You’ve seen it every October. Two people walk into a party—one with a smeared red grin and the other with mismatched pigtails. It’s the classic Joker and Harley Quinn makeup duo. It’s safe. It’s iconic. But honestly? Most people are still doing the 2016 version, and the world has moved on.
Makeup is storytelling. If you’re just slapping on some white greasepaint and calling it a day, you’re missing the point of why these characters actually look the way they do. Especially now, with the influence of Joker: Folie à Deux, the aesthetic has shifted from "costume" to "grotesque realism."
The Death of Perfection
Professional makeup artist Nicki Ledermann, who worked on both Joker films, has a specific philosophy: "ninja-style makeup." She doesn't want it to look like a pro did it. She wants it to look like Arthur Fleck or Lee Quinzel did it themselves in a dimly lit bathroom.
This is the first thing people get wrong. They try to make the lines perfect. They use stencils. They spend three hours on a wing that’s supposed to look like it was applied during a manic episode.
📖 Related: Cast of Fred 3 Camp Fred: What the Actors Are Doing in 2026
Stop.
Realism comes from asymmetry. In the 2024 sequel, the Joker's smile isn't even. It pulls higher on the left side. The blue triangles under the eyes aren't carbon copies of each other. If you’re aiming for the modern look, you need to lean into the "perfectly imperfect."
How to Get the Base Right Without Looking Like a Ghost
Don't just buy the cheapest "clown white" from a pop-up Halloween store. It'll crack before you even finish your first drink.
Instead, look at what was actually used on Joaquin Phoenix. Ledermann used M.A.C. Chromacakes. These are water-activated. To get that streaky, organic look, you mix the white with a little water and brush it on unevenly. You want your natural skin texture to peek through in spots. It makes the character feel human and, frankly, a lot scarier.
- Prep your skin: Use a good moisturizer like Bioderma Hydrabio Gel Cream. If your skin is dry, the makeup will flake.
- The White Wash: Apply your pale base (or white pigment) with a damp sponge or a fluffy brush. Don't go for 100% opacity.
- Set it: A translucent powder like Huda Beauty Easy Bake is a lifesaver. It stops the "melting" look while keeping the matte finish.
Harley’s Evolution: From Jester to Grunge
Harley Quinn’s look has changed more than almost any other comic character. You’ve got the 1992 Animated Series jester look, the New 52 roller derby vibe, and the Margot Robbie "Suicide Squad" glam.
But the Lady Gaga version? That's a different beast.
It’s grimy. It’s 1970s downtown New York. It’s thrifted and raw. If you're going for this specific Joker and Harley Quinn makeup style, you need to ditch the bright, neon pink and blue. Think "deep berry" and "midnight blue."
Sarah Tanno, Gaga’s long-time makeup artist, focused on "unlearning technique" for this role. For the courtroom scenes, the makeup is smeared but deliberate. It’s the look of someone who has been crying and laughing at the same time.
🔗 Read more: Why Smooth Criminal by MJ Still Defines Pop Perfection Decades Later
The "Smudge" Technique
To get that authentic Harley smudge, don't use a brush. Use your fingers.
Apply a bold red or deep blue shadow to the lid, then literally drag your index finger downward from the outer corner. This creates a "teardrop" effect that looks like gravity did the work.
"She’s not supposed to be glam. She’s grungy, dirty, and a bit messed up." — Miranda van R, Makeup Creator.
Choosing Your Products (2026 Trends)
The market has changed. We're seeing a massive shift toward "stained" looks rather than heavy layers. For 2026, the trend is moving toward stained lips with a balmy finish.
If you want the Harley lip to last through a whole convention or party, you need a liquid matte. But don't keep the edges crisp. Use a cotton swab to blur the lip line while the product is still slightly tacky.
- For the Lips: NYX Liquid Suede or Danessa Myricks Evolution Powder for a blackened-red effect.
- For the Eyes: ColourPop Crème Gel Eyeliners are great because they give you about 30 seconds of "smudge time" before they lock in and become waterproof.
- The Heart Tattoo: Use a waterproof liquid liner. Don't use a pencil; it'll migrate to your cheekbone by midnight.
The Joker’s "Chelsea Smile"
If you’re going for the Heath Ledger or Jared Leto iterations, you’re dealing with texture, not just color.
For the scars, you can use 3rd Degree Silicone. It’s a two-part system that you mix together and sculpt directly on the skin. It mimics real flesh. Once it sets, you paint over it with your red pigment.
If that’s too technical, a "scabbing blood" or a dark red lip stain works. Just remember: the Joker’s mouth is supposed to look like a wound, not a lipstick ad.
Actionable Tips for Longevity
You don't want to look like a melting candle two hours into your event.
- Layering is King: Apply a cream product first, then "lock" it with a matching powder shadow. Red cream shadow followed by red powder shadow will not move.
- The Double Set: Use a setting powder, then a heavy-duty setting spray like One/Size On 'Til Dawn.
- The "Rotten" Detail: If you’re doing the face tattoos, dust them with a tiny bit of translucent powder. It takes away the "marker" shine and makes it look like it’s actually under your skin.
What People Always Forget
The neck.
People spend hours on their face and then leave their neck perfectly tan. It ruins the illusion. Whatever base color you use, drag it down past your jawline. Blend it into your collarbones.
Also, the teeth. If you're the Joker, bright white teeth look weird against a dingy, stained face. You can use Nicotine Tooth Enamel (it’s a safe, temporary paint) to give that "I haven't seen a dentist in Arkham" look.
Moving Forward
Creating a high-quality Joker and Harley Quinn makeup look is about embracing the chaos. Start by picking your "era." Are you the classic 90s duo, the 2016 glam-squad, or the 2024 operatic tragedy?
Once you’ve picked, focus on the eyes first. They carry the emotion. Everything else—the white skin, the red lips—is just background noise.
To take this to the next level, practice your "asymmetry" on a piece of paper first. Try drawing the Joker's smile without looking in a mirror. The more natural and "unthinking" the application feels, the more authentic the final result will look to everyone else.