Sibling rivalry is usually a phase. You fight over the remote, maybe scream about a borrowed shirt, and eventually, you grow out of it. But for Sara Louise Bradshaw, jealousy isn't just a phase—it’s a living, breathing creature that swallows her whole.
If you grew up in the late 80s or early 90s, you probably remember the Jacob Have I Loved movie popping up on PBS. It was part of the WonderWorks series, back when TV movies for kids didn't feel like they were talking down to us. Honestly, it was pretty heavy stuff for a Saturday afternoon. Watching a young Bridget Fonda play a girl who genuinely believes God hates her because she’s the "plain" twin? That stays with you.
What Actually Happens in the Jacob Have I Loved Movie?
The story is set on Rass Island, a tiny, wind-swept speck in the Chesapeake Bay during World War II. Everything is gray, salty, and isolated. Sara Louise—who everyone calls "Wheeze," a nickname her sister Caroline gave her—is the older twin by a few minutes.
But Caroline is the "miracle child." She was born sickly and required all the attention, while Louise was basically set aside the moment she took her first breath. By the time they’re fifteen, Caroline is the beautiful one with the voice of an angel. Louise is the one hauling crab pots and smelling like bait.
The movie captures that crushing feeling of being second-best in your own house. It’s not just that Caroline is better at things; it’s that the world seems to conspire to give Caroline everything Louise wants. Even the money Louise earns working on her father's boat ends up going toward Caroline’s music lessons. It’s brutal.
👉 See also: Why the Lyrics for T Rex Get It On Still Define Glam Rock Decades Later
The Cast That Made It Work
Seeing a young Bridget Fonda as Louise is a trip. This was 1989, right before she became a massive star in movies like Single White Female. She brings this raw, simmering bitterness to the role. You can see the resentment in her eyes every time Jenny Robertson (who plays Caroline) starts singing or batting her eyelashes.
John Kellogg plays "The Captain," an old man who returns to the island after decades away. He becomes the catalyst for a lot of the drama. Louise develops this huge, awkward crush on him—partly because he’s the only person who really sees her as an individual. But then, in typical fashion for this story, Caroline waltzes in and charms him too.
The Bible Verse That Breaks the Camel's Back
The title comes from a verse in Romans: "Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I hated."
In the film, Louise’s grandmother—a woman who is basically a professional at being miserable—quotes this to her. She implies that just as God chose Jacob over Esau, He has chosen Caroline over Louise. It’s a devastating moment. For a kid growing up in a strict, religious community, being told you’re "the hated one" by divine decree is a psychological gut punch.
Louise starts to believe that her destiny is to be the shadow. She stops trying to be "pretty" or "talented." She just leans into the salt and the work.
Book vs. Movie: What Changed?
If you read the Katherine Paterson novel (which won the Newbery Medal), you know it spans many years. We see Louise go from a teenager to a grown woman, eventually finding her own life as a midwife in the Appalachian mountains.
The Jacob Have I Loved movie is a bit more condensed. It’s only about an hour long. Because of that, some of the nuance of her journey into adulthood feels a little rushed. In the book, the ending is a beautiful, full-circle moment where Louise delivers twins and makes sure the "weak" one isn't pampered at the expense of the "strong" one. The movie hits the emotional beats, but it doesn't quite have the room to breathe that the prose does.
Why Does It Still Matter?
Most "coming of age" movies are about finding your first love or winning the big game. This one is about the ugly parts of the human heart. It’s about how jealousy can turn into a personality trait if you aren't careful.
📖 Related: Electric Barbarella: Why This Duran Duran Experiment Still Matters
It also touches on gender roles in a way that felt ahead of its time for a 1989 TV special. Louise wants to be a waterman. She wants to be out on the bay with her dad. But the island says no—that’s men’s work. She’s trapped by her geography, her gender, and her sister’s shadow.
How to Watch It Now
Finding the Jacob Have I Loved movie today is a bit of a scavenger hunt. It isn't exactly sitting on the front page of Netflix.
- DVDs: You can occasionally find old WonderWorks DVD collections on eBay or Amazon.
- YouTube: Sometimes the full movie or clips uploaded from old VHS tapes surface there.
- Libraries: Don't sleep on your local library’s digital catalog (like Hoopla or Libby); sometimes these educational gems are tucked away there.
Moving Forward With This Story
If you’ve only seen the movie, you’re missing half the heart. The real "ending" of the story isn't just about Louise leaving the island. It’s about her realizing that she was the one holding herself back by comparing her life to Caroline’s.
💡 You might also like: Why Hip Hop Albums 1994 Was Actually the Greatest Year Ever
If you want to dive deeper into this world, here is what you should do:
- Read the original novel by Katherine Paterson. The movie is a 7/10 adaptation, but the book is a 10/10 masterpiece. The internal monologue of Louise’s bitterness is much more vivid on the page.
- Look for other WonderWorks adaptations. If you liked the vibe of this film, check out Bridge to Terabithia (the 1985 version) or The House of Dies Drear. They have that same earnest, slightly haunting quality.
- Reflect on the "Esau" in your own life. This story works because everyone has felt like the "un-favored" twin at some point. Use it as a lens to look at your own past rivalries.
The Jacob Have I Loved movie might be over 35 years old, but the sting of feeling invisible never really goes out of style.