You walk into the chaos of 205 East Houston Street and someone shoves a small ticket into your hand. Do not lose that ticket. Seriously. If you drop that little scrap of paper, you’re looking at a $50 "lost ticket" fee at the exit, even if you only bought a Dr. Brown's Cel-Ray soda.
Most people come here for the pastrami. It’s the star of the show, the one everyone posts on Instagram, and the meat that made Meg Ryan famous in When Harry Met Sally. But if you’re only eating the pastrami, you’re missing the actual soul of the Jewish deli. The Katz’s corned beef sandwich is the quiet, reliable legend that actually tells the story of how this place survived since 1888.
The 30-Day Secret Nobody Mentions
If you buy corned beef at a supermarket, it’s basically "pumped" meat. Big industrial processors take a brisket and inject it with brine using hundreds of needles. It’s cured in 36 hours. It’s fast, efficient, and frankly, a little rubbery.
Katz’s Delicatessen doesn't do that. They still use a slow-cure method that takes up to 30 days. Think about that for a second. While most restaurants are worried about what they’re serving tomorrow, the guys at Katz’s are preparing the meat you’re going to eat a month from now. They submerge the beef brisket in a saltwater brine loaded with their proprietary blend of pickling spices. No injections. Just time and salt.
This is why the texture is different. It’s not "springy" like the stuff you get at a deli counter in the suburbs. It’s dense but tender. It pulls apart with a fork, but it doesn't turn into mush.
Corned Beef vs. Pastrami: The Rivalry
You’ve got to understand the mechanical difference here. Both start as beef, sure. But pastrami is the navel cut—it’s fattier, smoked, and rubbed with a heavy crust of black pepper and coriander.
The Katz’s corned beef sandwich uses the brisket. It’s a leaner cut, though at Katz’s, "lean" is a relative term. Instead of being smoked, the corned beef is boiled and then steamed. This pulls out some of the saltiness from the month-long brine and replaces it with a moist, silky texture.
Jake Dell, the fifth-generation owner, has noted that for the first century of the deli's existence, corned beef actually outsold pastrami two-to-one. It was only in the last few decades that the pastrami took the crown. Honestly? The corned beef is for the purists. It’s for the people who want to taste the beef and the brine without the distraction of heavy smoke.
How to Order Like a Local
Don't be the person who asks for mayo. Just don't. The carvers might actually give you a look that makes you want to crawl under the table.
When you get to the counter, find a carver who looks like he’s seen everything. Hand over your ticket. You want the corned beef on rye.
- The Mustard: Use the deli mustard. It’s spicy, vinegary, and cuts through the richness of the brisket.
- The Slicing: This is the most important part. Katz’s is one of the few places left that hand-slices everything. Why? Because a machine blade creates friction, which heats up the fat and changes the flavor. Hand-slicing keeps the meat cool and allows the carver to cut against the grain with surgical precision.
- The Tip: You’ll see a little tip jar on the counter. Drop a dollar or two in there before they start slicing. Your sandwich might magically get a little bit bigger.
The sandwich arrives as a mountain of meat. It’s roughly $30.95 in 2026, which sounds insane for a sandwich until you realize it’s basically three meals in one. The bread-to-meat ratio is hilarious. The two slices of rye are basically just handles to keep your fingers from getting greasy.
Why the Brisket Matters
The brisket is a tough muscle. It’s the chest of the cow. If you don't treat it right, it’s like chewing on a leather boot. Because Katz's steams the meat right behind the counter, it stays at a constant, humid temperature.
The carvers are artists. They know exactly where the fat "deckle" is and how to trim it so you get the perfect bite. If you want it extra lean, you can ask, but you’re doing yourself a disservice. That fat is where the pickling spices live.
The Pickles Are Not a Garnish
When you buy a Katz’s corned beef sandwich, you get a side of pickles. This isn't just a tradition; it’s a palate cleanser. You get a mix of "full sours" (fermented for months) and "half sours" (still bright green and crunchy). You need that hit of acid to reset your taste buds between bites of the salty, fatty brisket.
Can You Get It Outside of NYC?
The short answer: Yes. The long answer: It’s complicated.
Katz’s ships nationwide now. They’ve figured out a way to vacuum-seal the hand-carved meat and flash-freeze it. You can buy corned beef by the pound (around $38) or get a full Reuben kit.
But there’s a catch. You have to reheat it right. If you throw it in the microwave, you’ve basically committed a culinary crime. You have to submerge the sealed plastic bag in boiling water for about 5 to 10 minutes. This mimics the steaming process at the deli. It’s the only way to get that "melt-in-your-mouth" vibe at home.
The Cultural Weight of a Sandwich
Katz’s isn't just a restaurant; it’s a museum that serves lunch. During WWII, the deli’s slogan was "Send a salami to your boy in the army." They still do it.
The walls are covered in thousands of photos of celebrities, but when you’re sitting at those long communal tables, nobody cares if you’re a movie star or a tourist from Ohio. You’re all just people struggling to fit a four-inch-thick sandwich into your mouth.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
If you're planning to tackle the Katz’s corned beef sandwich soon, keep these specifics in mind to avoid looking like a total amateur:
📖 Related: Tailored pants for ladies: Why most brands get the fit totally wrong
- Bring Cash: They have ATMs, but the line for the register is faster if you’re prepared. They do take cards now, but the "cash is king" vibe still lingers.
- Split the Sandwich: Unless you’re a competitive eater, one sandwich is plenty for two people. Order a side of potato latkes or matzo ball soup to round it out.
- Timing is Everything: If you go at 1:00 PM on a Saturday, you will wait for an hour. Go at 10:30 AM on a Tuesday. You’ll walk right in and get better service from the carvers.
- Check the Meat: When the carver gives you a "sample slice" (a tradition), eat it immediately. If it's too fatty or too dry for your liking, tell them right then. They want you to like it.
- The Reuben Pivot: If you find plain corned beef too intense, order the Reuben. It’s the corned beef topped with Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing. It’s a mess, but it’s a glorious one.
The Katz’s corned beef sandwich remains a benchmark of New York City culture because it refuses to change. In a world of "fast-casual" and "optimized" food, a 30-day cure is an act of rebellion. It’s salty, it’s expensive, and the service is brisk—but it’s also the best version of this sandwich you will ever have.