The stock market feels expensive. Honestly, it almost always feels that way when you’re looking at the CAPE ratio S&P 500 data. You’ve probably seen the charts. They look like a mountain range that just won’t stop growing, leaving everyone wondering if we’re standing on a peak or just a plateau.
Robert Shiller, the Nobel laureate from Yale who basically made this metric famous, designed it to help us see through the noise. It’s simple, really. Instead of looking at a single year of earnings—which can be messy and volatile—you look at the last ten years, adjusted for inflation. That’s the "Cyclically Adjusted Price-to-Earnings" part. It’s meant to be a valuation anchor. But here’s the thing: that anchor has been dragging behind a speedboat for most of the last decade.
If you sold your stocks every time the CAPE ratio S&P 500 crossed its historical average of about 17, you would have missed out on one of the greatest bull markets in human history. You'd be sitting on a pile of cash, watching the world go by, feeling very "right" but getting much poorer.
Why the CAPE Ratio S&P 500 keeps screaming "fire" in a crowded theater
We have to talk about the 1990s. During the dot-com bubble, the CAPE ratio soared to an eye-watering 44. People thought the world was ending when it finally crashed. Since then, we’ve spent a huge chunk of time well above the long-term mean. Does that mean the mean is wrong? Or is the market permanently broken?
The reality is nuanced. When you look at the CAPE ratio S&P 500 today, you’re seeing a reflection of a few massive structural shifts in how the world works. Interest rates are the big one. For years, they were basically zero. When money is free, paying a premium for future earnings makes total sense. If you can't get a decent return on a bond, you’re going to buy stocks, even if they're pricey.
Then there's the "composition" problem. The S&P 500 of 1960 isn't the S&P 500 of 2026. Back then, it was dominated by capital-intensive stuff. Steel. Oil. Trains. These businesses have huge overhead. Today, the index is top-heavy with software and tech giants like Apple, Microsoft, and Alphabet. These companies have massive profit margins and lean balance sheets. Investors argue they should trade at a higher multiple than a 1950s railroad company.
It’s easy to get lost in the math. But the math is just a proxy for human psychology. The CAPE ratio S&P 500 tells us how much we’re willing to pay for a dollar of hope. Right now, hope is expensive.
The Shiller effect and the 10-year trap
One of the biggest gripes critics have with Shiller’s metric is the ten-year window. Think about what was happening ten years ago. If we’re in 2026, the ten-year average includes the tail end of the mid-2010s. It includes the strange, distorted earnings of the 2020 pandemic era.
👉 See also: Where Was Dutch Bros Founded? The True Story of the Coffee Cart That Changed Oregon
Accounting rules have changed, too. FASB (Financial Accounting Standards Board) updates mean that earnings today aren't calculated the same way they were in the 1920s. If you don't adjust for these accounting shifts, you're basically comparing apples to a bag of hammers. Jeremy Siegel, a professor at Wharton and a frequent "bullish" counterpoint to Shiller, has long argued that the CAPE ratio is too pessimistic because it doesn't account for these shifts in how companies report profits.
He has a point. If you look at "operating earnings" instead of "reported earnings," the market suddenly looks a bit more reasonable. Still expensive? Yeah. But not "the-sky-is-falling" expensive.
How to actually use the CAPE ratio S&P 500 without losing your mind
Most people use the CAPE ratio as a timing tool. That’s a mistake. A massive mistake.
Valuation metrics are terrible at telling you what will happen next month or next year. They are, however, pretty decent at telling you what might happen over the next decade. There is a strong historical correlation between a high starting CAPE ratio S&P 500 and lower-than-average returns over the following ten years. It doesn't mean a crash is coming tomorrow. It just means the "easy money" has probably been made.
If you see a CAPE of 30, you shouldn't panic and sell everything. Instead, you should probably lower your expectations. Maybe you won't get 10% a year. Maybe you'll get 4% or 5%. That's a huge difference when you're planning for retirement.
- Diversification matters more when CAPE is high. If the US market is expensive, maybe international markets or emerging markets aren't.
- Don't ignore the E (Earnings). If companies keep growing their bottom line at 15% a year, they can grow into a high valuation.
- Context is king. A CAPE of 30 in a 1% interest rate environment is very different from a CAPE of 30 when bonds are paying 5%.
The "New Normal" argument
Some folks think we should just move the goalposts. If the average for the last 30 years has been 25, why are we still comparing it to a century-long average of 17?
It’s a tempting idea. But it’s also dangerous. "This time is different" are the four most expensive words in investing. Just because we've stayed high for a long time doesn't mean gravity has stopped working. It just means the bungee cord is really, really long. Eventually, it snaps back. We saw it in 2000, 2008, and the 2022 bear market.
What's fascinating about the CAPE ratio S&P 500 is its ability to stay irrational longer than most people can stay solvent. You can be "right" about the market being overvalued and still go broke trying to short it.
Actionable steps for the "Expensive" market
So, what do you actually do with this information? You don't need to be a macroeconomist to survive a high-CAPE environment.
First, check your asset allocation. If your stock portfolio has ballooned because of the massive run-up, you might be taking on more risk than you realize. Rebalancing isn't about timing the market; it's about managing your own fear.
Second, look at your "bond tent." If you’re nearing retirement and the CAPE ratio S&P 500 is in the top 10% of its historical range, it might be time to get a little more conservative. You don't want a "lost decade" to start the day you stop working.
Third, stay humble. No one—not Shiller, not Siegel, and definitely not some guy on YouTube—knows exactly where the S&P 500 will be in twelve months. The CAPE ratio is a weather vane, not a GPS. It tells you which way the wind is blowing, but it won't tell you if a storm is going to hit your house at 3:00 PM.
Focus on what you can control: your savings rate, your tax efficiency, and your ability to stay calm when the numbers on the screen turn red. The CAPE ratio S&P 500 is a great tool for perspective, but a terrible master for your daily life. Keep it in your toolbox, but don't let it drive the car.
✨ Don't miss: Is Your 20 Dollar Bill 2013 Series Actually Worth More Than Face Value?
Review your current portfolio weightings against your original targets. If the S&P 500's high valuation has pushed your stock exposure to 80% when you intended for 60%, trim the excess and move it into short-term fixed income or value-oriented sectors that aren't trading at historical extremes. Use the CAPE ratio as a signal to be cautious with new "lump sum" investments, perhaps opting for dollar-cost averaging to smooth out the entry price over several months.