Let’s be real for a second. When the first posters for Kaathu Vaakula Rendu Kadhal dropped, featuring Vijay Sethupathi flanked by Nayanthara and Samantha Ruth Prabhu, the internet basically lost its mind. It was the kind of casting coup that felt like a fever dream. You had the "Makkal Selvan," the "Lady Superstar," and the reigning queen of South Indian cinema all in one frame. People expected a massive, game-changing romantic epic. What they actually got was a messy, loud, often chaotic exploration of polyamory wrapped in the skin of a commercial Kollywood comedy.
Vignesh Shivan has always had this specific vibe. He’s the guy who gave us Naanum Rowdy Dhaan, a movie that balanced dark humor with genuine soul. But with this one? He took a massive swing. It’s a film about a guy named Rambo—short for Ranjankudi Anbarasu Murugesa Boopathy—who believes he’s cursed. This guy thinks his very existence brings bad luck to those he loves. So, naturally, when he falls for two women simultaneously, his solution isn't to choose. It’s to try and keep them both.
It's a wild premise. Some people loved the audacity. Others found it deeply problematic or just plain exhausting.
The Rambo Dilemma and the Curse of Bad Luck
The story kicks off with a heavy dose of superstition. Rambo, played with a sort of weary, hangdog charm by Vijay Sethupathi, grows up believing that if he stays with someone, they die or suffer. This isn't just a quirky character trait; it’s the engine of the entire plot. He works two jobs—a cab driver by day and a bouncer by night—essentially living two lives. This duality sets the stage for his two romances.
He meets Kanmani (Nayanthara) during his day shift. She’s poised, maternal, and carrying the weight of her family on her shoulders. Then there’s Khatija (Samantha), whom he meets at the club. She’s fierce, independent, and looking for an escape from a suffocating relationship.
The film tries to convince us that Rambo isn't a "player" in the traditional sense. He’s depicted as a man who is so starved for affection that when it finally comes from two different directions, he’s physically unable to say no to either. It’s a classic "have your cake and eat it too" scenario, but dressed up in the melodrama of a man who thinks he’s saving them by not fully committing to just one. Honestly, the logic is a bit of a stretch, but Sethupathi sells the desperation well enough that you almost—almost—feel for him.
A Masterclass in Casting vs. Character Depth
We have to talk about the chemistry. Or the lack thereof, depending on who you ask.
The scenes where all three are on screen together are the film's highlights. There’s a specific energy when Samantha and Nayanthara trade barbs. For years, fans had pitted these two against each other in "who is the bigger star" debates. Seeing them share a screen was a monumental moment for Tamil cinema. Samantha, in particular, seemed to be having a blast. Her portrayal of Khatija brought a much-needed spark to the second half, especially when the script started to drag.
Nayanthara, on the other hand, played the more grounded Kanmani. It’s a role she’s played before, but her screen presence is undeniable. The problem? The movie doesn't always know what to do with them beyond their relationship to Rambo. They are two powerhouses relegated to fighting over a guy who, let’s be honest, is kind of a mess.
The Anirudh Factor: Why the Music Carried the Movie
If there is one thing everyone agreed on, it was the soundtrack. Anirudh Ravichander is basically the MVP here.
"Two Two Two" became an instant anthem. It was catchy, vibrant, and perfectly captured the frantic energy of the film. Then you had "Naan Pizhai," a soulful melody that made the romance feel much more profound than the dialogue often allowed. Without Anirudh’s score, Kaathu Vaakula Rendu Kadhal would have felt significantly flatter. The music provided the emotional scaffolding that the screenplay occasionally forgot to build. It’s a testament to how a great OST can elevate a mediocre script into something that feels like an "event."
Addressing the Polyamory Elephant in the Room
This is where the movie gets polarizing. Vignesh Shivan attempted to navigate the concept of "double dating" or "two loves" in a culture that is traditionally very monogamous.
The film tries to play it for laughs. It uses the "mental balance" argument—Rambo claims he needs both women to stay sane and break his curse. But is it actually a progressive look at polyamory? Not really. It’s more of a male fantasy masquerading as a rom-com. The women are eventually asked to "share" him, a resolution that felt dated to many modern viewers.
Yet, there is a segment of the audience that appreciated the attempt to talk about unconventional relationships at all. In a film industry that often treats romance as a black-and-white, "happily ever after with one person" deal, this was a messy, gray-area experiment. It didn't necessarily succeed in being a deep philosophical dive, but it started conversations. People were talking about the ethics of Rambo's choices for weeks after the release.
