It was 2002. A rooftop bar at The Peninsula Hotel in Manhattan. Katie Lee, a 21-year-old college student from West Virginia, was just trying to find the bathroom. Instead, she practically ran into a guy who looked a little familiar. That guy was Billy Joel.
He didn't just say hi. He invited her and her friend for drinks. Then dinner—white truffles and pasta, the whole nine yards. Most people would be shaking. Katie? Honestly, she was kinda unimpressed. She thought he was just a guy who worked at a Broadway show because he took her to see Movin' Out and hopped on stage to sing a few songs. She figured that was just his nightly "gig."
Maybe that’s why he fell for her. The Piano Man had already been through two high-profile marriages with Elizabeth Weber and Christie Brinkley. He was a global icon. And here was this young woman who didn't care about his fame. They bonded over food. Two years later, they were married at his massive estate in Oyster Bay.
💡 You might also like: Becky G Without Makeup: What Most People Get Wrong About Her Glow
The Reality of Being the Third Wife
People talked. A lot. The 33-year age gap was the obvious target. When they tied the knot in 2004, Katie was 23 and Billy was 55. She was actually only four years older than his daughter, Alexa Ray Joel.
But for a while, it worked. Billy seemed rejuvenated. He wrote the song "All My Life" as an anniversary gift for her in 2007. It’s a gorgeous, slow-burn ballad. He even credited her with helping him get back into the swing of things after a long hiatus from songwriting.
Katie wasn't just sitting around being a "rock star wife," either. She was ambitious. She landed the hosting gig for the very first season of Top Chef in 2006. If you go back and watch those old clips, it’s a trip. She was stiff. Critics were brutal. They called her "robotic." She eventually lost that job to Padma Lakshmi, which she later admitted was a huge blow to her confidence.
Why the Marriage Hit the Rocks
By 2009, the rumors were everywhere. You’d see headlines about Katie out late in the city while Billy was tucked away on Long Island with his motorcycles.
The lifestyle clash was real. Billy is a legendary homebody when he isn't on tour. He likes his boats. He likes his quiet. Katie was in her twenties, her career was just starting to take off, and she wanted to be where the action was.
Then there were the rumors. People saw Katie with fashion designer Yigal Azrouel. The tabloids went nuclear. While both Katie and Billy eventually denied any infidelity, the damage was done. In his recent HBO documentary, Billy Joel: And So It Goes, Billy got remarkably candid about his drinking during that era. He mentioned that Katie actually gave him an ultimatum: fix the drinking, or it’s over.
He went to rehab at Betty Ford, but as he says now, he didn't really want to be there. He was doing it for her, not himself. Anyone who has dealt with addiction knows that's a recipe for failure. The connection snapped.
The Divorce and the "Good Terms" Myth
Usually, when celebs say they "remain caring friends" in a press release, it's total PR fluff. With these two, it actually seems kinda true. When they announced their split in June 2009, it wasn't a messy, public brawl.
Katie walked away with a townhouse in New York City (valued around $5.9 million at the time) and her own burgeoning career. She didn't let the Top Chef failure or the divorce define her. It took seven years of pitching, but she eventually became a staple on the Food Network with The Kitchen.
Billy eventually found stability with his fourth wife, Alexis Roderick. They married in 2015 and have two daughters. When the news broke that Billy was expecting a baby at 66, Katie told the press she was "really happy for them." No salt. No shade.
What We Can Learn from the Joel-Lee Years
It’s easy to look at a 33-year age gap and assume it’s all about money or a mid-life crisis. But looking back, their relationship was more of a bridge.
For Billy, Katie was a spark of energy during a period where he felt musically stagnant. For Katie, the marriage provided a platform, sure, but it also forced her to grow a thick skin. She learned how to handle public failure and intense scrutiny before she even hit 30.
Basically, it was a chapter that didn't have a happy ending, but it had a purpose. They weren't "the one" for each other, but they were the right people for that specific moment in their lives.
✨ Don't miss: Stassi Schroeder Before Chin Implant: What Really Happened
Next Steps for Fans and Readers:
- Check out the documentary: If you want the raw version, watch Billy Joel: And So It Goes on HBO Max. Billy's honesty about his sobriety and his past marriages is pretty refreshing.
- Revisit the music: Listen to "All My Life" (2007). It’s one of the few love songs he wrote in the 21st century, and you can hear how much he cared for her at the time.
- Follow Katie’s career: She’s a great example of a "career pivot." If you're struggling with a professional setback, her story of being fired from Top Chef only to become a Food Network star is actually really inspiring.