When you think of Katie Holmes, you probably think of a few specific snapshots. Maybe it’s the girl-next-door Joey Potter on a pier in North Carolina. Or perhaps it’s the image of her looking slightly dazed while Tom Cruise did a literal Olympic-style jump on Oprah’s sofa.
Honestly? Most people forget how many different "eras" she's actually lived through.
From the early days of teen stardom to the ultra-private years following her high-profile divorce, Katie’s romantic life has been a strange, fascinating barometer for her own personal growth. It hasn’t always been easy. Navigating the fishbowl of Hollywood while trying to raise a daughter is one thing; doing it while every guy you grab coffee with becomes a front-page headline is another entirely.
Katie Holmes Past Boyfriends: The First Love and the "First" Big Breakup
Let’s go back to 1998.
Long before the world knew her as Mrs. Cruise, Katie was just a kid from Toledo who landed a life-changing role on Dawson’s Creek. That’s where she met Joshua Jackson.
If you were a fan of the show, you know Pacey and Joey were "the" couple. In real life, things weren’t much different. Katie has actually gone on record—most famously in a Rolling Stone interview—calling Josh her "first love." It was sweet. It was intense. And then, like most first loves, it ended.
But here is the twist: they stayed friends. Seriously. Decades later, rumors still swirl whenever they’re spotted in the same zip code. In fact, as of late 2025, gossip columns have been buzzing about a possible rekindling after they were seen looking pretty cozy during a reunion event.
The Chris Klein Years
After Jackson, Katie moved on to Chris Klein.
You remember him from American Pie. They were basically the "prom king and queen" of the early 2000s. They met in 2000, and by 2003, they were engaged. It looked like a total slam dunk. But by March 2005, the engagement was off. Klein later told People that they were just "kids" going through a crazy experience together.
The timing of that breakup? It was impeccable. Or suspicious, depending on who you ask.
Weeks after the split from Klein was announced, Katie made her first public appearance with a certain Top Gun pilot.
The TomKat Era and the Great Escape
You can't talk about Katie Holmes past boyfriends without talking about the six-year marriage that changed everything. Tom Cruise didn't just date Katie; he basically launched a campaign for her.
They met in April 2005. Seven weeks later, he was proposing on top of the Eiffel Tower.
The sheer speed was dizzying. Critics called it a PR stunt. Supporters called it a whirlwind. But by 2006, they were married in a massive Scientology ceremony in Italy and had welcomed their daughter, Suri.
Why the divorce actually shocked the world
The end of "TomKat" in 2012 wasn't just a breakup; it was a tactical operation. Katie filed for divorce while Tom was filming in Iceland. She allegedly used disposable phones and secret apartments to orchestrate the split, largely to ensure she got custody of Suri and moved her away from the influence of the Church of Scientology.
For years after, Katie’s dating life went into a total blackout.
👉 See also: Kate Upton Wet T-Shirt: Why That One Moment Still Matters Today
The Mystery of Jamie Foxx
This is where things get really interesting. For a solid five or six years, everyone "knew" Katie was dating Jamie Foxx, but nobody could prove it.
They were first spotted dancing together at a Hamptons benefit in 2013. Then… nothing. For years. There were rumors of a "no-dating" clause in her divorce settlement that prevented her from publicly seeing anyone for five years.
Whether that clause was real or not, they didn't go "official" until the 2019 Met Gala. They looked happy. They were holding hands. And then, just like that, they split a few months later.
Friends close to them mentioned that they basically lived separate lives. He was a night owl and a partier; she was a New York mom focused on a quiet life. Sometimes, the vibes just don't align.
The Post-Pandemic Pivot
After the secrecy of the Foxx years, Katie seemed to decide she was done hiding.
🔗 Read more: Carrie Keagan Breast Size: What Most People Get Wrong
Enter Emilio Vitolo Jr. He was a chef at his family’s famous NYC restaurant, Emilio’s Ballato. In 2020, they were everywhere. We’re talking full-blown PDA on the streets of Manhattan. It was the "Real Katie" era. She wasn't molding herself to fit a movie star's life anymore; she was just a woman dating a guy who liked to cook.
It lasted about eight months.
They reportedly split because their schedules didn't match once the world opened back up. No drama. No messy headlines. Just two people going different ways.
Then came Bobby Wooten III.
In 2022, she was linked to the Grammy-nominated musician. They did the red carpet thing, they looked adorable at the US Open, and they even met each other's families. But again, it fizzled after eight months.
What We’ve Learned About Katie’s Pattern
If you look closely at the list of Katie Holmes past boyfriends, a clear shift happens after 2012.
- Autonomy is king. She stopped being "the girlfriend" and started being the lead in her own story.
- Privacy is a choice, not a cage. She can be secret (Foxx) or loud (Vitolo) depending on how she feels, not what a studio demands.
- The Joshua Jackson tether. There is a reason people still care about Joey and Pacey. That foundation of friendship seems to be the one constant in her life.
Honestly, Katie’s history is a reminder that you can survive a massive, life-altering public event and still find yourself on the other side. She isn't defined by the "couch jump" anymore. She's defined by the quiet, steady way she's navigated the aftermath.
Actionable Takeaway for the Curious
If you're following Katie's journey today, keep an eye on New York City film sets. With the 2025/2026 rumors of a project with Joshua Jackson, the "First Love" era might be making a comeback. Check local NYC sightings or trade publications like Variety to see if the professional reunion is actually turning into something more personal.