If you’ve been scrolling through Bravo threads or keeping up with the drama in the San Fernando Valley, you’ve likely seen the name Michelle Aaron floating around. Except, there is a tiny bit of a mix-up there. Fans are actually searching for the saga of Michelle Saniei (formerly Lally) and her now-ex-boyfriend, Aaron Nosler. It’s the classic reality TV game of telephone. People smash the names together. Honestly, can you blame them? The drama between these two on The Valley was enough to make anyone’s head spin.
For a minute there, it really looked like Michelle had found her "happily ever after" post-Jesse Lally. Aaron was the calm financial advisor who sold organic honey on the side. He seemed like the polar opposite of her high-strung ex-husband. But as we’ve learned from years of watching Bravo, "calm" usually has an expiration date when cameras are rolling.
🔗 Read more: Who is in the Once Upon a Prince cast? Meet the faces behind the Hallmark favorite
What Really Happened With Michelle and Aaron on The Valley?
The relationship started in the most "LA" way possible. Michelle was at a coffee shop with her daughter, Isabella. The toddler waved at a stranger. That stranger was Aaron Nosler. They kept bumping into each other at Runyon Canyon—classic—and eventually, a friendship turned into a full-blown romance. By the time Season 2 of The Valley started filming, Aaron was a fixture.
He wasn't just a background character. Aaron was right in the thick of it. He even sat down for a very awkward "man-to-man" with Jesse Lally. Jesse, being Jesse, was convinced that Michelle and Aaron had been a thing long before the marriage officially ended. He flat-out accused them of having an emotional and physical affair while they were still living under the same roof.
Aaron denied it. Michelle denied it.
The tension was thick enough to cut with a steak knife. Aaron told Jesse they just "texted here and there" and ran into each other while he was out selling his honey. Jesse didn't buy it for a second. He pointed out how weird it was that Michelle had a "boyfriend" just two weeks after they separated.
The Ultimatum That Ended Everything
You’d think the drama with the ex-husband would be the hardest part, but it turns out the pressure of the show was the real relationship killer. By July 2025, the news broke: Michelle and Aaron were done.
It wasn't a slow burn. It was a "delete all photos and unfollow on Instagram" kind of breakup.
Michelle later shared that Jesse’s antics were a huge part of why things soured. Aaron apparently gave her a bit of an ultimatum. He loved her, and he loved Isabella, but he couldn't deal with a "crazy ex-husband" breathing down their necks constantly. If things didn't change with Jesse, Aaron was out.
Well, things didn't change.
Behind the Scenes: Who is Aaron Nosler?
If you're wondering what Aaron does when he's not being grilled by reality stars, he's actually quite established. He’s a director at Thrivent, which is a big financial firm. He also spends time volunteering with Kids Hope USA.
He’s a guy who clearly values stability. That’s probably why the chaotic world of The Valley felt like such a bad fit. Dealing with rumors about secret boyfriends and "movie director" scandals isn't exactly in the job description for a financial advisor.
Interestingly, while Michelle has moved out and moved on, Aaron is still set to appear as a "Friend of" in Season 3. It’s going to be incredibly awkward to see the fallout of their split play out on screen, especially since they were talking about having kids together just months before the breakup.
Life After the Split for Michelle
Michelle hasn't let the breakup slow her down. She’s officially dropped the "Lally" last name and is back to being Michelle Saniei. She’s leaning heavily into her luxury real estate career and her podcast, Pursuit of Sassiness.
💡 You might also like: Where Can I Watch Evil Without Getting Lost in Streaming Limbo
She’s also finally settled her divorce with Jesse. They reached an out-of-court agreement in October 2025, which covers custody of Isabella and their various financial assets. It seems like she’s trying to scrub the "chaos" from her life, one legal document at a time.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans Following the Drama
If you’re trying to keep up with the cast of The Valley, here is the "cheat sheet" for what’s coming next:
- Watch Season 3 for the aftermath: Since Aaron is returning as a "friend," expect to see some very tense group scenes where they have to interact.
- Check the Podcast: If you want the unedited version of Michelle's side, Pursuit of Sassiness is where she drops the most tea about her personal life.
- Follow the Real Estate: Michelle is still a powerhouse in the Beverly Hills market. Her professional success is often a much better indicator of her "vibe" than her dating life.
- Don't Believe Every Rumor: Jesse Lally is known for spinning narratives. While the "Michelle Aaron" connection was real, the timeline of when it started is still a major point of contention between the exes.
The lesson here? Bringing a "normal" person into the Bravo-verse is always a gamble. Sometimes you get a happy ending, but usually, you just get a lot of deleted Instagram posts and a really awkward reunion segment.