It starts with that specific jingle. You know the one. It’s early November, you’re walking through a Target or scrolling through a holiday playlist, and suddenly a teenage voice from 2011 is crooning about "shawty" and "the fire’s light."
Most pop stars try to make a holiday album once in their career. Most fail. They end up with a collection of elevator-music covers that get played for one season and then buried in the digital graveyard of Spotify’s seasonal section. But the Justin Bieber christmas song—specifically the juggernaut that is "Mistletoe"—refuses to die. In fact, it’s arguably more relevant now than when it first dropped.
Why? Because it’s a weirdly perfect time capsule.
Back in 2011, Bieber was at the peak of his "Bieber Fever" era. He had the hair, the purple hoodies, and a fan base that would literally scream at a cardboard cutout. When he announced Under the Mistletoe, the industry expected a cash grab. What they got was a record that debuted at number one on the Billboard 200, making him the first male artist to have a Christmas album enter at the top spot.
The "Mistletoe" Blueprint: How One Song Beat the Odds
Let's be honest for a second. Writing a new Christmas song is a suicide mission. You’re competing against Mariah Carey, Wham!, and Bing Crosby. You aren't just fighting contemporary artists; you're fighting seventy years of nostalgia and "All I Want for Christmas Is You."
The lead Justin Bieber christmas song, "Mistletoe," succeeded because it didn't try to be a big, orchestral anthem. It went the opposite direction. It’s basically a stripped-down acoustic pop track with a slight reggae-inflected rhythm. It sounds more like Jason Mraz than "Silent Night."
It felt modern.
The lyrics are undeniably of their time. Using the word "shawty" in a Christmas carol is a choice that probably shouldn't work, yet for an entire generation of Gen Z and Millennials, it’s now a core memory. It’s the bridge between the old-school tradition of the holidays and the 2010s pop explosion.
Produced by The Messengers, the track was designed to be "sticky." It doesn't rely on heavy sleigh bells or a 50-piece choir. Instead, it leans into a catchy guitar loop that stays in your head for three days. It was a calculated risk that paid off. Today, "Mistletoe" consistently racks up hundreds of millions of streams every single December, often outperforming many "classic" carols.
Collaborations That Shouldn't Have Worked (But Did)
If you look at the tracklist of the Under the Mistletoe album, it looks like a fever dream. You’ve got Boyz II Men, Busta Rhymes, Usher, and... Mariah Carey herself.
The "All I Want for Christmas Is You (SuperFestive!)" duet is a fascinating piece of pop history. At the time, critics were skeptical. Why would Mariah re-record her magnum opus with a kid who was barely born when the original came out?
- The Mariah Factor: By partnering with the Queen of Christmas, Bieber essentially got "baptized" into the holiday canon. It gave the project instant legitimacy.
- The "Drummer Boy" feat. Busta Rhymes is perhaps the most unhinged Christmas cover ever recorded. Bieber raps. Busta Rhymes goes at 100 miles per hour. It’s chaotic. It’s loud. It shouldn't exist. And yet, it’s a fan favorite because it’s so wildly different from the slow, somber versions we’re used to.
- "Fa La La" with Boyz II Men showed off Bieber’s actual vocal range. This wasn't just studio magic; it was a kid holding his own with R&B legends.
These collaborations weren't just about the music. They were about positioning. By working with these icons, the Justin Bieber christmas song catalog became something more than just "teen pop." It became a bridge between different musical eras.
The Longevity of "Mistletoe" in the Streaming Era
TikTok changed everything for holiday music.
👉 See also: Witness Mindless Self Indulgence: Why the Chaos Still Matters
A few years ago, songs like "Mistletoe" might have started to fade as Bieber’s newer, more "mature" hits like "Peaches" or "Stay" took over. Instead, the opposite happened. The holiday tracks became viral sounds.
The nostalgia cycle has shortened. People who were ten years old when "Mistletoe" came out are now in their twenties. They aren't just listening to it ironically; they’re listening because it represents their childhood.
Data from platforms like Chartmetric shows a massive spike in Bieber’s holiday catalog starting as early as November 1st every year. It’s not just a one-day wonder on December 25th. It’s a two-month-long revenue machine. In 2023, "Mistletoe" was still hitting the Global Top 50 on Spotify during the week of Christmas. That kind of staying power is rare. Very rare.
