You’ve probably seen the grainy cell phone footage by now. Two guys, both past their professional primes, nearly coming to blows on a humid New Orleans night while tourists in beads just sort of shuffle past. It’s a weird sight. On one side, you have Pat Mahomes Sr., the father of the NFL’s golden boy. On the other, John Rocker, a name that mostly functions as a cautionary tale for 90s baseball fans.
What exactly brings a Super Bowl dad and a retired Braves firebrand together for a shouting match in the middle of Bourbon Street?
Honestly, it’s a mix of old baseball rivalries, modern social media clout, and a “boxing” match that sounds more like a fever dream than a sporting event. People were confused. They should be. It’s not every day you see the father of a three-time Super Bowl MVP trading insults with a guy who once famously insulted the entire 7 train in New York.
The Bourbon Street Blowup
The confrontation went down during Super Bowl LIX week in February 2025. Patrick Mahomes Jr. and the Kansas City Chiefs were in town to face the Philadelphia Eagles. While the younger Mahomes was focused on the game—which the Chiefs eventually lost 40-22—his father was having a much different experience.
In the viral video, Rocker approaches Mahomes Sr. outside a bar. Rocker extends a hand, seemingly for a handshake. Mahomes Sr. isn't having it. He pulls his hand back, starts gesturing wildly, and the air fills with expletives. It wasn't a friendly "long time no see" moment. It was tense.
Bystanders eventually stepped in. As Mahomes was ushered away, Rocker allegedly threw a cup of ice or a drink in his direction. The whole thing looked like a scene from a reality show that had gone off the rails.
Why do they even know each other?
It’s easy to forget that Pat Mahomes Sr. was a legit Major League pitcher for over a decade. He wasn't just "Patrick's dad." He played for the Mets in 1999 and 2000. That’s the exact window when John Rocker was the most hated man in New York. Rocker was the closer for the Atlanta Braves, the Mets' biggest rival at the time.
🔗 Read more: Oscar De La Hoya Net Worth: Why the Golden Boy is Still Winning
Rocker had also just given that infamous Sports Illustrated interview where he disparaged New York City’s diversity. The tension between those two teams was at an all-time high. While they weren't direct rivals on the mound, they occupied the same space during one of baseball's most heated eras.
The Social Media War
If you thought the argument ended when the cameras stopped rolling, you don't know John Rocker. He took to X (formerly Twitter) almost immediately. He called Mahomes Sr. a "loser" who couldn't take a joke. He even went as far as to tweet "F*** PATRICK MAHOMES."
Mahomes Sr. didn't stay quiet either. He fired back, calling Rocker a "menace to society" and telling him to keep his name out of his "loud mouth."
"You really haven't changed one bit in the last 25 years," Mahomes Sr. wrote.
That line hits home. Rocker’s reputation has been frozen in time since 1999. Even after a stint on Survivor in 2014, where he was voted off almost immediately after being recognized, he hasn't exactly leaned into a "redemption arc."
Was it all a Barstool Stunt?
Here’s where it gets kinda greasy. Shortly after the video went viral, Dave Portnoy of Barstool Sports entered the chat. He claimed that the two were scheduled to fight in a "Rough N' Rowdy" boxing match.
Suddenly, the Bourbon Street fight looked less like a spontaneous outburst and more like a promo for a pay-per-view. Critics pointed out how convenient it was that cameras were perfectly positioned to catch the "organic" beef.
The fight details were supposedly:
- Event: Rough N' Rowdy
- Date: Scheduled for April 18, 2025
- Format: Three one-minute rounds of amateur-style boxing
But as the date approached, the match fell apart. In April 2025, Rocker went on another rant, claiming that Mahomes Sr. backed out of the fight. He blamed Patrick Mahomes Jr. and his wife, Brittany, saying they stepped in to stop the elder Mahomes because it was a "bad look" for the family brand.
The Mahomes Family Dynamic
It’s no secret that the Mahomes family has had a rough couple of years in the headlines. Mahomes Sr. has faced multiple legal issues, including a third DWI arrest in 2024 that led to jail time and probation.
When you’re the face of the NFL like Patrick is, your family’s baggage becomes your baggage. The younger Mahomes has generally stayed out of his father’s public spats. He’s the ultimate professional, a stark contrast to the chaotic energy his father and John Rocker brought to New Orleans.
Rocker, meanwhile, seems to thrive in the chaos. Since retiring from baseball in 2003, he’s popped up occasionally in political circles or reality TV, usually saying something designed to get a rise out of people. Comparing the two is like comparing a surgical strike to a grenade with the pin pulled.
Real Talk: Does it actually matter?
In the grand scheme of sports history? No. It’s a footnote. But as a cultural moment, it says a lot about how we consume sports now. We’ve moved from "who’s the best pitcher" to "who’s going to fight in a Barstool boxing ring."
Here is what we know for sure:
- The confrontation in New Orleans was real, but its "spontaneity" is highly debated.
- The rivalry dates back to the 1999-2000 Mets vs. Braves era.
- The proposed boxing match never happened, likely due to pressure from the Mahomes camp to protect their brand.
- John Rocker hasn't softened his image; if anything, he's doubled down.
If you’re looking for a takeaway, it’s probably this: legacy is a fragile thing. Pat Mahomes Sr. has a legacy as a pro athlete and the father of a legend, but he’s currently treading water in the world of viral controversy. John Rocker’s legacy is already written in stone—he's the guy people love to hate.
What to Watch for Next
If you're following this saga, don't expect a civil resolution. Rocker is still active on social media and rarely misses a chance to take a jab at the Mahomes family when they are in the news.
Next steps for fans:
- Check the sources: When you see a "viral" athlete fight, look for the promoter's watermark. If Barstool or a similar outlet is attached, it's likely a work.
- Separate the athlete from the family: Patrick Mahomes Jr. is responsible for his play on the field; he can't control what his dad does on Bourbon Street.
- Understand the history: The Rocker-Mahomes beef makes zero sense without the context of late-90s NL East baseball.
The era of the "celebrity" athlete grudge match isn't going anywhere. Whether it's retired pitchers or YouTube stars, the formula remains the same: find a grievance, film it, and try to sell tickets. Just don't expect a high-level athletic performance when the bell finally rings.