You know that feeling when you're watching a grown man in a suit lose his absolute mind because a red puppet just made a joke? That’s basically the entire vibe of whenever Jimmy Fallon and Sesame Street cross paths. It’s pure, unadulterated chaos, but in the best way possible.
Honestly, it’s kinda weird how well it works. Fallon is famously known for "breaking" during sketches—that giggly, can’t-hold-it-together energy that some people find annoying and others find endearing. But when you put him next to Elmo or Cookie Monster? That energy finally finds its soulmate. The Muppets are professionals, but they are also agents of chaos.
📖 Related: Why Ed Grimley on Saturday Night Live Was the Weirdest Risk That Actually Worked
The Night Elmo "Banned" Jimmy
There’s this specific clip from Late Night that still makes the rounds on TikTok and Reels because it’s just so awkward and hilarious. Elmo is sitting there, and Jimmy is trying to be the host, and Elmo just snaps. He basically tells Jimmy he’s not allowed on Sesame Street anymore.
"You're being a brat," Elmo says. A three-year-old monster calling a late-night host a brat to his face.
The genius of these moments isn't just the script. It’s the improv. The puppeteers behind these characters—legends like Kevin Clash or Matt Vogel—have this incredible ability to stay in character while playing off Jimmy's real-life laughter. Jimmy doesn't just treat them like puppets; he treats them like difficult A-list celebrities who might walk off the set at any moment.
That Classroom Instruments Moment
If you haven't seen the 2013 rendition of the Sesame Street theme song with The Roots and the Muppets, you're missing out on a piece of internet history. We've seen Jimmy do the classroom instruments thing with everyone from Metallica to Adele, but this was different.
- Cookie Monster was on the banana shaker.
- The Count did the literal countdown (obviously).
- Questlove looked like he was having the time of his life on a tiny toy drum set.
It wasn't just a "cute" segment for kids. It was a legitimate musical arrangement that felt nostalgic for the adults watching at 11:35 PM. It hit that sweet spot of E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) for entertainment—you had world-class musicians and world-class puppeteers creating something that actually sounded good.
Why it Works for the "Algorithm"
Google and social media algorithms love this pairing for a simple reason: multi-generational appeal.
Most late-night segments target a very specific demographic. But when Jimmy Fallon and Sesame Street team up, you have 30-somethings watching for nostalgia, kids watching because it’s Elmo, and seniors watching because they remember when Big Bird first showed up in 1969.
It’s "safe" content that doesn't feel "corporate." When Jimmy and Tariq Trotter (Black Thought) did the 50th Anniversary Rap, it could have been incredibly cringy. Instead, it was a high-energy tribute that respected the source material. They brought out Snuffleupagus. You can't lose when Snuffy is involved.
The "Word of the Day" and Beyond
Back in 2010, Jimmy did a "Word of the Day" segment on the actual Sesame Street set. The word was inspect.
🔗 Read more: Kathryn on Housewives of Beverly Hills: What Really Happened with the O.J. Connection
It’s a simple concept. Jimmy explains the word, Elmo demonstrates it. But watch Jimmy’s face. He’s wearing this striped t-shirt, looking about twelve years younger, and he’s genuinely leaning into the educational aspect of the show. It shows a different side of a guy who usually spends his time playing Beer Pong with Tom Cruise.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Cameos
A lot of people think these are just promotional stops for the Muppets. It’s actually deeper. The Jim Henson Company and Sesame Workshop are notoriously protective of their characters. They don't just "show up" anywhere.
The reason we see so much of Jimmy Fallon and Sesame Street is because the chemistry is verified. The performers behind the Muppets trust Jimmy to play along with the "reality" of the characters. When Cookie Monster says he doesn't want his cookies to be lonely, Jimmy doesn't roll his eyes. He has a total meltdown of laughter because, in that moment, he believes the cookies are lonely too.
The Secret Ingredient: The Roots
We can't talk about this duo without mentioning The Roots. Tariq Trotter’s ability to weave Sesame Street lore into hip-hop verses is a masterclass in songwriting.
In the 50th Anniversary Rap, he managed to make "1-2-3 Sesame Street" sound like a club anthem. It bridges the gap between the "Street" we knew as kids and the modern media landscape.
💡 You might also like: Why We Found a Love in a Hopeless Place Is Still the Definitive Anthem of the 2010s
Recent Moments to Rewatch
- The Photobomb Segment: Jimmy and the Muppets hid behind a curtain and popped out while kids were getting their pictures taken. The pure shock on those kids' faces when a real-life Big Bird appeared is the kind of "Discover-friendly" content that lives forever.
- The Hashtags Bit: Having Oscar the Grouch read "grumpy" tweets is a match made in heaven.
- Password: Seeing Cookie Monster try to play a word-association game without just saying "Cookie" for every answer is high-stakes television.
Moving Forward with the Muppets
So, what's the takeaway? Whether it's a 50th-anniversary special or a random Tuesday night on The Tonight Show, the collaboration between Jimmy Fallon and Sesame Street serves as a blueprint for how to do celebrity crossovers right. It’s not about "branding." It’s about play.
If you're looking to revisit these moments, start with the "Classroom Instruments" video on YouTube—it’s the gold standard. From there, dive into the "Elmo Bans Jimmy" clip to see some of the best improv in late-night history. It’s a reminder that no matter how old we get, there’s something inherently joyful about a guy in a suit losing a battle of wits to a piece of felt.
To get the most out of this rabbit hole, check out the official Tonight Show "Sesame Street" playlist, which compiles over a decade of these interactions. You can also see how the Muppet performers handle these live bits by looking for behind-the-scenes interviews with Matt Vogel (Big Bird/Kermit) or Eric Jacobson (Grover/Bert), which give a whole new perspective on the technical skill required to make Jimmy laugh that hard.