Honestly, it’s been a weird few years for the local crafting scene. If you grew up around the Mahoning Valley, you probably remember when a trip to the Eastwood Mall complex wasn’t complete without hitting the big craft stores. But things shifted. Fast.
Joann Fabrics in Niles Ohio used to be that reliable, slightly chaotic anchor for every DIY disaster and Halloween costume emergency. It was the place where you’d stand in a twenty-minute line with a bolt of fleece just to have someone in an apron give you a measuring tip that actually saved your project. But lately, the conversation around the Niles location—and the company as a whole—has turned into a confusing mess of bankruptcy headlines and "everything must go" signs.
The truth is, the retail landscape in Niles isn't what it was in 2019. Between the rising costs of literally everything and the way we all got used to ordering yarn from our phones, the physical store at 5555 Youngstown Warren Road hit some major speed bumps.
The Bankruptcy Reality Check
You've likely heard the rumors. Or saw the news.
Joann Inc. has been through the ringer. After a first brush with Chapter 11 in 2024, the company filed again in early 2025. This wasn't just a "corporate restructuring" this time—it was a massive downsizing that hit Ohio particularly hard. The Niles location, tucked into the busy retail sprawl near the Eastwood Mall, was unfortunately caught in the crosshairs.
While the company initially tried to keep the lights on at about 300 stores nationwide, the Niles spot ended up on the closure list. It’s a bummer. For local sewists, losing a major hub like this isn't just about losing a place to buy thread; it's about losing that tactile experience of feeling the fabric before you commit to five yards of it.
Why Niles Felt Different
There was always something specific about the Niles store. It wasn't just a generic box. Because it sat right in that Trumbull County sweet spot, it drew in people from Warren, Howland, and even across the border from PA.
The staff there? They'd seen it all. From the frantic high schoolers working on prom dress alterations to the pros who had been quilting since before the mall was built.
📖 Related: Weather Bellmore NY Hourly: Why Your App Might Be Lying to You
- The Sewing Studio: One of the biggest losses for the Niles community was the specialized sewing machine area. It wasn't just a shelf of Singers; they actually did demos and held classes.
- Custom Framing: This was often the "secret" part of the store. People would bring in everything from diplomas to vintage sports jerseys.
- The Seasonal Aisle: You know the one. In Niles, that aisle would transition from "vaguely fall" to "full-blown Christmas" faster than you could say Youngstown cookie table.
The Gift Card Drama
If you’re sitting on a gift card right now, pay attention. During the liquidation process that hit many Ohio stores in late 2025, there was a massive amount of confusion.
I’ve seen reports of customers showing up to Niles or the Boardman location only to be told their plastic was basically a bookmark. Basically, once a store enters a full liquidation phase run by third-party companies like Gordon Brothers, they often stop accepting Joann-branded gift cards or rewards certificates. It’s frustrating. It feels like theft when you’ve got $50 in credit that suddenly vanishes because of a court filing.
If you have a card, the move is to use it online immediately—if the site is even still processing them—or check if a nearby "survivor" store is still honoring them before they all potentially go dark.
Where Do We Go Now?
With the Joann Fabrics in Niles Ohio winding down its presence, the "crafting desert" is becoming a real thing for some. Local hobbyists are having to pivot.
Some are heading to the big-box competitors like Hobby Lobby or Michael's, but those stores don't always have the same depth of apparel fabric or specific sewing notions. Others are going old-school and hunting for independent quilt shops in the smaller towns surrounding Niles. There’s something kinda nice about that, actually. Supporting a small business that knows your name might be the silver lining in this corporate collapse.
What to do if you’re still looking for supplies:
- Check the Liquidators: If the Niles store is still in its final weeks, you can snag some insane deals, but don’t expect the staff to be able to help with technical questions. They’re usually just trying to clear the floor.
- Verify Class Credits: If you paid for a sewing class that never happened, you might need to contact the Joann corporate restructuring site (joannrestructuring.com) to see about a refund claim. Don't expect the local store manager to have the cash in the drawer.
- Local Groups: Join some of the Youngstown/Warren Facebook crafting groups. People are sharing where they’re finding the best deals and which local shops are picking up the slack for repairs and classes.
The era of the massive fabric warehouse in Niles might be ending, but the people who make stuff? They aren't going anywhere. We'll just find new places to congregate, even if it's a bit further of a drive.
Check your email for any "Smiles" rewards you haven't redeemed yet. If the Niles store is still open for its final liquidation days, bring those coupons but be prepared for them to say no—the rules change daily when a store is closing its doors for good.