Everyone wants to know where Marcel is. If you've seen the A24 film, you know that feeling—that weird, chest-tightening mix of joy and absolute heartbreak. It’s been years since Dean Fleischer Camp and Jenny Slate finally brought their stop-motion creation to the big screen, and the question of Marcel the Shell with Shoes On 2 keeps bubbling up in Discord servers and film forums. People are desperate for more. Honestly, it's easy to see why. We live in a world that feels increasingly loud and jagged, and Marcel is basically the human equivalent of a warm blanket, even if he’s just a calcium carbonate structure with a googly eye.
But here is the thing.
The path to a sequel isn't as simple as just "making another one." Animation is a slow, grueling process that eats years of a creator's life.
The Reality of a Marcel the Shell with Shoes On Sequel
Making the first feature took about seven years. Seven. That is a massive chunk of time to spend moving a tiny shell a fraction of a millimeter at a time. Dean Fleischer Camp, the director who originally voiced the "filmmaker" character, has been pretty open about how much of a marathon the process was. When we talk about Marcel the Shell with Shoes On 2, we have to look at the logistical nightmare of stop-motion. It isn't like a live-action comedy where you can gather the cast for six weeks in Atlanta and call it a day. It’s a labor of love that requires a specific kind of patience most people don't possess.
Most fans don't realize that the first film was actually a "stealth" production for a long time. They worked on it independently before A24 ever stepped in to distribute it. That independence gave it that raw, documentary feel that makes it so special. If a second film happens, does it lose that magic?
There’s also the question of the story. The 2022 film felt like a complete emotional arc. Marcel found his community. He dealt with the grief of losing his family and the bittersweet reality of his grandmother, Connie, passing away. Isabella Rossellini’s performance as Connie was the emotional anchor of that movie. Without her, a sequel would have a massive, shell-shaped hole in its heart. You can't just replace that kind of chemistry.
Why A24 Hasn't Greenlit the Project Yet
Money matters. It always does. While the first film was a critical darling and even nabbed an Academy Award nomination for Best Animated Feature, it wasn't a "Minions" level box office smash. It made roughly $7 million domestically. Now, for an indie stop-motion film, that’s actually decent, but it doesn't immediately scream "franchise" to the suits in charge of budgets. A24 is known for taking risks, but they also like to keep their brand curated. They don't usually do sequels unless there is a massive creative reason to return to that world.
💡 You might also like: The 8 Deaths of Spider-Man: What Really Happened When Peter Parker Met His End
Think about Pearl and X. That worked because Ti West had a specific vision for a trilogy. With Marcel, the charm is in the smallness. In the quiet.
If Marcel the Shell with Shoes On 2 happens, it’s probably going to be because Jenny Slate and Dean Fleischer Camp found a story that feels as urgent as the first one. It won't be because of a studio mandate. Jenny Slate has mentioned in various interviews during the press circuit that Marcel is a part of her soul. She doesn't just "do the voice." She inhabits the character. That kind of connection means she’s likely protective of him. She isn't going to let Marcel become a corporate mascot for the sake of a paycheck.
The Stop-Motion Hurdle
Let's get nerdy about the tech for a second. The first movie used a unique blend of stop-motion characters placed into real-world, live-action environments. This required "plates"—basically footage of the house—to be filmed first, then the animators had to match the lighting and physics perfectly in the studio.
- Lighting matches have to be frame-accurate.
- Dust motes in the air need to look consistent.
- The "handheld" camera feel is actually a digital effect applied to static shots.
It’s an expensive, high-wire act. If they decide to go bigger for a sequel, the costs could balloon.
What a Second Story Could Actually Look Like
What is left for Marcel to explore? He’s a YouTube star now. The first movie ended with him reaching a level of fame that he wasn't necessarily prepared for. A sequel could easily dive into the pitfalls of internet celebrity. Imagine Marcel trying to navigate TikTok trends or dealing with "fans" who don't respect his boundaries. It's a very modern problem that fits the "documentary" style perfectly.
Or, maybe it goes the other way. Maybe it’s about Marcel trying to help other lost objects. We saw a glimpse of a wider world of sentient household items. Exploring that community could expand the universe without losing the intimacy.
But honestly? Most people just want to see Marcel being Marcel. They want to see him use a piece of bread as a bed or a tennis ball as a rover. The "Marcel-isms" are the draw. His perspective on the world is so refreshingly sincere that you could almost put him in any situation and it would work. But "almost" is a dangerous word in filmmaking.
The Voice of the Fans and the Academy
The Oscar nomination changed things. Before that, Marcel was a cult classic from the early days of YouTube (remember the 2010 short films?). After the nomination, Marcel became a "prestige" character. This puts a lot of pressure on any potential Marcel the Shell with Shoes On 2. If it isn't as good as the first, it risks tarnishing a near-perfect legacy.
Critics like David Ehrlich and outlets like The Hollywood Reporter praised the film for its "emotional depth." It’s rare for a movie about a shell to be compared to the works of Pixar or Studio Ghibli, but that’s the level we’re talking about here.
I think we have to consider the possibility that we might get more Marcel, but not in a movie format. Short films? A limited series? A24 has been expanding into television more aggressively lately. A series of 10-minute vignettes could actually suit Marcel’s pacing better than another 90-minute feature. It would allow for those quiet, observational moments that made the original YouTube shorts go viral in the first place.
Where Does This Leave Us?
Right now, there is no official release date. No production start. Just a lot of "we'll see."
Dean Fleischer Camp has been busy. He was tapped to direct the live-action Lilo & Stitch remake for Disney. That is a massive project that takes up a huge amount of time. Working on a Disney blockbuster is basically the opposite of the indie, DIY spirit of Marcel. It’s possible that after finishing a giant studio film, he’ll want to go back to his roots and spend some time with his favorite shell.
We also have to acknowledge the changing landscape of cinema. In 2026, the mid-budget movie is in a weird spot. It’s either "straight to streaming" or "massive theatrical event." Marcel exists in the cracks between those two things.
👉 See also: Why We Need a Little Christmas Still Hits Different After Sixty Years
If you’re looking for a silver-lining, remember that Marcel has survived longer than most internet memes. He’s been around for over 15 years. He isn't going anywhere. Whether or not we get a theatrical sequel, the character is firmly lodged in the cultural zeitgeist.
Actionable Steps for Marcel Fans
If you're itching for more and can't wait for a sequel that might be years away, here is how you can stay in the loop and support the creators:
- Follow the Creators Directly: Dean Fleischer Camp and Jenny Slate are the only ones who will truly know when something is moving. Skip the "leak" sites; they’re usually just guessing for clicks.
- Revisit the Original Shorts: If you’ve only seen the movie, go back to the 2010, 2011, and 2014 shorts. They have a slightly different, more cynical edge that is fascinating to see in hindsight.
- Support Stop-Motion Indie Films: The best way to ensure movies like Marcel get sequels is to show studios that there is a market for them. Check out films from studios like Laika or smaller indie stop-motion projects on streaming platforms.
- Check Out the Books: There are Marcel the Shell storybooks that feature art and prose not found in the movies. They’re technically for kids, but let's be real—Marcel is for everyone.
The wait for Marcel the Shell with Shoes On 2 might be long, but if the first film taught us anything, it’s that good things take time. You can’t rush a shell. They move at their own pace, and usually, that pace is exactly what we need. Keep an eye on A24’s official production slates, but don't hold your breath for a 2026 release. These things are hand-crafted, and you can't automate soul.