Robert Eggers didn't just make a movie about a goat and some missing silver cups. He built a time machine. When people ask is The Witch scary, they usually expect a "yes" or "no" based on jump scares or buckets of gore. But that’s not what this is. It’s a slow, agonizing crawl into 1630s New England paranoia.
Honestly, if you’re looking for The Conjuring or Insidious, you’re going to be bored out of your mind. There are no demons popping out of wardrobes. Instead, you get a family starving in the woods while their religion turns into a weapon against them. It’s bleak. It’s quiet.
The fear comes from the isolation. You’ve got a family kicked out of their plantation because the dad, William (played by a booming Ralph Ineson), is too stubborn for his own good. They settle on the edge of a forest that looks like it’s waiting to swallow them whole. And it does.
📖 Related: Why Do You Realize Still Hits Different Two Decades Later
The Anatomy of Dread: Why It Works
Most horror movies rely on the "gotcha" moment. You know the one. The music swells, the screen goes quiet, and then bam—a loud noise. The Witch (or The VVitch, if you want to be fancy with the typography) hates that trope. It prefers the "something is very wrong and it's not going away" vibe.
Take the opening. We see a baby disappear during a game of peek-a-boo. It’s fast. It’s brutal. We actually see what happens to the baby—which is rare for a modern film—and it sets a tone of absolute hopelessness. There is no safety net. When you realize the antagonist isn't just a monster but the very environment itself, that’s when the real chills start.
Is it scary? For many, the answer lies in the psychological weight. Anya Taylor-Joy, in her breakout role as Thomasin, carries the burden of a family’s collective sins. Her parents start blaming her for everything from the curdled milk to the missing brother. That’s a universal fear: being gaslit by the people who are supposed to love you most.
The Folklore is Real (And That’s Terrifying)
Eggers did his homework. He spent years researching 17th-century journals and court records. Most of the dialogue is lifted directly from primary sources. This isn't just "inspired by true events" in a marketing sense; the things characters say were actually said by people who genuinely believed their neighbors were flying on broomsticks.
- The prayer scenes aren't just filler; they show the desperate, suffocating piety of the era.
- The obsession with "the devil’s book" reflects the actual legal documents from the Salem era.
- Even the design of the witch herself—the glimpses we get—pulls from Goya-esque imagery and genuine 1600s folklore.
When characters speak in that dense, King James-style English, it creates a barrier. You feel like a voyeur watching a tragedy unfold in a world that doesn't operate by your rules. It makes the supernatural elements feel more grounded. If these people believe in the devil as a physical, breathing entity, then you start to believe it too.
Black Phillip and the Animal Factor
We have to talk about the goat. Black Phillip.
Charlie, the real-life goat who played the role, was apparently a nightmare on set. He even sent Ralph Ineson to the hospital after a goring incident. That unpredictability translates to the screen. Every time that goat is in the frame, you feel an immense sense of unease. He’s just standing there. Staring. It’s weirdly effective.
The film uses animals to bridge the gap between the natural and the supernatural. A crow pecking at a breast, a hare that won't move, a goat that seems to understand English. It plays on the primal fear that nature is hostile.
📖 Related: When is Season 2 of Paradise Coming Out: The Messy Truth About the Netflix Sci-Fi Sequel
Is The Witch Scary for Casual Viewers?
Here is the truth: a lot of people hate this movie. If you go on Reddit or look at the CinemaScore from when it first came out, you’ll see people calling it a "snoozefest."
If your definition of "scary" requires a high body count or a monster that stays in the light, you’ll likely find it frustrating. It’s a period piece first, a family drama second, and a horror movie third. But if you find the idea of losing your mind in the wilderness while your mother looks at you with murderous intent scary? Then yeah, this is the peak of the genre.
The ending is where things usually split the audience. Some find it empowering, others find it devastating. Without spoiling too much, it’s a complete departure from the "survival" horror we’re used to. It asks a terrifying question: what if the "evil" side is actually better than the life you’re currently living?
Comparing The Witch to Other A24 Horror
| Movie | Style of Scare | Pacing |
|---|---|---|
| Hereditary | Traumatic, visceral | Medium |
| Midsommar | Bright, psychedelic | Slow |
| The Witch | Atmospheric, folktale | Very Slow |
Hereditary hits you like a truck. The Witch is more like a slow-acting poison. You don't realize how much it’s affecting you until the credits roll and you’re afraid to look at the shadows in your hallway.
Expert Consensus on the "Fear Factor"
Film critics and psychologists often point to The Witch as a prime example of "elevated horror" (a term many horror fans actually dislike, but it fits the description). Dr. Steven Schlozman, a psychiatrist who writes about the psychology of horror, often discusses how horror works best when it mirrors our real-world anxieties.
In this case, the anxiety is about the breakdown of the family unit. When the father fails to provide food and the mother fails to provide comfort, the children are left vulnerable. The "witch" is simply the catalyst that speeds up the rot. This is why the movie sticks with you—it’s not about the lady in the woods; it’s about the collapse of a home.
How to Prepare for a First Watch
If you’ve decided to brave it, don't watch this on a laptop with the lights on while scrolling on your phone. You’ll miss everything. This is a movie that demands your full attention.
- Turn on subtitles. The 17th-century dialect is thick. You’ll miss crucial plot points if you don't understand what William is mumbling into his beard.
- Sound is key. Mark Korven’s score is incredible. He used instruments like the nyckelharpa and the waterphone to create sounds that shouldn't exist. It’s dissonant and jarring.
- Watch the background. Eggers loves putting things in the negative space. Sometimes, the scariest thing in the frame is the thing you didn't notice until the second time you looked.
- Forget the jump scares. Just let the atmosphere soak in. It’s a mood piece.
Actionable Insights for Horror Fans
If you found The Witch scary and want to explore more of this specific "folk horror" subgenre, there are a few places to go next.
First, check out the "Unholy Trinity" of folk horror: The Wicker Man (1973), Witchfinder General (1968), and The Blood on Satan’s Claw (1971). These are the blueprints Eggers used to build his world. They deal with the same themes of isolated communities, old gods, and the clash between Christianity and the earth.
🔗 Read more: Why All of Me Cast and That Classic Body-Swap Magic Still Work Today
Second, read up on the actual history of the period. Books like The Enemy Within: 2,000 Years of Witch-hunting by John Demos provide context that makes the movie even more chilling. Knowing that the characters' reactions were the cultural norm at the time adds a layer of realism that's hard to shake.
Third, look into Robert Eggers’ later work like The Lighthouse or The Northman. He carries that same obsession with historical accuracy and oppressive atmosphere through all his films.
The "scary" part of The Witch isn't the supernatural. It’s the realization of how fragile the human mind is when it’s stripped of its comforts and forced to confront the unknown. Whether you call it a masterpiece or a slow-burn, it’s undeniably a film that changed the landscape of modern horror.
To truly appreciate why this film works, your next move should be watching a "Making Of" featurette or reading Eggers’ interviews about the set design. Understanding that they used actual period-accurate materials—down to the hand-stitched clothing—explains why the movie feels so uncomfortably "real." Once you see the effort put into the world-building, the dread becomes even more tangible on a rewatch. Take a night, turn the lights off, and pay attention to the silence between the dialogue; that's where the real witch lives.