Honestly, it’s hard to remember a time when Alabama wasn't just a "Heisman factory." We see Derrick Henry, Bryce Young, and DeVonta Smith taking home hardware now and it feels like a birthright in Tuscaloosa. But go back to early December 2009. Things were different. Alabama had all the tradition in the world—Bear Bryant, the hats, the championships—but they had a giant, gaping hole in the trophy case. No player had ever won the big one. Then came a kid from Flint, Michigan.
When you look at the mark ingram heisman trophy win, you aren't just looking at a stat sheet. You're looking at the closest vote in the history of the award. It was a chaotic, three-way photo finish that still gets people heated at bars today.
The Night Everything Changed in NYC
The 75th Heisman ceremony was tense. No, seriously—it was uncomfortable. Usually, there’s a clear favorite, but 2009 was a mess. You had Mark Ingram, Stanford’s powerhouse Toby Gerhart, and Texas quarterback Colt McCoy. Even Nebraska’s Ndamukong Suh was looming in the background after he basically ate the entire Big 12 for breakfast.
When the envelope opened, Ingram had 1,304 points. Gerhart had 1,276.
That is a margin of 28 points. Total. Out of thousands.
People forget how emotional it was. Ingram was only a sophomore. He was 19 years old—barely a man—and he just started sobbing. His dad, Mark Ingram Sr., was in prison at the time and couldn't be there. That weight was all over his face. He talked about his mom, Shonda, and he talked about Flint. It wasn't some polished, PR-approved speech. It was raw.
Why the 2009 Season Was Actually Ridiculous
A lot of people say Ingram "stole" it from Gerhart because Gerhart had more yards and touchdowns. Look, I get it. Gerhart was a bus. But you have to look at what Ingram was doing against the best teams in the country. He wasn't stat-padding against cupcakes.
In 2009, Ingram put up 1,658 rushing yards and 17 touchdowns. He added another 334 yards and 3 scores through the air. Basically, he was the engine for a team that went 14-0.
The Game That Won It
If you want to know why the mark ingram heisman trophy ended up in Alabama, look at the 2009 SEC Championship against Florida. Tim Tebow was the king of college football. Florida was the defending champ. They were ranked #1.
Ingram didn't just play well; he took over the game.
- 113 rushing yards.
- 3 touchdowns on the ground.
- 76 receiving yards.
- 189 all-purpose yards against the nastiest defense in the country.
That was the "Heisman Moment." He out-Tebowed Tebow. While McCoy was struggling against Nebraska and Gerhart was playing late-night games on the West Coast, Ingram was carving up the Gators on national TV. That matters to voters. It always has.
Breaking the Alabama "Curse"
Before Ingram, Alabama was the "best program never to have a Heisman winner." It was a weird trivia fact that lived in the back of everyone's mind. Joe Namath didn't win it. Ken Stabler didn't win it. Shaun Alexander didn't win it.
✨ Don't miss: Noche UFC Explained: Why Dana White is Obsessed With Mexican Independence Day
Ingram didn't just win a trophy; he broke a seal. Since 2009, the Crimson Tide has added three more. It’s like he gave everyone permission to win it.
He was also a different kind of back. He wasn't the tallest guy at 5'9" or 5'10", but he was built like a fire hydrant. Low center of gravity. You couldn't knock him over. He had this "dead leg" move that made defenders look stupid. Nick Saban loved him because he was reliable. He rarely fumbled—only lost one all season—and he blocked like a fullback when he needed to.
The Gerhart vs. Ingram Debate
We have to talk about Toby Gerhart. Stanford fans are still salty, and honestly? They have a right to be. Gerhart had 1,871 yards and 28 touchdowns. Those are "Video Game" numbers.
But here is the nuance: Gerhart was the entire offense. Ingram was sharing the backfield with a young Trent Richardson. If Ingram had the same number of carries as Gerhart (343 vs 271), his stats would have been astronomical. Ingram averaged 6.1 yards per carry. Gerhart was at 5.5.
Efficiency over volume. That’s what the voters saw. Plus, Ingram’s team was playing for a title. Fair or not, winning the biggest games on the biggest stages carries a lot of weight in the Heisman race.
✨ Don't miss: Do the Kansas City Chiefs play today? Why the 2026 postseason looks different
What He's Doing Now (2026 Update)
It's 2026, and Ingram is still everywhere. He just got elected to the College Football Hall of Fame—class of 2026. Totally deserved. He’s also become a massive personality on TV. If you watch "Big Noon Kickoff," he’s the guy bringing all the energy.
He recently made headlines for calling out Diego Pavia over some post-Heisman saltiness, which is funny because Ingram knows better than anyone how much that trophy means. He respects the "Heisman House" fraternity. To him, it’s about character as much as it is about 40-yard dash times.
By The Numbers: 2009 Historic Run
- Total Scrimmage Yards: 1,992
- Total Touchdowns: 20
- Rushing Record: Broke Bobby Humphrey’s single-season Alabama record.
- Vote Margin: 28 points (The narrowest gap in 75 years).
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you're a college football junkie or an Alabama fan, there are a few things you should actually do to appreciate this legacy:
- Watch the SEC Championship Highlights: Specifically the 2009 game against Florida. It is the blueprint for how a running back wins the Heisman.
- Look at the 2009 Voting Map: It’s wild. Ingram won the South, Northeast, Mid-Atlantic, and Midwest. Gerhart only won the Far West. It shows how much regional bias played a role back then.
- Appreciate the Longevity: Ingram played 12 years in the NFL. That’s an eternity for a running back. His Heisman wasn't a fluke; the guy was a legitimate pro-level talent from the day he stepped on campus.
Mark Ingram’s 2009 season wasn't just about a trophy. It was the moment Alabama became the modern juggernaut we know today. He was the first. He was the spark. And even 17 years later, that 28-point margin is the most fascinating "what if" in the history of the sport.