It’s a confrontation.
"I hear what you're saying, and we need to figure out how to fund it" is a collaboration.
It’s such a small linguistic pivot, yet it changes the entire chemistry of the room. You’ve moved from being an obstacle to being a partner. That’s how influence is your superpower in the day-to-day grind. It’s not about the big speeches; it’s about the micro-choices in your vocabulary.
The Spotlight Effect is Ruining Your Pitch
We all suffer from the "Spotlight Effect." We think everyone is looking at us, judging our every word, and noticing that tiny coffee stain on our shirt.
Newsflash: They aren't.
Everyone else is too busy worrying about their coffee stains and their awkward comments. This is actually incredibly liberating. Once you realize that people are primarily concerned with themselves, you can stop focusing on how you look and start focusing on how they feel.
If you want to influence someone, make them the hero of the story. Don't tell them how great your product is. Tell them how great they will be once they use it. It’s the difference between saying "This software has a 10x faster processing speed" and "This software will give you two hours of your life back every Friday."
Who cares about the processing speed? Everyone cares about their Friday afternoon.
Real World Examples: The Good, The Bad, and The Weird
Let’s look at how this plays out in the wild.
The Ben Franklin Effect: Old Ben had a hater in the Pennsylvania legislature. Instead of being extra nice to the guy, Franklin asked to borrow a rare book from the man's library. The rival agreed. Because he did Franklin a favor, his brain had to resolve the cognitive dissonance: "Why did I do a favor for someone I hate? I must actually like him!" They became lifelong friends.
The "Magic" Word: There’s a famous study by Ellen Langer at Harvard involving a Xerox machine. People were more likely to let someone cut in line if they used the word "because"—even if the reason was totally nonsensical ("Can I use the Xerox machine because I have to make copies?"). The "Gator brain" hears the structure of a logical argument and just nods along.
The Steve Jobs "Reality Distortion Field": Jobs didn’t just give specs. He used metaphors. He called the computer a "bicycle for the mind." He used the power of framing to change how people perceived the entire category of personal technology. He understood that influence is your superpower only when you can dictate the context of the conversation.
Mistakes That Kill Your Credibility
- Asking for permission to speak: "Can I just say something?" Just say it.
- Upspeak: Ending your sentences on a high note like they’re questions? It makes you sound like you’re seeking validation.
- Over-apologizing: "Sorry, I just have a quick question." Unless you stepped on someone's foot, stop saying sorry. It’s a submissive cue that drains your influence.
Actionable Steps to Reclaim Your Influence
If you want to start seeing influence is your superpower as a tangible tool rather than a vague concept, you need to practice in low-stakes environments. You don't wait for the championship game to start practicing your free throws.
Start with the "No" Challenge
Go out and intentionally ask for things where the answer might be no. Ask for a discount at a major retail chain. Ask for a better table at a half-empty restaurant. The goal isn't to get the "yes"—it's to desensitize yourself to the "no." Once you aren't afraid of rejection, you become infinitely more influential because you're no longer projecting desperation.
Master the Frame
Before every meeting, ask yourself: "What is the frame here?" Is it a frame of scarcity (we don't have enough money) or a frame of opportunity (this investment will scale us)? If you don't set the frame, someone else will. Usually, it'll be the person with the loudest voice or the most anxiety.
Practice Active Listening (The Real Kind)
Most people just wait for their turn to speak. Real influence comes from making the other person feel truly heard. Use "mirroring"—repeat the last three words of what they said as a question. It forces them to expand and shows you're paying attention.
The "Pause" Experiment
In your next three conversations, try to leave a three-second gap after the other person finishes speaking before you respond. Watch how they react. Often, they will fill that gap with more information, often the real information they were hesitant to share at first.
Influence isn't something you're born with or without. It's a muscle. If yours is atrophied, it's going to hurt to use it at first. You'll feel awkward. You'll feel like an imposter. But the more you lean into the reality that your voice matters and your requests are valid, the more the world starts to bend in your direction.
Stop waiting for someone to give you a platform. Build your own. Use the tools of psychology, empathy, and framing to move the needle. Because at the end of the day, the people who change the world aren't usually the ones with the most authority—they're the ones who understood that influence is the only superpower that actually exists.