Marc Methot didn't play a "flashy" game. He wasn't the guy leading the rush or firing 100-mph slapshots from the point every night. Honestly, if you only looked at the scoresheet, you might’ve missed him entirely. But if you actually watched those mid-2010s Ottawa Senators teams, you know he was the glue. He was the literal bodyguard for one of the greatest offensive defensemen to ever live.
When we talk about the Marc Methot Ottawa Senators era, we’re talking about a specific brand of hockey. It was gritty. It was "pesky." And it featured arguably the best defensive pairing the franchise has ever seen.
The Trade That Changed Everything
In the summer of 2012, the Senators made a move that felt, at the time, like a simple "hockey trade." They sent Nick Foligno to the Columbus Blue Jackets in exchange for a local kid from Ottawa named Marc Methot. Foligno was a fan favorite, a heart-and-soul guy who would eventually captain the Jackets. But Ottawa had a glaring problem: they had plenty of skill but lacked a true, physical anchor on the left side of the blue line.
Methot was that anchor.
He was 6'4", 230 pounds, and played with a mean streak that reminded old-school fans of the "Big Rig" Chris Phillips. He wasn't there to score. He was there to clear the crease, eat up 22 minutes a night, and—most importantly—let Erik Karlsson be Erik Karlsson.
The Karlsson-Methot Connection
You really can't tell the story of the Marc Methot Ottawa Senators years without mentioning #65. It was a perfect marriage of styles. Erik Karlsson was a Gazelle; he wanted to roam, pinch, and create. To do that, he needed a partner who was content to stay home and defend the house.
Methot was the ultimate "stay-at-home" guy, but he was also surprisingly mobile for his size. He could close gaps quickly and was a master of the hip check. Just ask some of the star forwards who ended up in the third row after trying to turn the corner on him.
The stats backed up the "eye test," too. When Methot was out of the lineup due to injury—which happened more than fans liked—Karlsson’s numbers often dipped. He lacked that safety net. Without Methot there to cover the back door, Karlsson had to play a more conservative game, which neutered Ottawa's greatest offensive weapon.
Why the Pairing Worked
- Chemistry: They just knew where the other was. It was telepathic.
- Roles: Methot didn't have an ego. He was happy to do the dirty work while Karlsson took the headlines.
- Physicality: Methot made the Senators "hard to play against." He wasn't a fighter in the traditional sense, but he was punishing.
The Finger, the Playoffs, and the "What Ifs"
The 2017 playoff run was the peak of this era. The Senators were a goal away from the Stanley Cup Finals. Methot was a massive part of that, even though he was playing through absolute carnage. Earlier that season, Sidney Crosby had slashed him so hard it literally severed the tip of his finger. It was gruesome.
✨ Don't miss: Who Won Tampa Bay Game Last Night: The Lightning's Historic Streak Continues
Most guys would have been out for the season. Methot was back for the playoffs.
That 2017 run showed what a Methot-led defense could do. They played a suffocating "1-3-1" system that drove opponents crazy. Methot was the perfect soldier for Guy Boucher’s system. He was disciplined, heavy, and reliable.
Then came the Vegas Expansion Draft. It’s still a sore spot for Sens fans. Because of various "No Move" clauses and a weird roster situation, the Senators couldn't protect Methot. Vegas snatched him up, and just like that, the era was over. He was traded to Dallas shortly after, but injuries—specifically a chronic knee issue—started to take their toll.
Life After the NHL: The Broadcast Booth and Beyond
Methot officially retired in 2021. He didn't just fade away, though. He transitioned into the media world, joining TSN as an analyst and launching The Wally and Methot Show (now Coming in Hot) with Brent Wallace.
He was good at it. Really good.
He brought that same "no-nonsense" attitude to the screen. He was one of the few former players who wasn't afraid to call out the organization or specific players when they were underperforming. He was authentic.
However, things got complicated in late 2025. Following some controversial comments on social media—specifically a post regarding a protest in Ottawa that many deemed offensive—TSN decided to move in a different direction. In October 2025, it was confirmed that Methot would no longer be part of the Senators' regional broadcasts.
It was a messy end to a broadcast career that seemed to be on an upward trajectory. Methot, for his part, took it in stride on social media, mentioning he was focusing on coaching his son’s team and working on his family farm.
What Most People Get Wrong About Methot
People often call him a "limited" player. That’s a mistake. While he didn't put up 50 points, his hockey IQ was elite. You don't survive a decade in the NHL as a top-pairing defenseman just by being big. He understood lanes, he was a great communicator on the ice, and his first pass out of the zone was consistently underrated.
He was the "modern" shutdown defenseman before the league moved entirely toward puck-moving specialists. He proved that even in a fast-paced NHL, there is still a massive value in a guy who simply refuses to let you get to the net.
Legacy in the Capital
When you walk into the Canadian Tire Centre today, you still see Methot jerseys. He represents a time when the Senators were a legitimate threat in the Eastern Conference. He was a local kid who came home and made the team better.
The Marc Methot Ottawa Senators connection is about more than just stats. It’s about a player who knew his role and played it to perfection. He was the perfect foil for a superstar, a voice of reason in the media, and a guy who literally left a piece of himself (his finger) on the ice for the city.
Practical Lessons from the Methot Era
- Balance is Key: You can’t have five Erik Karlssons. Every great offensive talent needs a "Methot" to balance the scales.
- Intangibles Matter: The hip checks and the net-front battles don't always show up in Corsi ratings, but they wear down opponents over a seven-game series.
- Asset Management: The loss of Methot in the expansion draft was a turning point for the franchise. It’s a case study in why managing "No Move" clauses is critical for long-term success.
To understand the current state of the Senators' defense, you have to look back at what they lost when Methot left. They’ve spent years trying to find a left-handed defenseman who can provide that same level of stability. It turns out, finding a Marc Methot is a lot harder than it looks.