People are obsessed with labels. It’s basically the internet’s favorite pastime, especially when it comes to pop stars like Sabrina Carpenter. Ever since she dropped Short n’ Sweet and dominated the 2024 charts, the question "is Sabrina Carpenter straight" has been bouncing around Reddit threads and TikTok comment sections like a pinball.
Honestly? The answer isn't a simple yes or no because Sabrina herself hasn't slapped a specific label on her forehead. She’s lived her life in the public eye since she was a literal child on Disney Channel, and as she’s grown into her mid-twenties, she’s become a master of the "wink and a nudge" school of songwriting.
The Lyrics That Set the Internet on Fire
You’ve heard "Slim Pickins," right? It’s that track where she laments the lack of decent guys in the dating pool. One line in particular caused a massive spike in Google searches: “Since the Lord forgot my gay awakening / Then I’ll just be here in the kitchen.”
That specific lyric is kinda hilarious. It’s self-deprecating. Most fans took it as a pretty blunt confirmation of her heterosexuality—basically saying she wishes she could find women attractive because men are such a headache, but her brain just isn't wired that way. It’s a sentiment a lot of straight women relate to when they’re tired of "manchildren."
But then you have the "Taste" music video.
The visuals there are... a lot. You’ve got Sabrina and Jenna Ortega basically trying to murder each other in a Death Becomes Her style feud, only for it to end with them sharing a kiss. Some people screamed "queerbaiting," while others saw it as a campy, artistic choice that fits the song's theme of "you'll have to taste me when he's kissing you." It was messy. It was loud. It was very Sabrina.
💡 You might also like: Penelope Menchaca OnlyFans: What Really Happened with the Viral Rumors
A History of "Boyfriend" Rumors
If we look at the hard data—the dating history—it’s a very long list of men.
- The Disney Days: She dated Bradley Steven Perry way back in 2014. He asked her out with a note in a bottle. Super cute, super middle-school vibes.
- The Triangle: Then came the Joshua Bassett era. This was the "Drivers License" drama heard 'round the world. Whether she was the "blonde girl" Olivia Rodrigo sang about or not, that whole saga was centered entirely on a heteronormative love triangle.
- The Short-Lived Flings: We saw the pap shots of her with Shawn Mendes in early 2023. They looked cozy, but Shawn eventually shut it down, saying they weren't dating.
- The Barry Keoghan Chapter: This was the big one. The Saltburn actor starred in her "Please Please Please" video. They did the Met Gala together. They were the "it" couple of 2024 until they reportedly split in December of that year.
As of early 2026, the rumor mill is spinning again. There have been sightings of her in Italy and England with a "handsome blonde man" who looks a bit older. While nothing is confirmed, the pattern is pretty consistent.
The "Gay Awakening" vs. "Busy Woman"
Not everything has been smooth sailing with the LGBTQ+ community, though. In her track "Busy Woman," there’s a lyric that goes: “If you don’t want me, I’ll deem you gay.”
Yikes.
That line rubbed a lot of people the wrong way. It feels a bit like those old-school tropes where a woman's ego is so big she assumes a man's lack of interest must mean he's not into women at all. It’s sassy, sure, but it felt a little dated to some listeners. On the flip side, Sabrina has been a vocal supporter of LGBTQ+ rights for years. She’s not out here trying to be a villain; she’s just writing lyrics that are, in her own words, "irony-laced" and "sarcastic."
What She’s Actually Said
In a 2025 interview with Vogue Italia, Sabrina got real about her feelings toward men. She called them a "fun species to watch," noting that she feels "adored and loved" by some and "confused and ridiculed" by others.
She hasn't had a "coming out" moment because, for all intents and purposes, she hasn't indicated there is anything to come out about. She seems to be navigating the world as a woman who is primarily, if not exclusively, attracted to men, even if she finds the experience exhausting.
Does that mean she's 100% straight? We don't know her private thoughts. But based on every public interview, relationship, and lyric (even the cheeky ones), she hasn't claimed a queer identity.
The Takeaway
If you're looking for a definitive "yes, she is straight" or "no, she is bi," you’re probably going to be waiting a long time. Sabrina Carpenter likes to keep people guessing. She plays with themes of sexuality in her art because that's what pop stars do—they push buttons.
Here is what we actually know:
- Every public relationship she has had has been with a man.
- Her lyrics often joke about her lack of a "gay awakening."
- She uses queer-coded imagery in her videos (like "Taste") for artistic and "camp" effect.
- She currently appears to be single or quietly seeing a new male acquaintance as of early 2026.
If you want to stay updated on her status, the best thing to do is watch her lyrics. She usually tells on herself in the second verse of her B-sides before the tabloids even get a whiff of the truth. Pay attention to the credits on her next album—that’s where the real tea is usually hidden.