Hollywood loves a good "gotcha" moment. Usually, it's the paparazzi catching a star without makeup or in a stained t-shirt. But back in 1951, Marilyn Monroe flipped the script. She didn't just get caught looking "unrefined"—she did it on purpose, wearing a literal Idaho potato bag.
Honestly, the photos are legendary now. You've probably seen them on a postcard or a vintage-style t-shirt. She’s leaning against a wall, grinning, draped in scratchy burlap that has "Idaho Potatoes" stamped across her midsection in bold, block letters. She looks incredible. Like, better than most people look in Prada.
But why did it happen? Was it a joke? A dare? Or just some genius-level 1950s PR?
The Red Dress That Started the Fight
It all started at a party at the Beverly Hills Hotel. Marilyn showed up in a red velvet dress that was, to put it mildly, a bit much for the conservative crowd. It had a plunging neckline that basically defied physics.
A female columnist—whose name is often lost to history but was likely one of the big "gossip queens" of the era—absolutely hated it. She wrote a scathing review saying Marilyn looked "cheap" and "vulgar." Then came the zinger that changed everything. The writer claimed that Monroe only looked good because of her fancy clothes and Hollywood styling. She literally said the starlet would be better suited wearing a potato sack.
Most people would have cried or fired their stylist. Marilyn? She leaned in.
Turning Burlap Into High Fashion
Twentieth Century Fox, Marilyn’s studio, saw a golden opportunity. They didn't want their rising star to be known as "cheap." They wanted her to be known as the girl who could pull off anything.
💡 You might also like: Anthony Kiedis: Why the Red Hot Chili Peppers Singer is More Than Just a Rock Icon
They grabbed a real burlap sack from Idaho. They didn't just cut holes in it and call it a day, though. Look closely at those photos. The sack is tailored. It’s nipped at the waist to highlight her hourglass figure and frayed at the bottom to give it a weirdly intentional fringe.
Earl Theisen was the photographer tasked with capturing the moment. He shot her in various poses: sitting, standing, laughing. The message was loud and clear: It’s not the dress that makes the woman; it’s the woman that makes the dress.
What happened next was actually kinda sweet
- The Potato Farmers Loved It: The Idaho potato growers were thrilled. I mean, talk about free marketing. They reportedly sent her sacks of actual potatoes as a thank-you.
- The "Theft": Marilyn later joked that she never actually got to eat those potatoes. She claimed the "boys in the publicity department" stole them all because there was a minor shortage at the time.
- The Global Reaction: The photos went viral (well, 1951 viral). They were printed in newspapers across the globe, proving that Marilyn had a sense of humor to match her looks.
Why the Marilyn Monroe Potato Bag Still Matters
We live in a world of filtered Instagram posts and carefully curated "candid" shots. Marilyn was doing this 75 years ago. She understood that if you can laugh at yourself, you take the power away from the critics.
There's a persistent myth that the "potato sack" look was just a misattributed quote from another actress, like Lana Turner. While Turner certainly had her share of fashion critiques, the Monroe photo session is a documented historical event. It wasn't a "shabby" moment; it was a calculated strike against fashion snobbery.
It also highlighted a weird bit of American history. During the Great Depression, people actually did make clothes out of flour and potato sacks because they were so poor. Companies eventually started printing patterns on the fabric so the dresses would look prettier. By wearing one in 1951, Marilyn—who grew up in foster homes and knew what it was like to have nothing—was subtly nodding to a struggle millions of Americans understood.
How to Spot the Real Story
If you're looking into this, you'll see people claim she wore it to a party. She didn't. She wore it for a specific photoshoot because of what happened at the party.
The "cheap and vulgar" comment is the key. Without that insult, we wouldn't have the iconic images. It's a classic case of turning lemons into lemonade—or in this case, turning burlap into a billion-dollar legacy.
Next steps for you:
💡 You might also like: Madison Beer Cum Tribute: Why These Internet Trends Are Actually Harassment
Take a look at the original Earl Theisen prints if you can find them in a digital archive. Notice the lighting. It’s high-glamour lighting used on a piece of trash. It's the ultimate lesson in confidence. If you're ever feeling like you don't "fit in" or your outfit isn't "right," remember that the most famous woman in the world once won a fight against the media while wearing a bag of spuds.