If you’ve spent any time on Instagram lately, you’ve probably seen the smile. You know the one. Amanda Kloots has this way of beaming that feels like it could power a small city. After everything she went through with the loss of Nick Cordero in 2020, the world has basically been holding its breath, waiting for her to find that "second act" love.
Naturally, the rumor mill is spinning. People see a photo of her looking happy and immediately start typing "is Amanda Kloots engaged" into their search bars.
But here’s the reality: as of early 2026, Amanda Kloots is not engaged. She is, however, very much in a relationship that has people talking—for a lot of different reasons. Last year, she went public with retired tennis pro Justin Gimelstob. It wasn’t just a "soft launch" on a Story; they did the full red carpet debut at the Unforgettable Evening gala in Los Angeles.
Since then, the speculation hasn't stopped.
The Justin Gimelstob Connection: More Than Just "Courting"
Amanda has been incredibly open about how hard it was to start dating again. She’s talked about the "widow fire," the guilt, and the weirdness of introducing a new person to her son, Elvis. When she finally stepped out with Justin, she told reporters they were still in the "courting" phase.
It sounds old-fashioned. Kinda sweet, actually.
They met through mutual friends, though Justin admitted he’d been admiring her from afar for a long time—specifically since seeing her at a Formula 1 race in Vegas back in 2023. It took about 18 months for them to actually go on a date.
But why the engagement rumors?
Usually, it's a mix of two things. First, her sister, Anna Kloots, recently got married in Paris. Whenever a sibling ties the knot, the "you’re next" energy starts following the other one around. Second, fans are just desperate for Amanda to have a happy ending. We saw her go through the absolute worst-case scenario on a national stage. We want the ring for her.
Why This Relationship Is Polarizing
Now, if you dig into the comments on Reddit or X, you’ll see that not everyone is throwing confetti. While Amanda is the quintessential "nice girl" of daytime TV, Justin Gimelstob comes with some heavy baggage.
He’s a former tennis star, sure. But he also has a past that includes some pretty public legal trouble and controversy within the tennis world. This has led to a bit of a divide among Amanda’s followers.
- The Supporters: They figure she’s a grown woman who has earned the right to choose her own partner. If she’s happy, they’re happy.
- The Skeptics: They worry about his history and wonder if he fits the "wholesome" brand she’s built over the last few years.
Honestly, it's a complicated situation. Amanda has said that Nick (her late husband) basically gave her his blessing through various mediums and signs, telling her that love was "coming." To her, this might be exactly what she was told to look for.
✨ Don't miss: How Old Is Marco Antonio Solis? The Surprising Truth About El Buki in 2026
Life as a "Blended" Duo
One reason people think an engagement might be on the horizon is how integrated their lives have become. This isn't just two people getting dinner. They are blending families.
Justin has a son, Brandon, and Amanda has Elvis. Seeing the two boys bond has been a huge part of why Amanda says the relationship feels "lovely." When you're a single mom, you aren't just dating for yourself. You're dating for your kid, too.
Handling the "Nick" Legacy
It is impossible to talk about Amanda Kloots getting engaged or even dating without mentioning Nick Cordero. He is a massive part of her story.
She still honors his anniversary. She still posts about him. She’s making it clear that a new love doesn't replace the old one—it just sits alongside it. That’s a hard needle to thread. Most people struggle with that level of nuance.
If she does get engaged, it’s going to be a massive internet moment. But for now? No ring. Just a lot of tennis matches and red carpets.
What to Watch For Next
If you’re looking for signs that an engagement is actually happening, keep an eye on a few specific things:
- The Jewelry: Obviously. But Amanda wears a lot of rings, so don't get fooled by a right-hand sparkler.
- Travel: They’ve been spending time in Paris and various vacation spots. A "big ask" usually happens on a trip.
- The Move: There has been plenty of talk about whether they will move into one of their Los Angeles homes together. If they consolidate households, a proposal is usually the next logical step.
Basically, she's happy. After 2020, that's really all anyone should care about. Whether there’s a wedding in 2026 or they just keep "courting" for another three years, she’s clearly moved into a chapter where she’s no longer just "the woman who lost her husband." She’s a woman who found herself again.
Next Steps for Fans:
Follow Amanda’s official social media for actual announcements rather than tabloid speculation. If you're interested in her journey through grief and new love, her book Live Your Life offers the best context for why she approaches relationships the way she does today. Be wary of "insider" reports on gossip sites—most are just guessing based on her latest vacation photos.