You're standing on the corner of 5th and 57th. The wind is biting. You just want a bed that doesn't feel like a shoebox and a shower with actual water pressure. Most people think booking any of the dozen marriott properties in new york city is a safe bet because of the brand name. Honestly? That's how you end up paying $600 for a room where you can hear your neighbor brushing their teeth.
New York is a beast. The Marriott portfolio here is massive—over 300 hotels if you count the greater metro area—and they are not created equal. Some are legendary landmarks. Others are basically glorified dorms for business travelers who stopped caring in 2014. If you aren't careful, you’ll burn 80,000 Bonvoy points on a "Luxury Collection" hotel that hasn't seen a vacuum since the Clinton administration.
The Luxury Trap vs. Real Value
Let’s talk about the big guns. The St. Regis New York is the granddaddy. It’s got the history, the butler service, and the King Cole Bar where the Bloody Mary was supposedly born. But here is the thing: it’s old. For some, that’s "charm." For others, it’s "I’m paying two grand a night for a temperamental radiator."
If you want actual modern luxury, you go to the Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad. It opened fairly recently and it’s basically the gold standard right now. The views from the upper floors make you feel like you own the skyline. Plus, they have a house car—an electric Cadillac Lyriq—that will drop you off in Soho if you’re too fancy for the N train.
✨ Don't miss: The Balto Statue Central Park: Why a Bronze Dog Still Gets All the Love
Then there’s the JW Marriott Essex House. It’s right on Central Park South. People love it for the sign and the location. Is it worth the premium? Kinda. If you get a park-view room, yes. If you’re facing the interior courtyard, you might as well be in a windowless basement in Queens.
Where the "Normal" People Stay
Not everyone has a corporate expense account or a million points. Most of us are looking at the mid-range stuff. The Moxy NYC Times Square is a frequent target for travelers. It’s cheap (by NYC standards) and has a killer rooftop bar.
But be warned.
The rooms are tiny. Like, "I have to fold my suitcase to walk to the bathroom" tiny. If you’re traveling with a partner and you’ve been together less than six months, the glass-walled bathrooms might end the relationship. It’s a vibe, but it’s a specific one.
For something that doesn't feel like a nightclub, the Courtyard New York Manhattan/Central Park is surprisingly decent. It’s one of the tallest hotels in the city. If you ask for a high floor, you get views that rival the five-star spots for half the price. It’s basically a hack for people who want the view without the $100-per-night "destination fee" some luxury spots tack on.
Why Location Is Your Biggest Mistake
People obsess over being in Times Square. Don't. It’s a sensory nightmare of Elmo impersonators and $18 hot dogs.
If you’re looking at marriott properties in new york city, look at the outskirts of the chaos.
- The New York EDITION by Madison Square Park: You’re near the Flatiron, the food is better, and the streets don't smell like desperation.
- Moxy Lower East Side: If you actually want to eat at good restaurants and see how New Yorkers live, stay here. Just don't expect a quiet night’s sleep—the bars downstairs stay loud until 4:00 AM.
- Residence Inn New York Manhattan/Midtown East: This is the "smart" play for families. You get a kitchenette. In a city where a bagel and coffee cost $15, having a fridge and a toaster is a legitimate financial strategy.
The Point Value Reality Check
As of early 2026, Marriott Bonvoy points in NYC are hovering around 0.7 to 0.8 cents in value. You’ll see some "experts" claiming you can get 2 cents per point. Sure, if you book a suite during New Year’s Eve. For a random Tuesday in March? You’re lucky to break even.
📖 Related: Temperature in Vancouver Canada: What Most People Get Wrong
The AC Hotel New York Times Square often hits a sweet spot for redemptions. It’s sleek, it’s clean, and it feels more expensive than it is. On the flip side, avoid using points at the Fairfield Inns in the Garment District unless you're desperate. The cash rates fluctuate so much that you’re often better off just paying the $220 and saving your points for a resort in Mexico.
The "Hidden" Fees You'll Definitely Pay
New York hotels love a "Destination Amenity Fee." It’s usually $30 to $50 a day. They’ll tell you it covers "high-speed Wi-Fi" and a "daily credit for the bar."
It’s a tax. Plain and simple.
Even if you’re a Titanium Elite member, you’re rarely exempt. Always check the fine print on the Marriott app before you hit "book." Some properties, like the New York Marriott Downtown, are a bit more transparent, but the Midtown spots are notorious for hiding these costs until the final checkout screen.
Practical Tips for the Savvy Traveler
If you’re heading to the city this year, do yourself a favor and stop looking for the "best" hotel. Look for the best hotel for your itinerary.
- Business in Midtown? Stick to the Westin New York Grand Central. The Heavenly Beds are actually heavenly, and it’s a three-minute walk to the 4/5/6 trains.
- First time in NYC? The Marriott Marquis in Times Square is a cliché for a reason. The elevators are a marvel of engineering, and you’re in the heart of it. Just bring earplugs.
- Traveling with a pet? TownePlace Suites New York Manhattan/Chelsea is surprisingly accommodating. Most NYC hotels treat dogs like biohazards, but this spot is chill about it.
New York doesn't care about your loyalty status as much as you think it does. Even with Platinum status, upgrades are rare because the city is always at 90% capacity. Instead of praying for a suite, book the room you actually need.
Before you finalize your trip, take a hard look at the map. If your hotel is more than two blocks from a subway station, you’re going to hate your life by day three. New York is a walking city, and those extra blocks add up when you're carrying shopping bags or a laptop bag.
👉 See also: Finding Your Way: The Big Sur USA Map Problems Most People Ignore
Check the "recent" reviews on the Bonvoy app. Not the ones from 2022. The ones from last week. Elevators go out of service, rooftop bars close for private events, and construction next door can turn a "quiet retreat" into a jackhammer-fueled nightmare. Knowledge is power, or at least it’s the difference between a good trip and a miserable one.
Go to the Marriott Bonvoy app and filter by "Member Rates" specifically for the Chelsea and NoMad neighborhoods. These areas currently offer the best balance of subway access and actual "New York" feel without the soul-crushing crowds of 42nd Street. Look for the Renaissance New York Chelsea Hotel—the rooftop pool is a rare find in the city and worth the extra few bucks if the weather is even remotely nice.