If you were a kid in the late 90s, you probably remember the summer of '98 like it was yesterday. The home run chase was everywhere. Mark McGwire wasn't just a first baseman; he was a walking, breathing superhero. Honestly, if you had a Mark McGwire baseball card in your binder back then, you felt like you were holding a winning lottery ticket.
Then came the Mitchell Report. The steroid era fallout basically nuked the value of anything Big Mac related for a decade. People felt betrayed, and the market reflected that. But funny enough, 2026 is seeing a massive resurgence in his market. Collectors are getting nostalgic, and the "villain" label is wearing off in favor of "iconic power hitter."
The Card That Still Rules the Market
Most people think his rookie card is the 1987 Topps with the wood-grain border. You've probably seen a million of those. But the real "Holy Grail" for McGwire fans is actually the 1985 Topps #401 USA Baseball card.
It’s a weird one because he’s not in an Oakland A's uniform. He’s wearing his Team USA jersey from the '84 Olympics. Technically, it's his "pre-rookie" or XRC, but most collectors treat it as the definitive rookie card.
💡 You might also like: UC Davis Football Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong About Shredville
Here is the thing about the 1985 Topps #401: it is notoriously hard to find in perfect condition. The centering is usually terrible. If you manage to find one that is actually centered with sharp corners, you’re looking at some serious cash. A BGS 10 Pristine recently sold for over $4,600. Even a standard PSA 10 can easily clear $3,800 in today's market.
If you're digging through a shoebox and find one, don't get too excited yet. Check the corners. Check the surface. A raw, beat-up version might only get you $15 at a local card show. Condition is everything.
Tiffany vs. Standard: The $17,000 Difference
If you want to talk about the high-end stuff, you have to talk about Topps Tiffany.
Back in the 80s, Topps produced these limited-edition factory sets. They looked almost identical to the regular cards but had a high-gloss finish and white cardstock instead of the dingy gray stuff. They only made about 5,000 sets of the 1985 Tiffany.
✨ Don't miss: Man U vs Grimsby: What Really Happened in the Most Embarrassing Cup Night Ever
- Standard 1985 Topps #401: $10–$20 raw.
- 1985 Topps Tiffany #401 (PSA 10): We've seen these go for $17,500.
How do you tell them apart? Basically, flip the card over. If the back is bright and easy to read, it’s probably Tiffany. If it looks like it was printed on a cereal box, it’s the standard version. Also, if you hold the front under a light, the Tiffany will have a "wet" look because of the coating.
Why 1987 is the "True" Rookie Era
While the '85 is the king, 1987 was the year McGwire actually hit the big leagues and smashed 49 homers. This gave us the "Big Three" of his rookie year:
- 1987 Topps #366: The iconic wood border. It’s a beautiful card, but they printed millions of them. You can get a PSA 10 for under $100.
- 1987 Donruss #46: The "Rated Rookie" logo. It’s classic 80s design.
- 1987 Fleer #604: Often overlooked, but still a staple for any serious McGwire collector.
The 1987 Leaf (the Canadian version of Donruss) is actually the sleeper pick here. It’s much rarer than the US version. A PSA 9 or 10 Leaf will always command a premium because the print run was way lower. Honestly, if you're looking for an investment that isn't five figures, the Leaf Rated Rookie is a smart move.
The 90s Inserts: The New Frontier
Lately, the "Junk Wax" era cards (1987-1994) have stayed pretty flat. But the late-90s inserts? They are exploding.
Collectors who grew up during the 1998 home run chase are finally making enough money to buy the cards they couldn't afford as kids. We're talking about things like the 1997 Topps Finest Gold Embossed Die-Cut Refractor. That's a mouthful, I know. But these cards were 1-per-case hits or harder.
A PSA 10 of a 1998 "The Man" Refractor /75 can sell for nearly $1,000 now. These aren't the cards you find in a $1 bin. They are rare, shiny, and incredibly hard to grade because the foil surfaces scratch if you even look at them wrong.
Avoid the Reprints and Scams
You've got to be careful. Because the 1985 Topps card is so valuable, the market is flooded with fakes.
One of the easiest ways to spot a fake is the "dot" test. Take a jeweler's loupe—or even just the zoom on your phone—and look at the "USA" logo. On a real card, the colors are made of tiny, distinct dots (Crosfield dots). On a modern reprint or a fake, the colors often look solid or blurry because they were made with a digital printer.
Also, look at the 1982 Anchorage Glacier Pilots card. It's his earliest minor league card. It's super rare, but there are more reprints of that card than there are actual originals. If someone is selling one for $50 and it looks brand new, it’s almost certainly a fake.
👉 See also: Why the Atlanta Half Marathon Thanksgiving Tradition Is Actually Worth the Hype
What to Do With Your McGwire Collection
If you're sitting on a stack of Big Mac cards, here is the move.
First, stop touching them. Human skin oils are the enemy of 80s cardstock. Get them into "penny sleeves" and "top loaders" immediately.
Second, don't bother grading anything that isn't visually perfect. A PSA 8 or 9 for a common 1987 Topps won't even cover the cost of the grading fee. You only send in the cards that look like they just came out of a pack—perfectly centered with no white "chipping" on the edges.
Focus on the rarities. The 1985 Topps (especially Tiffany), the 1987 Leaf, and any 90s refractors are the ones that will keep gaining value as we get further away from the steroid era drama. McGwire's legacy is complicated, sure, but in the world of card collecting, his impact on the game is permanent.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Check the back of your 1985 Topps #401. If the cardstock is white and glossy, it’s a Tiffany—get it graded by PSA or SGC immediately.
- Use a magnifying glass to check for "print dots" on the 1985 USA logo to ensure your card isn't a 90s-era reprint.
- Look for 1997-1999 "Refractor" parallels in your late-90s binders; these are currently outperforming his 1987 rookie cards in terms of price growth.