Honestly, the American Idol finale is usually where the hype starts to die down for anyone who didn't take home the big trophy. But for John Foster, finishing as the runner-up in Season 23 (2025) was basically just the opening act. People were scouring the internet for weeks asking the same thing: when is the first John Foster post-idol music video coming out?
He didn't make them wait long.
While winner Jamal Roberts was busy with the immediate victory lap, John went back to his roots. He didn't drop some over-produced pop track or a flashy Nashville sizzle reel. Instead, he released a raw, one-take video for "Amazing Grace" (La Grâce du Ciel). It wasn't just a cover; it was a nod to his Louisiana upbringing, complete with a verse in Cajun French.
The First Post-Idol Music Video: A Strategic Pivot?
Most Idol finalists try to strike while the iron is hot with a high-budget production. John did the opposite. The "Amazing Grace" video, captured by Fable House at Celtic Studios in Baton Rouge, felt more like a prayer than a promo.
It was smart.
By choosing a hymn and singing in Cajun French, he solidified his brand as a "Neo-Traditional" country artist. He wasn't trying to be the next big radio star right out of the gate; he was telling his 5 million viewers that he’s the same guy from Addis, Louisiana, who brought the judges boudin and cracklins during his audition.
The video dropped on May 31, 2025, just about two weeks after the finale. It was a "thank you" to the fans he calls "family." For a guy who spent the season proving he was "good enough," this video was the proof that he didn't need the title of "Idol" to have a voice.
👉 See also: How to Nail Stranger Things Birthday Invitations Without Looking Like a Total Mouth Breather
Why "Tell That Angel I Love Her" Is the Real Story
You can't talk about a John Foster post-idol music video without mentioning the song that actually put him on the map. During the Top 20, John performed an original called "Tell That Angel I Love Her." It's a heavy one.
He wrote it for his best friend, Maggie Dunn, and her friend Caroline Gill. They were killed in a tragic car accident on New Year’s Eve 2022 involving a police chase. That performance—and the subsequent "2025 Version" of the single released under Arista Nashville—is what really fueled his post-show momentum.
- The Emotional Hook: Millions of people watched Maggie’s mom in the audience during the show.
- The Authentic Songwriting: John wrote the track solo, which is rare for reality show contestants who usually rely on professional songwriters.
- The Nashville Deal: Arista Nashville didn't wait. They saw the streaming numbers and signed him, leading to the official re-release of the single in July 2025.
From the Bayou to the Opry
While fans were watching his YouTube clips, John was actually living out a country music fever dream. He made his Grand Ole Opry debut on June 7, 2025. Think about that. Less than a month after the Idol finale, he was standing in the circle.
He didn't just play once, either.
By the end of 2025, he’d performed at the Opry eight different times, covering everything from George Strait to Keith Whitley. This wasn't just luck. His deep, baritone voice—the one that made Luke Bryan do a literal double-take during auditions—is tailor-made for that stage.
What Most People Get Wrong About His Career
There’s this weird misconception that if you don't win Idol, you’ve failed. Tell that to Morgan Wallen or Gabby Barrett.
John's path is looking a lot more like a slow-burn success story. He’s been busy. Very busy. Since the show ended, he's popped up in the Rose Parade on New Year’s Day 2026, representing Louisiana on a float with a 100,000-rose pelican chef. He’s also been touring through Texas, Florida, and even Switzerland.
He recently released another single in October 2025 called "Little Goes A Long Way." It’s a bit more upbeat than his early stuff but keeps that same grounded feel. It’s clear he’s trying to build a "body of work," as he put it, rather than just chasing a viral moment.
What's actually in the works:
- A Full-Length Album: He’s been teasing this in almost every interview. It’s expected to drop sometime in mid-2026.
- More Duets: He’s stayed close with fellow finalist Breanna Nix. They’ve done a few live performances together that fans are begging to see as official recordings.
- The "Neo-Traditional" Label: He’s leaning hard into the 90s country aesthetic. Think hats, starch-crisp shirts, and songs about real life.
Is the Hype Sustainable?
Kinda. The challenge for any Idol alum is staying relevant once the next season starts. John has a few things going for him that others don't. First, he has a very specific niche: the faith-based, traditional country market. That audience is incredibly loyal.
Second, he’s a valedictorian. The kid is smart. He’s not just letting a label dictate his every move; he’s talking about the "legal work" and the "studio process" with a level of maturity you don't usually see from an 18-year-old.
He’s admitted he was "shook" to be in the top two, but he’s also made it clear that he’s at peace with it. That lack of desperation is probably why he’s actually succeeding. He’s not trying to be a "star"—he’s trying to be a musician.
Your Next Steps to Follow John’s Journey
If you’re looking to keep up with John Foster beyond just the "Amazing Grace" video, here is exactly where you need to look:
- Watch the "Amazing Grace (La Grâce du Ciel)" video on his official YouTube channel to see the raw, one-take performance that defined his post-show start.
- Stream the 2025 Version of "Tell That Angel I Love Her" on Apple Music or Spotify; it has much higher production value than the audition version.
- Check his official website (johnfmusic.com) for his 2026 tour dates, especially if you’re in the South or planning to catch a show in Nashville.
- Follow his Instagram for "Fable House" updates, as he often records intimate acoustic sessions there that don't always make it to the major streaming platforms.