You’re walking through Monterey Square in Savannah, past the heavy Spanish moss and the tourists arguing over a map, and then you see it. It looks like a cathedral. Seriously. There are these towering spires and pointed arches that scream "medieval Europe," but then you notice the Hebrew lettering and the cupola.
Basically, you’ve just stumbled onto Mickve Israel Temple Savannah.
Most people just snap a photo and move on to the Mercer-Williams House across the square, but they’re missing the point. This isn't just a "pretty building" or a random stop on a ghost tour. It is, quite literally, one of the most significant religious sites in the United States. And honestly? It’s kind of a miracle it even exists.
Why Mickve Israel Temple Savannah Is One-of-a-Kind
First off, let’s clear up the architecture thing. If you think it looks like a church, you’re not crazy. It was designed by Henry G. Harrison in 1878, and it’s the only pure neo-Gothic synagogue in North America.
Usually, synagogues from that era were built in the Moorish or Byzantine style—think domes and horseshoe arches. But the folks in Savannah wanted something that fit the Victorian vibe of the South at the time. The result is this stunning white structure with stained glass that would make a French bishop jealous.
The 1733 Arrival: 42 Brave Souls
The story actually starts way before the current building was a twinkle in an architect’s eye. In July 1733, just five months after James Oglethorpe founded Georgia, a ship called the William and Sarah pulled into the harbor.
Onboard were 42 Jewish refugees.
Most were Sephardic Jews fleeing the Inquisition in Portugal and Spain. They had lived as "Crypto-Jews," pretending to be Catholic while practicing Judaism in secret. They brought a few things with them that you can still see today if you take the tour:
- A deerskin Torah scroll (the oldest in North America).
- A special circumcision kit.
- A lot of hope (hence the name Kahal Kadosh Mickva Israel, which translates to "Holy Congregation, Hope of Israel").
If it weren't for a doctor on that ship named Samuel Nunes, the colony might have folded entirely. Savannah was being ravaged by yellow fever. Oglethorpe’s own doctors were dead. Nunes stepped in, saved the colony, and Oglethorpe basically said, "Yeah, these guys can stay."
The Museum Is Where the Real Secrets Are
You've gotta go inside. I know, the exterior is great for Instagram, but the Lawrence & Nancy Gutstein Museum on the second floor is where the "heavy hitters" are kept.
It’s not just about the Torah, though seeing a 15th-century scroll that survived a cross-Atlantic voyage in a wooden ship is wild. They have actual letters from U.S. Presidents. We’re talking George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, and James Madison.
Washington wrote to them in 1790. He was basically thanking them for their support and wishing them well. It’s a tangible reminder that Jewish history isn't a "side story" in American history—it’s been there since the literal first page.
The "Crypto-Jew" Connection
One thing the docents talk about—which sort of blows my mind—is the fear these early settlers had. Even after they got to Savannah, they were terrified of the Spanish in Florida.
👉 See also: The Westin Palace Madrid: Why This Century-Old Icon Still Dominates the City
During the War of Jenkins' Ear (yeah, real name), when the Spanish were getting close to Savannah, many of the Jewish families fled. They knew if they were captured by the Spanish, they’d be sent back to the Inquisition. They didn't fully feel "safe" until the British won the Battle of Bloody Marsh.
Planning Your Visit (The Non-Boring Way)
If you're heading to Mickve Israel Temple Savannah, don't just show up and expect to wander around. It’s an active Reform congregation. They have services, they have a school, and they have lives.
The Tour Lowdown:
- Timing: Tours usually run Monday through Friday. They close for lunch (12:00 PM to 1:15 PM), so don't be that person banging on the door while the staff is eating a sandwich.
- Cost: It’s about $14 for adults. Honestly, it’s a steal compared to some of the "haunted" tours in town that just tell you fake stories about ghosts.
- The Food: If you happen to be in Savannah in late October, you must go to the "Shalom Y'all" Jewish Food Festival in Monterey Square. Sizzling latkes, brisket, and kugel in the middle of a Georgia park? It’s chaos in the best way possible.
What Most People Miss
The stained glass. Look at the windows on the north side (the Wayne Street side). One of them is a memorial to Moses Ferst. The colors in these windows are original, and when the afternoon sun hits them, the sanctuary turns into a kaleidoscope.
Also, notice the organ. In traditional Orthodox synagogues, you wouldn't find an organ. But Mickve Israel moved toward Reform Judaism in the 19th century. They actually had an organ and mixed seating (men and women together) way before it was common elsewhere in the South.
Actionable Takeaways for Your Trip
Don't just treat this like a museum. It's a living piece of Savannah's "Strolling City" charm.
- Book in advance: Use their website to snag a tour slot. It gets crowded, especially on "Super Museum Sunday" in February.
- Respect the space: It’s a house of worship. Business casual is the way to go, though they're pretty chill with tourists in "nice" casual clothes.
- Check the schedule: If you want to experience the acoustics, try to attend a Friday night service at 6:00 PM. The music is incredible.
- Pair your visit: Since you're already at Monterey Square, walk across to see the Pulaski Monument or grab a coffee at a nearby cafe to process the history you just saw.
The history of the Jewish South is complicated and messy and beautiful. Seeing it through the lens of a Gothic building that looks like it belongs in London but sits firmly in Georgia soil is something you won’t forget.
Before you leave the Historic District, make sure to check the congregation's calendar for any "Scholar in Residence" events. They often host historians who dive into the specific genealogy of the original 42 families, which is fascinating if you're into the nitty-gritty of colonial life.