The short answer? No. Kaylor Martin and Aaron Evans are definitely not together anymore.
If you’re looking for a fairytale ending where the blonde girl from Pennsylvania and the British guy with the "two front teeth" lived happily ever after, you’re about a year too late. Honestly, their breakup was one of the loudest, messiest exits in Love Island USA history. It wasn’t just a "we grew apart" situation. It was a "you lied to my face for three days in a New York hotel room" situation.
By the time the Season 6 reunion aired in August 2024, the ship hadn't just sailed—it had hit an iceberg and sunk to the bottom of the Atlantic.
The moment it all officially went south
We all saw the Casa Amor disaster. Kaylor crying on the dock while Aaron was busy "snogging" Daniela in Fiji. But the real nail in the coffin happened back in the real world.
Kaylor basically "hard launched" their breakup right outside the reunion taping in New York City. She was filmed telling a crowd of screaming fans, "We are done, we are not together." It was iconic. It was overdue. But inside the reunion, things got even darker.
Aaron finally admitted to the stuff he’d been downplaying for weeks. He confessed to being much more physical with Daniela than he ever let on to Kaylor. The kicker? They had been hanging out in New York for days leading up to that filming, and he didn't say a word. Kaylor’s reaction was raw. She called him "disgusting" and told him she never wanted to speak to him again.
Where are they now in 2026?
Fast forward to 2026, and the dust has mostly settled, but they are living completely separate lives.
Kaylor's new chapter
Kaylor has moved on in a big way. Around Memorial Day weekend in 2025, she "hard launched" a new relationship with a guy named Torin Dunn. She posted a TikTok singing along to Kesha’s "Grow a Pear" (shade intended?) and eventually shared photos of them kissing on Instagram.
💡 You might also like: Brenda Song Sexy Pics: Why the Star’s Red Carpet Style Matters in 2026
She seems much more like herself these-days. If you remember her in the villa, she was constantly in tears, second-guessing everything. Now? She’s living that LA life, doing the influencer thing, and seemingly dating someone who doesn't make her cry every 48 hours.
Aaron's "healing era"
Aaron, on the other hand, went through a pretty dark period after the show. He caught a massive amount of heat from the public—way more than he probably expected. He actually moved back to the UK for a while and completely unplugged.
In the spinoff series Love Island: Beyond the Villa, which aired in mid-2025, Aaron opened up about his mental health. He admitted that the backlash after the reunion was "horrible" and that he basically just wanted to sleep all day to avoid his own thoughts. He's stayed mostly off social media, which honestly, was probably the best move for him.
Did they ever make up?
Surprisingly, they are on "civil" terms now.
When they filmed Beyond the Villa in Los Angeles, they had to see each other for the first time in nearly a year. It was awkward. Kaylor admitted she still had love for him—not "get back together" love, but that lingering "we went through something crazy together" feeling.
Aaron actually apologized. Like, for real this time. He took accountability for the gaslighting and the manipulation. They agreed to be in the same friend groups without the screaming matches. But any chance of a romantic reconciliation? That door is locked, bolted, and the key has been melted down.
Why it was never going to work
Honestly, you could see the cracks from week two.
💡 You might also like: Mabel: Why the High Fashion World Can't Get Enough of This Modern Muse
- The Trust Gap: You can't build a house on sand. Once Aaron lied about the extent of his "connection" with Daniela, the trust was gone.
- Public Pressure: Being the "villains" of the season is exhausting. Every time they tried to make it work, the internet reminded Kaylor exactly why she shouldn't.
- Maturity Levels: Kaylor was 22 and falling in love for what felt like the first time. Aaron was 27 and seemed to be playing a game he didn't know how to finish.
What we can learn from the "Kaylor and Aaron" saga
If you’re currently in a relationship that feels like a Season 6 highlight reel—full of "love bombing" and "tests"—take a page out of Kaylor’s book.
- Trust your gut, not the "re-coupling" speech. If it feels wrong when the cameras are off, it's wrong.
- Accountability is everything. If they only tell the truth when they’re backed into a corner (or on a reunion stage), it's too late.
- Distance helps. Kaylor didn't truly start healing until Aaron was back in the UK and she was surrounded by her actual friends, like Liv and Leah.
The reality is that "is Kaylor and Aaron still together" is a question with a very permanent "No." But both of them seem better off for it. Kaylor found her confidence again, and Aaron seems to be doing the internal work he probably should have done before going on a dating show.
If you're still following the Season 6 cast, keep an eye on Kaylor's vlogs—she's been dropping more behind-the-scenes tea about the filming of the spinoff and how she's navigating the LA dating scene post-Aaron.