You probably remember the image. It’s hard to shake. Kevin Bacon, looking skeletal and broken, huddled in a pitch-black dungeon cell under Alcatraz. He’s Henri Young, a man the movie tells us was sent to the "Rock" for stealing a measly five dollars to feed his starving sister. It’s a classic David vs. Goliath setup.
But here is the thing: almost everything the 1995 film Murder in the First tells you about the "real" Henri Young is a lie.
Actually, "lie" might be too soft a word. It’s a complete reimagining. If you’re looking for a historical documentary, this isn't it. But if you want to see one of the most raw, physically demanding performances of the 1990s, Bacon’s work here is legendary. Even if the facts are messy, the emotional truth he taps into is very real.
🔗 Read more: Wet Wet Wet: What Really Happened to Scotland's Soul-Pop Giants
The Massive Gap Between Fact and Film
In the movie, Henri Young is a sympathetic victim. He’s a petty thief who gets chewed up by a sadistic system. After a failed escape, the "Associate Warden" (played with terrifying, cold-blooded precision by Gary Oldman) throws him into solitary for three straight years. When he finally gets out, he’s so broken that he stabs a fellow inmate to death with a spoon in the middle of the cafeteria.
Sounds like a tragedy, right?
The real Henri Young was... well, he was a bank robber. He wasn't some desperate kid looking for grocery money. He had a prior conviction for murder in Washington state before he even stepped foot on Alcatraz. And that escape attempt? He wasn't some lone wolf. He was part of a group that included "Doc" Barker, a member of the infamous Barker-Karpis gang.
When Young killed Rufus McCain (the inmate he stabs in the film), it didn't happen in a fit of sudden madness the second he left solitary. It happened about eleven days later in the prison's tailor shop.
The movie also claims the trial "took down Alcatraz."
Honestly? Not even close. Alcatraz stayed open for another 20 years. It eventually closed because it was too expensive to run, not because of one legal case in 1941.
Why Kevin Bacon Murder in the First Still Hits Different
Despite the historical gymnastics, the film works because of the acting. Kevin Bacon didn't just play the role; he seemingly lived it. He reportedly spent time locked in a dark cell for 20 hours just to feel the sensory deprivation. He lost weight. He changed his entire physicality—the way he walks with a limp, the way he flinches at light, the way his voice sounds like it’s being dragged through gravel.
There’s a specific scene where Christian Slater’s character (the idealistic lawyer James Stamphill) tries to get Henri to talk about baseball. Henri can barely remember the names of players. It’s heartbreaking. You forget you're watching a "bank robber." You just see a human being whose mind has been erased by the dark.
📖 Related: Movies Like Deep Blue Sea: Why We Can’t Stop Watching Genetically Modified Sharks
The Power of Gary Oldman and Christian Slater
While Bacon is the heart, Gary Oldman is the poison. His portrayal of Milton Glenn is genuinely unsettling. He doesn't scream. He doesn't twirl a mustache. He just operates with a cold, bureaucratic cruelty that makes your skin crawl.
- Christian Slater: Brings that 90s "young hotshot" energy.
- Gary Oldman: The absolute embodiment of systemic abuse.
- William H. Macy: Shows up in a smaller role, proving even then he was a scene-stealer.
The Reality of Solitary Confinement
Even if the movie fudges the timeline of Henri Young’s life, it got the atmosphere of the "Dungeon" right. In the 1930s and 40s, "D-Block" at Alcatraz was no joke. The cells were damp, dark, and freezing. Inmates were often stripped naked.
The film's strongest argument—and the reason it still resonates—is its indictment of solitary confinement. The defense team argued that the prison was the "weapon" and Henri was merely the "bullet." It’s a nuanced legal argument that still pops up in debates about prison reform today.
The jury in the real 1941 trial actually agreed with this to some extent. They found Young guilty of involuntary manslaughter rather than first-degree murder. They were horrified by the descriptions of the "hole."
What Happened to the Real Henri Young?
In the movie, Henri dies in his cell, a martyr for the cause of justice. He scrawls the word "victory" on the wall. It’s a Hollywood ending.
In real life? Henri Young lived a long, strange life. He was eventually transferred out of Alcatraz to a medical facility and later to a state prison in Washington to serve out his previous murder sentence.
In 1972, he was paroled.
And then? He just vanished.
He went "off the grid" before that was even a common phrase. No one knows where he died or what happened to him. He disappeared into the fog of history, much like the island he once tried to escape.
How to Approach the Movie Today
If you’re going to watch Murder in the First, don't go in expecting a history lesson. Go in for the masterclass in acting. It’s a "message movie" that wears its heart on its sleeve, but it’s also a reminder of a time when mid-budget adult dramas could actually be hits at the box office.
Actionable Insights for Cinephiles
- Watch for the Physicality: Notice how Bacon uses his hands. He keeps them tucked in or trembling, never fully confident in the space around him.
- Compare with The Rock: If you want to see how Alcatraz is used as a setting, watch this and then Michael Bay’s The Rock. The contrast between gritty drama and high-octane action is wild.
- Fact-Check as You Go: Keep a tab open for the real Henri Young. It makes the viewing experience more interesting to see where the writers chose to "beautify" the truth.
- Listen to the Score: Christopher Young’s music is haunting. It treats Henri like a tragic figure, almost religious in its tone, which adds to that "martyr" vibe the director was going for.
The legacy of the film isn't its accuracy. It's the way it makes you feel about the dark corners of the justice system. It’s uncomfortable, it’s loud, and it’s arguably Kevin Bacon's finest hour.
Check out the original 1941 trial transcripts if you want the unvarnished version of the "psychological coma" defense used by the real lawyers. You’ll find that while the movie is fiction, the debate over what isolation does to the human soul is very, very real.