:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Inside-out-2-Kensington-Tallman-060624-9bc351dcd3ac4e32994608c83a4de1ec.jpg)
You probably noticed it immediately. Within the first ten minutes of watching Riley hit puberty, something felt... off. Or maybe just different. Most of us went into the theater expecting the exact same vocal texture from the 2015 original, but the Inside Out 2 voices lineup underwent a massive, somewhat controversial shake-up before a single frame of animation was finalized. It wasn't just about adding new emotions like Anxiety or Ennui. It was about who disappeared.
Voice acting is a strange beast because we get so attached to the "soul" of a character through their cords. When Disney and Pixar announced the sequel, fans assumed the core five—Joy, Sadness, Anger, Fear, and Disgust—would be a package deal. They weren't.
The Massive Recasting Drama Nobody Expected
Let's address the elephant in the room: Bill Hader and Mindy Kaling. In the original film, Hader was the literal voice of Fear, and Kaling brought that perfect, sharp-tongued judgment to Disgust. They were iconic. But when the credits rolled on the sequel, their names were nowhere to be found.
Why? It basically came down to the bottom line.
Reports surfaced during production that Amy Poehler (the voice of Joy) was offered a massive $5 million salary plus bonuses to return. Meanwhile, the rest of the main cast was reportedly offered around $100,000. No bonuses. No back-end. Just a flat fee that, for stars of Hader and Kaling's caliber, felt like a lowball. They walked. It’s a move that sparked a lot of conversation in Hollywood about the value of voice talent versus "star power" marketing. Pixar had to pivot fast.
Replacing them wasn't easy. Tony Hale stepped into the shoes (and the sweater vest) of Fear, while Liza Lapira took over Disgust. Hale, known for Veep and Arrested Development, has that nervous energy down to a science, so the transition was smoother than most expected. Lapira had a harder job—matching Kaling’s specific brand of "valley girl" condescension—but she managed to keep the character’s essence without it feeling like a cheap parody.
The New Crew Taking Over Riley’s Brain
Puberty is messy. To reflect that, the Inside Out 2 voices expanded to include the "complex" emotions that come with being a teenager. This is where the casting got really inspired.
Maya Hawke as Anxiety is, quite frankly, a stroke of genius. She brought this frantic, raspy, mile-a-minute delivery that perfectly captured what it feels like when your brain starts spiraling about high school social hierarchies. It wasn’t just "nervous"; it was proactive and exhausting.
🔗 Read more: Funny Movies with Mark Wahlberg: The Roles Where He Actually Stole the Show
Then you have Ayo Edebiri as Envy. Edebiri is everywhere right now, and for good reason. Her take on Envy wasn't malicious or mean-spirited. Instead, she made the character small, wide-eyed, and constantly yearning. It made the emotion relatable rather than villainous.
Who Else Joined the Headspace?
- Adèle Exarchopoulos as Ennui: This was a deep cut. Casting a French actress to play the personification of "boredom" and "contempt" is a meta-joke that worked brilliantly. Her voice is low, monotone, and perpetually exhausted.
- Paul Walter Hauser as Embarrassment: He barely speaks. Most of his performance is grunts, sighs, and the sound of a hoodie being pulled over a face. It’s a physical vocal performance that proves you don't need a monologue to steal a scene.
- June Squibb as Nostalgia: A tiny cameo, but a memorable one. At 94 years old (at the time of recording), Squibb brought a grandmotherly warmth to an emotion that Riley isn't even supposed to have for another thirty years.
Why the Voice Shifts Matter for the Story
You might think recasting Fear and Disgust would break the immersion. Honestly? It kinda works for the narrative. Riley is thirteen now. Everything about her world is changing, including the way her internal dialogue sounds.
When you’re a kid, your emotions are distinct and pure. As you hit those teen years, your "sense of self" becomes more fractured. Having slightly different vocal textures for the original crew actually mirrors the physiological changes happening in a kid's brain. Joy, voiced with relentless (and sometimes grating) optimism by Amy Poehler, remains the anchor. Poehler is the only one who could make Joy’s borderline-toxic positivity feel empathetic rather than annoying.
The "Deep Dark Secret" and Hidden Cameos
If you stayed through the credits—and you should have—you saw the payoff for "Deep Dark Secret." This character was voiced by Steve Purcell. If that name sounds familiar to hardcore Pixar nerds, it’s because he’s a long-time director and writer at the studio.
👉 See also: Lucy Liu Charlie's Angels Outfits: Why Alex Munday Is Still the Queen of Y2K Style
And then there's Bloofy. If you grew up on Dora the Explorer or Blue's Clues, Bloofy was a hilarious, painful trigger. Voiced by Ron Funches, Bloofy represents the "preschool show" character that Riley is secretly still obsessed with but would die before admitting to her friends. Funches has this naturally melodic, joyful voice that fits the "2D animated dog" vibe perfectly.
Paired with him is Lance Slashblade, a parody of early 2000s video game protagonists (think Final Fantasy or Kingdom Hearts). He was voiced by Yong Yea, a professional voice actor famous in the gaming community. This was a smart move by Pixar to bring in someone who actually knows the "dramatic anime dub" style.
The Logistics: How They Recorded
Most people think the Inside Out 2 voices were all in a room together riffing. Nope.
That’s rarely how high-end animation works. Amy Poehler likely recorded her lines in a booth alone, reacting to scratch tracks or director Kelsey Mann feeding her lines. Maya Hawke recorded much of her part while balancing her Stranger Things schedule. The magic happens in the edit, where the sound engineers layer these separate performances to make it sound like Anxiety and Joy are actually standing three inches apart screaming at each other.
It’s a grueling process. They often record the same line 50 different ways. "I'm fine." "I'm fine." "I'm fine?" Each inflection changes the animation. Because in Pixar’s workflow, the voice usually comes first. The animators watch the footage of the actors recording—capturing Maya Hawke's frantic hand gestures or Tony Hale's eye twitches—and bake those human quirks into the characters.
What You Should Watch For Next
If you're a fan of the vocal performances in this franchise, there are a few things you can do to appreciate the craft more:
🔗 Read more: Noble House Pierce Brosnan: The 1988 Miniseries That Predicted His Bond Future
- Watch the "making of" clips: Look for the "B-roll" of the actors in the recording booth. Pay attention to how much they move their bodies to get the right sound.
- Compare the Fear performances: Listen to Bill Hader in the 2015 film and Tony Hale in the 2024 sequel back-to-back. Hale leans more into a "fragile" pitch, while Hader was more "manic."
- Check out the international dubs: Pixar is famous for localizing their films. In some versions, the "Emotion" characters are voiced by local celebrities or even psychologists to ensure the nuances of the feelings translate across cultures.
The Inside Out 2 voices cast proves that while "star power" matters for the poster, the "character soul" is what keeps the audience in their seats. Despite the drama over paychecks and recasting, the ensemble managed to do the impossible: they made a movie about a 13-year-old’s brain feel like a universal experience for adults, too.
To dive deeper into the world of animation, start following the individual voice actors on social media. Many of them, like Ron Funches and Tony Hale, often share behind-the-scenes stories about the specific directions they were given to find the "voice" of an abstract concept. You can also look up the "scratch vocal" process to see how Pixar uses their own employees to voice characters for years before the celebrities ever step into the booth.