It was supposed to be the greatest moment of Junior Alvarado’s life. On May 3, 2025, under a gray, drizzling Louisville sky, he guided a bay colt named Sovereignty across the finish line at Churchill Downs to win the 151st Kentucky Derby. He’d just beaten the heavy favorite, Journalism, in a grueling, sloppy stretch run. But the celebration didn't even last a week before the hammer dropped.
By the following Friday, the Kentucky Board of Stewards handed down a ruling that sent shockwaves through the backside: a $62,000 fine and a two-day kentucky derby jockey suspension.
📖 Related: Aaron Hicks Minnesota Twins: What Really Happened to the Future Five-Tool Star
For most people watching at home, the "whip" is just part of the scenery. But for the regulators at the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority (HISA), those two extra strikes cost Alvarado more than most Americans earn in a year.
The 6-Strike Rule: Why the math matters
Horse racing is changing. Kinda fast, actually. In the "old days," a jockey could essentially use the riding crop—the modern, cushioned version of the whip—as much as they felt was necessary to keep a horse focused.
Not anymore.
HISA rules are rigid. You get six strikes. That’s it. If you hit the horse seven, eight, or nine times, you’re in trouble. If you hit them ten times? The horse gets disqualified. Imagine losing the Kentucky Derby because of one extra flick of the wrist.
Alvarado hit Sovereignty eight times.
He admitted it, too. Honestly, his explanation was pretty human. He told reporters that when you’re looking at your dream coming true right in front of you, you aren't exactly counting on your fingers. You're just riding. But the stewards don't care about dreams; they care about the digital replay.
Why was the fine so high?
Usually, a whip violation is a few hundred bucks or maybe a day off. But the Kentucky Derby is different because the purse is massive. The total prize pool was $5 million, and the winner’s share was $3.1 million.
- Jockeys typically get 10% of the winner's share.
- Alvarado's take was $310,000.
- The standard penalty for being 1-3 strikes over the limit is 10% of the jockey’s earnings.
That would have been $31,000. But here’s the kicker: this was Alvarado's second offense within 180 days. He’d been cited back in December 2024 for a similar issue. Because he was a "repeat offender," the stewards doubled the penalty.
$62,000. For two extra taps on a horse's hindquarters.
🔗 Read more: How Much Is Caitlin Clark Worth? What Most People Get Wrong About Her 2026 Earnings
The appeal and the "90-Day" Loophole
The story didn't end with the fine. Alvarado’s agent, Mike Sellitto, immediately filed an appeal. They aren't just arguing that the fine is too high; they are playing a timing game with the rulebook.
HISA has been trying to change the "repeat offender" window from 180 days down to 90 days. If that rule change had been finalized by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) before the Derby, Alvarado’s December violation wouldn't have counted against him. He would have only owed $31,000.
HISA CEO Lisa Lazarus even went on a podcast and basically said they might give him the benefit of the new rules while they wait for the official paperwork. It's a weird, legal gray area where the sport's top regulator is admitting the punishment feels a bit steep.
Previous Derby Dramas
This isn't the first time the stewards have had to get aggressive. Remember Luis Saez in 2019? He was riding Maximum Security, crossed the wire first, and then got DQ’d for interference.
The stewards didn't just take the win away; they slapped Saez with a 15-day suspension. That was brutal because it meant he missed the Preakness Stakes. Compared to that, Alvarado’s two-day suspension (scheduled for late May) is a slap on the wrist.
What this means for the future of the Derby
If you're a bettor or just a casual fan, these suspensions tell you one thing: the era of "winning at all costs" is over. Jockeys are now terrified of the stewards. They are literally counting their strikes in the final 100 yards of the most important race in the world.
Some people think it’s gone too far. They say these modern crops are made of foam and don't actually hurt. Others say if you don't have strict rules, the optics of the sport will kill it entirely.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Bettors
If you're following the Triple Crown or betting on Churchill Downs, keep these three things in mind:
- Watch the "Strike Count": Jockeys who have already had a violation in the last few months (like Alvarado) will be much more hesitant to use the whip. This can actually change the outcome of a close race.
- The DQ Threat is Real: We were only two strikes away from Sovereignty being stripped of the title. If a jockey looks like they are "over-riding," the win isn't official until the "All Clear" sign flashes.
- Check the Suspension Lists: HISA and the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission post these rulings online. A jockey coming back from a suspension is often hungry—or sometimes a little "rusty" with their timing.
The 2025 Derby will be remembered for Sovereignty’s grit, but in the record books of the stewards, it’ll be remembered as the $62,000 lesson in counting to six.
To stay ahead of how these rulings affect upcoming races, you should regularly check the HISA Rulings database or the KHRC website. Understanding which jockeys are under the "repeat offender" microscope can give you a massive edge when looking at the program for the Belmont or next year's Derby trail.
Next Steps: Review the official HISA Racetrack Safety standings to see which other top-tier jockeys are currently one violation away from a doubled fine. This directly impacts how they will handle their mounts in the next major Grade 1 stakes race.