Labels are funny things. People love to slap them on a celebrity like a price tag at a yard sale, thinking they’ve finally figured out the "deal" with someone. When it comes to the question, is Caitlyn Jenner a lesbian, the answer isn't a simple yes or no. Honestly, it’s a lot more complicated than the internet comments make it out to be.
If you ask the average person on the street, they might say, "Well, she was married to women for decades, so she must be a lesbian now that she’s transitioned, right?" It sounds logical. But human identity doesn't always follow a straight line. Or a curved one. Sometimes it just sits there, refusing to move.
The Difference Between Who You Are and Who You Love
One of the biggest hurdles in understanding Caitlyn’s journey is the mix-up between gender identity and sexual orientation. She’s been very vocal about this since that first bombshell interview with Diane Sawyer back in 2015.
Basically, gender identity is who you go to bed as. Sexual orientation is who you go to bed with.
Caitlyn has spent years explaining that these two things are separate buckets. In her memoir, The Secrets of My Life, she describes a lifelong struggle with gender dysphoria that had nothing to do with her attraction to women. She loved her wives. She raised ten children. But the internal sense of being a woman was always there, independent of who she was dating.
What has she actually said?
She has been asked point-blank: are you a lesbian?
Her responses have shifted over time, which is totally normal for someone undergoing a massive life change in their 60s. Early on, she told Sawyer, "I am, as far as I know, heterosexual." That confused a lot of people. How can a woman who likes women be heterosexual? Well, at the time, she was still processing her transition and likely referring to her history of being attracted to women while living as a man.
Later, on her reality show I Am Cait, the conversation moved toward the possibility of dating men. She famously said it would be "attractive" to have a man treat her like a "normal woman." But even that wasn't a definitive "I'm straight now." It felt more like a curiosity about a different kind of validation.
The Asexual Angle
Here is the part most people miss. Caitlyn has often described herself as "asexual" in her current stage of life.
She’s 76 now. After three marriages—to Chrystie Crownover, Linda Thompson, and Kris Jenner—and decades of high-intensity living, she has repeatedly suggested that the "sex thing" just isn't a priority anymore. In a 2017 interview with Larry King, she basically shrugged and said she doesn't "even go there."
- Marriages: Three. All to women.
- Current Status: Single (officially).
- Public Stance: Not looking, not interested.
There was plenty of gossip about her and Sophia Hutchins. They lived together, they went to events together, and they clearly share a deep bond. But both have been adamant that their relationship is a partnership, not a sexual romance. Sophia has described it as a "parental" or "business" connection. Caitlyn has called her "my best friend."
Why the "Lesbian" Label Doesn't Stick
If we’re being technically precise with terminology, a woman who is exclusively attracted to other women is a lesbian. Since Caitlyn has only ever been in long-term romantic and sexual relationships with women, the label seems like a natural fit.
📖 Related: Timothée Chalamet Height and Weight: What Most People Get Wrong
But she hasn't claimed it.
Labels only work if the person chooses to wear them. Caitlyn has actually faced some pushback from the LGBTQ+ community for her conservative views and her initial "lukewarm" support for same-sex marriage. This friction makes her even less likely to adopt a label that she feels doesn't represent her personal experience.
She often speaks about her life in two distinct chapters. The "Bruce" chapter was about being a husband and a father. The "Caitlyn" chapter is about being a woman and an advocate. Sex and dating? They seem to be footnotes in the second chapter.
The "Been There, Done That" Energy
In a promo for I Am Cait, she once joked about her future dating life: "I've been there, done that, got three ex-wives."
That sentence alone tells you everything you need to know about her headspace. She isn't searching for a new partner to define her womanhood. She spent sixty-five years trying to get to a place where she could just look in the mirror and be okay. For her, that's the win. A romantic partner—male or female—feels like an unnecessary complication to a life that was already too complicated for too long.
Common Misconceptions vs. Reality
People often assume that transitioning "changes" who you like. It doesn't.
For some people, transitioning allows them to be more honest about their attractions. For others, it doesn't change a thing. In Caitlyn's case, it seems to have led to a period of peaceful solitude.
🔗 Read more: Carrie Underwood Political Party: What Most People Get Wrong
"I got bigger things than an orgasm to worry about."
— Caitlyn Jenner
That quote is legendary. It’s blunt, it’s a little salty, and it’s very her. It perfectly encapsulates why she doesn't bother with the "is caitlyn jenner a lesbian" debate. She’s busy with politics, her family, and her own brand.
What This Means for Us
Understanding Caitlyn's identity requires us to be okay with ambiguity. We live in a world that wants everyone to pick a team. We want to know exactly which box to check.
But identity is a spectrum.
If you’re looking for a definitive answer, you won’t find it in a dictionary. You’ll find it in her actions. She lives as a woman. She has a history of loving women. She currently expresses no desire to date anyone.
So, is she a lesbian? By some technical definitions, perhaps. By her own definition? She's just Caitlyn.
✨ Don't miss: Brianna Coppage Net Worth: What Most People Get Wrong About the Viral Teacher
Actionable Takeaways for the Curious
- Distinguish Gender from Orientation: Remember that being trans is about who you are, while being gay, straight, or bi is about who you like.
- Respect Self-Identification: Even if someone's history suggests a certain label, always use the terms they use for themselves.
- Understand the "A" in LGBTQIA+: Asexuality is a valid part of the spectrum, especially for older individuals or those who have undergone major life transitions.
- Look Beyond the Tabloids: Relationship rumors (like the ones involving Sophia Hutchins) are often just that—rumors. Trust the words of the people involved over the "sources" in gossip magazines.
The best way to stay informed is to follow her direct interviews rather than second-hand reports. She is someone who has never been afraid to speak her mind, even when her opinions are unpopular. If her identity ever changes or if she decides to embrace a new label, she’ll likely be the first one to tell us. Until then, we should probably take her at her word: she's done with the dating game and focused on living her life as she finally sees fit.