You've probably seen the memes. They’re everywhere. Usually, it’s a grainy photo of Margaret Sanger with a caption that makes your skin crawl—something about "exterminating" people or "human weeds." It’s heavy stuff. If you’re trying to figure out what she actually said versus what’s been twisted over the last hundred years, you’re in the right place. Honestly, the truth is way more complicated than a Twitter thread can handle.
Margaret Sanger was a firebrand. She was a nurse who saw women dying from back-alley abortions and constant childbearing in New York’s slums. That’s her "origin story." But as she fought to make birth control legal, she stepped into some very dark territory. To get her way, she rubbed elbows with people we’d find pretty repulsive today.
The Quote Everyone Gets Wrong
If you search for margaret sanger quotes on race, the big one that pops up is from a 1939 letter she wrote to Dr. Clarence Gamble. Here’s the snippet people love to share:
"We do not want word to go out that we want to exterminate the Negro population..."
Stop right there. When you read just those thirteen words, it sounds like a confession of genocide. It’s terrifying. But if you keep reading the rest of the sentence, the meaning shifts. The full quote is:
💡 You might also like: What Does a Sand Dollar Represent? The Meaning Behind These Fragile Ocean Treasures
"We do not want word to go out that we want to exterminate the Negro population and the minister is the man who can straighten out that idea if it ever occurs to any of their more rebellious members."
Basically, Sanger was worried about optics. She was launching "The Negro Project" in the South and knew that Black communities—rightfully—distrusted white doctors and organizations. She was telling Gamble that they needed Black ministers to lead the outreach so people wouldn't wrongly think the goal was extermination.
Was it paternalistic? Absolutely. Was it a "gotcha" admission of a secret murder plot? Not really. She was actually working with leaders like W.E.B. Du Bois and Mary McLeod Bethune on this. In fact, that famous phrase about "breeding carelessly and disastrously" that gets pinned on her? She actually borrowed that line from an article Du Bois wrote in the Birth Control Review in 1932.
The Eugenics Problem
We can't talk about her quotes without talking about eugenics. It was the "science" of the day. In the 1920s, everyone from Theodore Roosevelt to Ivy League professors thought you could "improve" the human race by making sure only the "fit" had kids.
Sanger leaned into this. Hard.
✨ Don't miss: Gluten Free In N Out: What You Actually Need to Know Before Ordering
In her 1922 book The Pivot of Civilization, she wrote about the "dead weight of human waste." She wasn't necessarily talking about race in that specific line—she was talking about people with disabilities, the "feeble-minded," and the very poor. She wanted "more children from the fit, less from the unfit."
The problem is that in the 1920s, "unfit" was a loaded term. It almost always meant anyone who wasn't a middle-class white person of Northern European descent. Even if Sanger argued that she was looking at individual "fitness" rather than skin color, she was using a toolkit designed by racists.
Why the Context Matters Today
History is messy. People want Sanger to be either a perfect feminist saint or a literal monster. She was neither. She was a woman who was single-mindedly obsessed with birth control. She was so obsessed that she’d talk to anyone to get it funded—including a group of women associated with the KKK in Silver Lake, New Jersey, in 1926.
She wrote about that meeting in her autobiography. She didn't praise them; she actually described the experience as weird and said she had to use "the most elementary terms" to get them to understand her. But the fact that she went at all shows how far she’d go to spread her message.
Here are a few more documented quotes that show the different sides of her rhetoric:
- On Individual Rights (1919): "The first right of every child is to be wanted... The second right of every child is to be well-born."
- On the "Unfit" (1921): "The most merciful thing that the large family does to one of its infant members is to kill it." (Note: This sounds like she's advocating for infanticide, but in the context of the essay, she was using hyperbole to describe the misery of poverty and child labor).
- On Opportunity (1942): Writing to Albert Lasker, she said helping Black families control their birth rate would allow them to "rise to their own heights through education and the principles of a democracy."
Moving Past the Memes
So, what do we do with this?
Planned Parenthood actually removed Sanger's name from their Manhattan health center a few years ago. They acknowledged that her legacy is "deeply complicated" by her support of eugenic ideology. They aren't erasing her, but they aren't ignoring the harm those ideas caused either.
If you’re looking into margaret sanger quotes on race, don't just trust a JPEG you saw on Facebook. Go to the New York University "Sanger Papers Project." They have digital copies of her actual letters. You can see the original handwriting. You can see the context.
Actionable Steps for Researching Historical Figures
- Check the Source: If a quote doesn't have a date and a specific letter or book title attached to it, be skeptical.
- Read the Paragraph, Not the Line: Pro-life and pro-choice activists both cherry-pick her words. Read the full page to see what she was actually arguing for.
- Acknowledge the Era: Remember that "fitness" and "hygiene" were the buzzwords of the 1920s. It doesn't make the ideas right, but it explains why they were so prevalent.
- Look at the Collaborators: See who she was working with. The fact that civil rights icons like Rev. Adam Clayton Powell Jr. supported her work suggests a relationship that was more than just "one-sided racism."
The real Margaret Sanger was a woman who did a massive amount of good for women's autonomy while simultaneously holding views that we now recognize as discriminatory and dangerous. We can hold both those truths at the same time. Life isn't a black-and-white movie. It's all grey areas.
For a deeper dive into how these ideas shaped modern healthcare, you can look into the history of the 1924 Immigration Act or the Supreme Court case Buck v. Bell, both of which were heavily influenced by the same eugenics circles Sanger moved in.