I've done it. You've done it. We've all sat there, staring at a screen or a mirror, and felt that weird, prickly heat behind the neck while me reacting to me lying becomes a physical sensation. It’s that bizarre moment of self-confrontation where the person you pretend to be hits a wall built by the person you actually are.
Lying is easy. Facing the lie? That's where the wheels come off.
Cognitive dissonance isn't just a fancy term psychologists like Leon Festinger tossed around in the fifties to sound smart at cocktail parties. It’s a literal internal war. When you realize you’ve been dishonest—whether it’s a "white lie" to save face or a massive fabrication to protect your ego—your brain enters a state of high alert. It hates inconsistency. It wants you to be the hero of your own story, but a liar is rarely the hero.
The Biology of the Double Take
What actually happens when you're me reacting to me lying? Honestly, your amygdala goes rogue.
Research from University College London (UCL) found that the brain actually gets "used" to lying. They call it emotional adaptation. The first time you tell a whopper, your heart races. Your palms get sweaty. Your brain screams that something is wrong. But by the tenth time? The amygdala—the part of the brain that handles fear and emotional response—barely blinks.
But there’s a catch.
While you might get better at telling the lie, the moment of "reacting" to it later is a different beast entirely. This usually happens in the "quiet" moments. Maybe you’re brushing your teeth. Maybe you’re trying to fall asleep. Suddenly, the reality of the deception hits you. You aren't reacting to the lie itself; you're reacting to the gap between your values and your actions.
It feels like a glitch in the simulation.
Why We Squirm When We See Ourselves Being Dishonest
Social media has made me reacting to me lying a literal, documented experience. Think about "storytimes" on TikTok where someone gets caught in a lie and then tries to "clarify." They are watching their own previous video—their own previous lie—and you can see the micro-expressions of discomfort.
💡 You might also like: What Is Chest Tightness a Symptom Of? The Answers Might Surprise You
Psychologist Paul Ekman, the guy who basically pioneered the study of micro-expressions, points out that "leakage" occurs when we try to conceal an emotion. Even when we are lying to ourselves, those leaks happen.
We cringe because the "self" we presented is being rejected by the "self" that knows the truth. It’s a form of social rejection, but it's coming from inside the house.
The Cost of the "Internal Gaslight"
When you lie to others, you eventually start lying to yourself to keep the narrative straight. This is where it gets dangerous.
Dr. Bella DePaulo, a leading researcher on the psychology of lying, suggests that most people tell one or two lies a day. Most are harmless. "You look great in that hat!" (They don't). But when the lies become foundational—about your job, your finances, or your feelings—the "reaction" phase becomes chronic stress.
- Increased cortisol levels
- Disrupted sleep patterns
- General irritability
- Social withdrawal to avoid being "found out"
The brain is an energy hog. Maintaining a lie requires massive amounts of "executive function" in the prefrontal cortex. You have to remember the lie, who you told it to, and the original truth. It’s exhausting. No wonder we feel like garbage when we finally have to face it.
Breaking the Cycle of Self-Deception
So, you’ve caught yourself. You’re in the middle of me reacting to me lying. You feel the shame. You feel the weird urge to just delete the last three years of your life and move to a cabin in the woods.
Don't do that. The woods are cold and the Wi-Fi is terrible.
Instead, acknowledge the "Reaction Gap." This is the space between the lie and the confession (to yourself or others). The longer this gap exists, the more damage it does to your self-esteem.
Step 1: Radical Inventory
Sit down. No phone. No distractions. Write down the lie. Not the "version" of the lie you tell people, but the raw, ugly truth.
"I told my boss I finished the report because I was embarrassed that I spent four hours watching sourdough fermentation videos instead of working."
Seeing it on paper strips it of its power. It’s just words now. It’s not a monstrous secret anymore. It’s a mistake.
Step 2: Analyze the "Why"
Most lies aren't malicious. They are protective. Are you lying because you’re afraid of being judged? Are you lying because you don't feel "enough"?
According to a 2021 study in the Journal of Neuroscience, people with higher levels of "self-centered impulsivity" are more likely to lie for personal gain, but the average person lies out of social anxiety or a desire to avoid conflict. Understanding your "why" changes the reaction from shame to curiosity.
Step 3: The Correction Phase
This is the hardest part. You have to close the loop.
If the lie affected someone else, you need to come clean. You don't need a grand apology. "Hey, I realize I wasn't entirely accurate about [X], and I wanted to clear that up" works wonders.
If the lie was only to yourself, you need to change your behavior. You can't just "feel bad" and expect things to change. Shame is a passive emotion. Accountability is an active one.
✨ Don't miss: Why LivingWell Cancer Resource Center Geneva IL Is Still the Gold Standard for Care
The Neuroscience of the "Clean Slate"
There is a genuine neurological relief that comes with honesty. When you stop the cycle of me reacting to me lying, your brain stops redirecting resources to "narrative maintenance."
The "Truth-Telling" effect is real. Studies have shown that people who make a conscious effort to tell fewer lies report fewer physical health complaints, like headaches or sore throats. It turns out that being a "honest person" isn't just a moral choice; it's a bio-hack for a better life.
How to Handle Being Called Out
What if the reaction isn't private? What if someone else catches you?
The instinct is to double down. Don't.
- Breathe for four seconds. It stops the "fight or flight" response.
- Acknowledge the lie immediately. "You're right, I wasn't being honest there."
- Do not over-explain. Over-explaining is just more lying disguised as context.
- Ask for a path forward. "How can I make this right?"
Practical Steps for Moving Forward
- The 24-Hour Rule: If you catch yourself telling a lie, you have 24 hours to correct it before it becomes "the truth" in your social circle.
- Identify "Lie Triggers": Are there specific people or situations that make you want to lie? (e.g., talking to your parents about money, or your ex about your dating life). Prepare honest scripts for these situations beforehand.
- Practice Vulnerability: Usually, we lie to hide a perceived weakness. Start sharing small, low-stakes weaknesses. "I actually don't know how to use Excel very well" is better than lying and struggling for weeks.
- Forgive the Reaction: Feeling bad about lying is a sign that your moral compass is still working. It’s the people who don’t react that we should worry about.
Living a life where you don't have to watch yourself lying is significantly less stressful. It frees up mental bandwidth for things that actually matter—like learning a new skill, building deep relationships, or finally figuring out how to make that sourdough starter work.
The goal isn't to be a perfect human who never tells a fib. That person doesn't exist. The goal is to shorten the distance between the lie and the truth until they eventually become the same thing.
Stop the internal gaslighting. Own the truth. Your brain will thank you for the extra storage space.
Immediate Action Plan:
- Identify one "active lie" you are currently maintaining in your life.
- Write down the specific fear that is preventing you from telling the truth.
- Draft a one-sentence "correction" you can send or say to the involved party within the next 4 hours.
- If the lie is purely internal (e.g., lying to yourself about your health or habits), schedule a 15-minute "truth session" tonight to map out a realistic change.