History is usually written by the winners, or at least the ones with the best PR teams. For decades, the "Lost Weekend" was framed as a dark, drug-fueled bender where a helpless John Lennon spiraled out of control until Yoko Ono "saved" him. But if you talk to May Pang, the story shifts. It wasn't just a weekend. It was 18 months of intense productivity, family reunions, and a legitimate love story that almost changed the course of music history.
May Pang was only 19 when she started working for the Lennons. She was a kid from Spanish Harlem who bluffed her way into a job at Apple Records. Honestly, she just wanted to be near the music. She didn't expect to be handed a legendary rock star as a boyfriend by his own wife.
The Setup Nobody Saw Coming
In 1973, the Lennon-Ono marriage was hitting a wall. They were fighting. The pressure of being the world’s most famous "peace couple" was wearing thin. Yoko, always the strategist, decided John needed a mistress. But not just anyone. She wanted someone she could trust. Someone she could control.
She walked into May’s office and basically said, "You’re going to be John’s girlfriend."
May was horrified. "I can't do that," she told her. "He’s my boss. He’s your husband." But Yoko was insistent. She didn't just suggest it; she orchestrated it. This wasn't some accidental affair born in a smoky bar. It was a cold, calculated management decision that backfired because John and May actually fell in love.
Why the "Lost Weekend" Wasn't So Lost
The term "Lost Weekend" comes from a 1945 movie about an alcoholic. John used the phrase later to describe this era, likely to appease Yoko when they reunited. But the reality was different. While there was certainly drinking—the infamous "tampon on the head" incident at the Troubadour with Harry Nilsson is rock lore—Lennon was also incredibly sharp.
During his time with May Pang, John was a machine. He produced Mind Games, Walls and Bridges, and Rock ‘n’ Roll. He got his first solo #1 hit with "Whatever Gets You Through the Night."
It wasn't just about the music, though.
May did something Yoko never quite managed: she brought John back to his family. Before May, John’s son Julian was practically a stranger to him. Yoko often blocked phone calls from Julian’s mother, Cynthia. May stopped that. She encouraged the reunions. She took the photos of John and Julian at Disneyland that fans now cherish. She even got John back in a room with Paul McCartney.
✨ Don't miss: Paula Jersey Shore Now: Why the "Walnut" Queen Actually Won the Long Game
The Night the Beatles Almost Reunited
Most people don't realize how close we came to a 1974 Beatles reunion. Paul and Linda McCartney showed up at John and May’s beach house in Santa Monica. They jammed. May took the last known photo of John and Paul together.
There were serious plans for John to head down to New Orleans to record with Paul on the Venus and Mars album. He was excited. He was ready to go. But then, the phone rang. It was always Yoko. She claimed she had found a way to help John stop smoking through hypnosis. He went back to the Dakota for a "treatment" and never really came back to May.
The Abrupt Ending
The end of the relationship was as weird as the beginning. John and May were planning to buy a house in Montauk. They were looking at properties. They were a couple.
Then, suddenly, he was back with Yoko.
May says there was no closure. No "it's not working out" talk. Just a sudden wall of silence and a public narrative that labeled her as a mere footnote—a "fling" that John regretted. But May has always maintained that the intimacy didn't end in 1975. According to her, John continued to call her, visit her, and tell her he loved her right up until his death in 1980.
What We Get Wrong About May Pang
The biggest misconception is that May was a groupie or a "home wrecker." She was a professional who was placed in an impossible situation by two of the most powerful people in pop culture.
- She wasn't a "distraction." She was a stabilizer.
- The period wasn't a "failure." It was John's most commercially successful solo era.
- She wasn't erased by choice. She was erased by a narrative designed to protect the "John and Yoko" brand.
Critics often point out that John's final interviews, like the one with Playboy in 1980, dismissed the time with May. But you have to remember who was sitting in the room during those interviews. John was a man who often reshaped his history to survive his current reality.
Actionable Insights: Learning from the Lennon-Pang History
If you’re a fan or a historian looking to understand the "real" John, you have to look past the official biographies.
- Check the Archives: Look at the photography in May Pang’s book Instamatic Karma. The photos don't show a miserable man. They show a guy wearing jeans and a t-shirt, hanging out with his kid, looking lighter than he had in years.
- Listen to the Lyrics: Listen to Walls and Bridges. Songs like "Surprise, Surprise (Sweet Bird of Paradox)" are direct tributes to May. They aren't the songs of a man who is "lost."
- Watch the Documentary: The Lost Weekend: A Love Story (2022) gives May the floor to speak without being filtered through the Lennon estate.
The story of May Pang and John Lennon is a reminder that people are complicated. Relationships aren't always binary. You can love two people. You can be "found" during a "lost" weekend. Most importantly, it's a reminder that the truth usually lies somewhere between the official press release and the private photos kept in a shoebox.
Next Steps for Music Buffs:
If you want to hear the musical proof of this era, go back and listen to the John Lennon Anthology box set. Pay attention to the studio chatter from 1973 and 1974. You’ll hear a version of John Lennon that sounds remarkably present, creative, and—dare I say it—happy.