You’re standing in the aisle, or more likely, scrolling through the Madison Reed website, and you see it. Milano Brown. It’s labeled as 5NAC. Dark chocolate brown with copper-auburn tones. It sounds like a dream, right? Like a decadent dessert for your hair. But if you’ve spent any time in hair color forums, you know that what looks like "dark chocolate" on a swatch can sometimes turn into "accidental orange" on a real human head.
Choosing a hair color is risky. It's basically a science experiment where your face is the lab.
Honestly, the Madison Reed Milano Brown is one of those shades that people either absolutely worship or deeply regret. There is no middle ground. Why? Because the "NAC" in that 5NAC code stands for Neutral, Ash, and Copper. It’s a complex cocktail. It’s trying to be everything at once: cool enough to look natural, but warm enough to have that "glow."
📖 Related: Why Your Back Scrub Brush For Shower Is Probably Gross (And How to Fix It)
The Science of 5NAC: What’s Actually in the Box?
Let's get technical for a second, but not boring. Most box dyes are flat. They give you one solid color that looks like a helmet. Madison Reed tries to do something different with their multi-tonal formula. Milano Brown is designed as a Level 5, which in the hair world means a medium-to-dark brown.
The "NAC" part is where the drama happens.
- N (Neutral): This is the base. It’s there to make sure your grays actually disappear.
- A (Ash): These are cool, blue/green-based pigments meant to fight off "brassiness" (that unwanted rusty look).
- C (Copper): This is the wild card. It adds that auburn, sun-lit warmth.
If your hair is naturally very dark or has a lot of "red" underlying pigment, that "C" can sometimes run away with the show. This is how some users end up seeing more orange than they bargained for. On the flip side, if you have a lot of stubborn grays, that copper tone is exactly what keeps the color from looking "inky" or "dead." It gives the hair life.
Does it Really Cover Grays?
Madison Reed claims 100% gray coverage. Most people find this to be true, but there's a catch. If you have what stylists call "resistant" grays—you know, the ones that feel like wire and refuse to take any color—you might need more than just the standard 35-minute wait time.
The "Smart 8-Free" formula (no ammonia, no PPD, no resorcinol, etc.) is way gentler on your scalp, which is a massive win for anyone who usually gets that "burning" sensation at the salon. But because it lacks ammonia, it doesn't "open" the hair cuticle as aggressively. For most, this means healthier hair. For some with super-hard grays, it means they might see those silver strands peeking back out after a week.
Pro tip: If your grays are stubborn, leave it on for 45 minutes. Don’t push it past that, though. More time doesn't always mean better color; it just means more potential for mess.
Why Some People Get "Orange" Results
You’ve probably seen the reviews. "It turned my hair bright ginger!"
This usually happens because of a misunderstanding of how hair color works. Madison Reed Milano Brown has copper tones built-in. If your hair is already lightened or if your natural base has a lot of warmth, adding more copper is like throwing gasoline on a fire.
✨ Don't miss: 1 pound to tons: Why Your Measurement Is Probably Wrong
The color is "dark chocolate," but it's a warm dark chocolate. Think of a Mexican hot chocolate with a hint of cinnamon and spice, rather than a 90% dark cocoa bar. If you want zero warmth—if you want that smoky, mushroom-brown look—you’re looking at the wrong box. You’d be better off with something like Torino Brown (5NA), which drops the copper and sticks to the ash.
What’s Actually Inside the Kit?
Madison Reed is famous for their packaging. It’s a bit extra, but in a good way. You aren't just getting a bottle of goo.
- Barrier Cream: This is the unsung hero. You rub it on your forehead and ears so you don't look like you had a tragic accident with a Sharpie.
- The Color and Activator: Standard stuff, but the cream is thick. It doesn't drip down your neck while you're waiting.
- Cleansing Wipe: For the inevitable spot you missed with the barrier cream.
- Cap and Gloves: Two pairs of gloves, actually. One for applying, one for rinsing. It’s a small detail that makes you feel like the company actually thinks about the user experience.
- Shampoo and Conditioner: These are actually decent. They smell like a spa and help lock that "NAC" pigment in.
The Ingredients: Is it "Safe"?
"Safe" is a relative term in the world of chemicals. However, Madison Reed is arguably one of the cleaner options on the mass market. They swapped out Ammonia for Ethanolamine. It does the same job but doesn't make your bathroom smell like a chemical plant.
They also use PTD instead of PPD. Some people are deathly allergic to PPD (it's the stuff that causes those horror-story swelling reactions). While PTD can still cause reactions in some, it’s generally considered a much lower risk.
Still, do the patch test. Seriously. Behind the ear. 48 hours. Just do it.
How to Apply it Like a Pro (And Not a Disaster)
Applying color at home is a skill. If you just glop it on and hope for the best, you’re going to get "hot roots." That’s when the hair near your scalp (which is warmer because of your body heat) processes faster and looks brighter than the rest.
Start at your roots. Use a bowl and brush if you can; it’s much more precise than the squeeze bottle. If you’re just touching up, stay on the roots. Do not pull the color through to your ends until the last 5 to 10 minutes. Your ends are porous. They soak up color like a sponge. If you put 5NAC on your ends for 45 minutes every time you dye your hair, they will eventually turn almost black while your roots stay bright.
Milano Brown vs. The Competition
Compared to a $8 box of drugstore dye, Madison Reed Milano Brown feels premium. The color has "dimension," which is a fancy way of saying it doesn't look like a flat wig. In the light, you’ll see those auburn glints. In the shade, it looks like a deep, rich brunette.
Is it worth the $30+ price tag? If you have sensitive skin or a sensitive nose, yes. If you want a color that doesn't fade into a weird muddy mess, yes. But if you’re looking for a drastic change—like going from blonde to dark brown—this isn't the shade to DIY without a consultation.
Actionable Advice for Your Next Dye Job
If you’ve decided that Milano Brown is the one, here is how you ensure you don't end up in the "regret" category:
- Check your starting point: If your hair is currently darker than a medium brown, this won't lighten it. Color doesn't lift color.
- The "Two Shade" Rule: Only use this if your natural hair is within two shades of a level 5. If you're a level 2 (nearly black) or a level 9 (platinum), this will be a disaster.
- Gloss is your friend: If your ends are looking a bit dull but your roots are fine, don't re-dye the whole head. Use a clear or chocolate gloss instead. It saves your hair from damage.
- Cool Water: When you rinse, use the coldest water you can stand. It seals the hair cuticle and keeps that copper-auburn shine from washing down the drain.
The truth is, Madison Reed Milano Brown is a sophisticated shade. It’s for the person who wants a "expensive" looking brunette that has a bit of personality. It’s not a safe, boring neutral. It’s a statement. As long as you know that the "C" in NAC stands for copper, you’ll know exactly what to expect when you look in the mirror.
📖 Related: How Many Tbsp in a Cup of Coffee and Why Your Scoop is Probably Wrong
To get the most out of your color, make sure you're using sulfate-free products afterward. Sulfates are basically dish soap for your hair; they’ll strip that beautiful Milano Brown faster than you can say "bad hair day." Stick to the included conditioner or a dedicated color-protecting line to keep the dimension alive for the full six weeks.