Why the Humor Didn't Always Land
Comedy is subjective. We know this. But in this movie, the humor felt a bit disjointed. Redin Kingsley and the supporting cast did their best with the slapstick elements, but the tonal shifts were jarring. You’d go from a heavy emotional scene about Rambo’s dead father to a wacky misunderstanding involving a fake wedding.
It’s that classic "Masala" style—a little bit of everything thrown into a blender. Sometimes it tastes great. Sometimes it’s just a weird brown mush. Kaathu Vaakula Rendu Kadhal often teetered on the edge of that mush. The "dippy-dippy" sequences and the over-the-top reactions worked for the front-benchers but left the critics cold.
The Production Reality: Delays and Expectations
It’s easy to forget that this movie took a long time to reach the screen. Announced years before its 2022 release, the anticipation grew to levels that were almost impossible to satisfy. When you tell fans for three years that the two biggest female stars in the industry are doing a movie together, their expectations move from "I hope it’s good" to "This must be a masterpiece."
The film was shot across Chennai and Pondicherry, and you can see the visual flair that Vignesh Shivan and cinematographer SR Kathir brought to the table. The colors are saturated, the frames are busy, and it looks like a big-budget celebration. But the production delays meant that by the time it came out, the "hype train" was so fast it was bound to derail for some people.
Regional Reception vs. Global Streaming
When the film hit theaters, the reception in Tamil Nadu was decent. It did well at the box office, largely thanks to the star power. However, its life on streaming platforms (it landed on Disney+ Hotstar) is where the real debate intensified.
Digital audiences tend to be more vocal about tropes and gender dynamics. The "two-heroine" trope is as old as cinema itself, but the way Rambo manipulated—even if unintentionally—the emotions of Kanmani and Khatija didn't sit well with a lot of Twitter/X armchair critics. Conversely, many viewers just saw it as a "time-pass" entertainer. They weren't looking for a treatise on modern dating; they wanted to see Vijay Sethupathi be funny and listen to Anirudh's beats.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Ending
There’s a common complaint that the ending was a cop-out. Without spoiling the final frames for the three people who haven't seen it, the resolution is... well, it’s indecisive.
Many viewers wanted Rambo to "choose." They wanted a winner. But Shivan’s point—as muddled as it might have been—was that Rambo's curse was his own making. By refusing to choose, he stays in a state of perpetual chaos. It wasn't necessarily a "happy" ending in the traditional sense; it was a stalemate. Whether that's clever writing or a failure to commit to a finale is up for debate.
Actionable Insights for the Casual Viewer
If you’re planning to revisit Kaathu Vaakula Rendu Kadhal or watch it for the first time, here is how to actually enjoy it:
💡 You might also like: Mimi Rogers in Playboy: What Really Happened With That 1993 Cover
- Adjust your expectations: Don't go in expecting a serious exploration of polyamory. Treat it as a screwball comedy with high production values.
- Focus on the performances: Watch Samantha. She really is the standout here, bringing a level of vulnerability to Khatija that the script doesn't always deserve.
- Listen to the subtext of the music: Pay attention to how the background score changes when Rambo is with Kanmani versus when he’s with Khatija. Anirudh actually gave them distinct musical identities.
- Watch it with a crowd: This is a "popcorn" movie. It plays much better when you have people to groan and laugh with than it does as a solo viewing experience.
The legacy of the film isn't going to be its plot. It’s going to be the fact that it proved you could get two massive female stars to headline a film alongside a top-tier hero without the world ending. It broke the "ego" myth that often prevents such casting in the South Indian industry.
Ultimately, the movie is a loud, colorful, flawed, and occasionally brilliant mess. It reflects the chaotic nature of love itself—even if that love is spread a little too thin. If you want a deep dive into the human psyche, look elsewhere. But if you want to see three of India’s best actors having a weirdly good time in a beautiful-looking film, it's worth the three hours.
To get the most out of your viewing, start by putting the soundtrack on repeat. Once those songs are stuck in your head, the logic of the movie starts to matter a whole lot less. You just find yourself humming along to the rhythm of Rambo's confused, double-sided heart. It’s not perfect cinema, but it’s a specific kind of Tamil pop-culture moment that won't be forgotten anytime soon.