Why "Drummer Boy" Still Divides the Internet
We have to talk about the rap.
In "Drummer Boy," Bieber delivers lines like, "I'm the boy that's playable, my heart is breakable." It’s peak 2011. Some people find it incredibly cringeworthy. Others find it to be the only "fun" Christmas song on their playlist.
The sheer audacity of turning a traditional 1941 carol into a fast-paced hip-hop track is what makes it memorable. In the world of SEO and viral content, being "fine" is the worst thing you can be. Being polarizing is great. People talk about it. They share it. They argue about whether it’s a "bop" or a "disaster."
The result? Millions of more views.
Vocal Evolution: 2011 vs. Now
There’s a stark difference between the Bieber on Under the Mistletoe and the Bieber we hear today. His voice back then was higher, thinner, and full of that youthful "rasp" that defined the era.
If you listen to his live performances of these songs from recent years, the arrangement usually changes. He slows them down. He adds more soul. He leans into the R&B influences that he’s explored in albums like Journals and Justice.
This evolution is part of the appeal. Fans have grown up with him. Hearing the 17-year-old version of him sing about the mistletoe while seeing the 30-year-old man he’s become creates a weird, beautiful sense of continuity.
The Cultural Impact of the Music Video
Shot in Franklin, Tennessee, the "Mistletoe" music video is basically a Hallmark movie condensed into three minutes. Fake snow. A vintage car. A girl who looks suspiciously like a stand-in for Selena Gomez (the internet spent months dissecting that one).
👉 See also: Pink and Chris Stapleton: Why Love Me Anyway Still Hits Different
It sold a vibe. It wasn't about the North Pole or elves; it was about a small-town winter romance. That relatable "down-to-earth" aesthetic helped the song feel less like a commercial product and more like a personal story.
Is There a New Justin Bieber Christmas Song Coming?
Rumors constantly swirl about a "Volume 2."
Given the success of the first one, it seems like a no-brainer. However, Bieber has been selective about his output lately. He’s focused on health and family. But in the world of pop, a holiday single is the gift that keeps on giving.
Even if he never records another holiday note, the existing Justin Bieber christmas song library is enough to keep him on the charts for the next three decades. He cracked the code. He made a song that feels like the holidays without feeling like a cliché.
What most people get wrong is thinking these songs are just for "Beliebers." They aren't. They’ve moved past the fandom and into the general public consciousness. They are "mall music" in the best way possible—the kind of songs that provide the background noise to our lives every December.
Making the Most of the Bieber Holiday Catalog
If you’re looking to refresh your December playlist, don't just stick to the radio edits.
- Try the Acoustic Versions: There are several "stripped" versions of these tracks that highlight the songwriting over the production.
- Watch the live "Home for the Holidays" performances: These show the raw energy of that era.
- Mix it up: Put "Drummer Boy" right after a Frank Sinatra track. The tonal shift is hilarious and keeps the holiday party from getting too sleepy.
The real lesson here? Never underestimate a pop star with a plan. Justin Bieber didn't just record a Christmas album; he claimed a piece of the most lucrative season in the music industry.
The next time you hear that guitar intro to "Mistletoe," don't fight it. Just lean in. It’s part of the tradition now.
Step-by-Step: How to Add These to Your Holiday Strategy
- Audit your current playlist: If it’s 90% songs from before 1970, it’s going to feel stale. You need "bridge" songs like "Mistletoe" to keep the energy up.
- Check out the 10th Anniversary Content: In 2021, a lot of "visualizers" and behind-the-scenes clips were released for the album. They’re worth a watch if you want to see the making of a holiday classic.
- Focus on the R&B tracks: If you aren't into "teen pop," listen to "Fa La La" or "Christmas Eve." They lean much harder into 90s R&B vibes and are genuinely great vocal performances.
- Observe the streaming patterns: Use sites like Kworb or Spotify Charts in December. It’s a masterclass in how certain songs—like the Justin Bieber christmas song—gradually climb the ranks as the big day approaches.