Nobody really knew what to expect when Sean McDermott walked into One Bills Drive in 2017. The drought was old enough to drive a car. The roster was a weird mix of Rex Ryan’s leftovers and a front office trying to find an identity. Then came the "Panther Pipeline." One of the first guys through that door was Mike Tolbert, a three-time Pro Bowler who looked more like a nose tackle than a tailback.
Fans in Buffalo have a complicated relationship with the man they called the Toldozer. To some, he was the seasoned veteran who helped steady a locker room that desperately needed a culture shift. To others? He was the guy taking carries away from LeSean McCoy on 3rd and short and getting stuffed.
But if you look at that 2017 season—the year the drought finally died—Tolbert’s role was way more nuanced than just a "fat guy running the ball."
💡 You might also like: 93.7 Pittsburgh Listen Live: How to Catch The Fan From Anywhere
Why the Mike Tolbert Buffalo Bills experiment happened
McDermott didn't just sign Tolbert for his 250-pound frame. He signed him because he knew exactly what he was getting. In Carolina, Tolbert was a Swiss Army knife. He could block, he could catch, and he was a nightmare to tackle in the red zone.
When he signed that one-year, $1 million deal in March 2017, the Bills also brought in Patrick DiMarco. It was a weird move. Two fullbacks? In a modern NFL? Honestly, it felt like the Bills were trying to travel back to 1994.
The logic was actually pretty simple. Rick Dennison, the offensive coordinator at the time, wanted a heavy, physical run game. Tolbert wasn't just a fullback in Buffalo; he was essentially the primary backup to Shady McCoy. He finished that year with 66 carries for 247 yards. Those aren't "wow" numbers, but in a room with a young Jonathan Williams (who didn't even make the final roster) and Joe Banyard, Tolbert was the "safe" pair of hands.
The "3rd and Tolbert" frustration
If you ask a Bills fan today about Mike Tolbert, they’ll probably mention the 2017 Wild Card game against the Jaguars. That 10-3 slog of a game was a nightmare for everyone involved. Tolbert had two carries for one yard.
The frustration throughout the season wasn't necessarily about Tolbert's talent. It was about usage.
There were times when LeSean McCoy, one of the most electric players in franchise history, would be on the sidelines during crucial short-yardage situations. In came #35. You've seen the clips. He’d hit the line, the pile wouldn't move, and the Bills would punting.
- Week 1 vs. Jets: He actually looked good. 12 carries, 42 yards, and a 1-yard TD.
- The Mid-Season Slump: As the weather got cold, the efficiency dipped.
- The Pass Blocking: This is where he actually earned his paycheck. PFF had him ranked as one of the top pass-blocking backs in the league that year. He kept Tyrod Taylor upright more often than people remember.
More than just a "Culture Guy"
"Culture" is a buzzword that sports fans hate, but Tolbert was the personification of it for McDermott. He was the bridge. When McDermott was preaching "The Process," he needed guys in the locker room who had seen it work. Tolbert had been to a Super Bowl with the Panthers just two years prior.
📖 Related: USA Ninja Challenge Cincinnati: What Your Kids Actually Get Out of It
He wasn't there to be the star. He was there to be the vet who showed the young guys how to practice. He stayed late. He coached up the rookies. He was the guy telling everyone to keep their heads up when the team hit a three-game losing streak in November where they gave up 135 points.
The statistical reality of 2017
Let’s be real: Tolbert was at the end of the road. He was 31 years old, which is basically 90 in running back years.
He averaged 3.7 yards per carry. That’s not great, but it’s also not the "disaster" people recall. For comparison, it was roughly the same as what the team got from other depth pieces in that era. The difference was the visibility. When you’re 250 pounds, people notice when you don't get the first down.
He caught 14 passes for 78 yards. He was a safety valve for Tyrod Taylor, who often preferred the checkdown to the risky deep ball. Was it exciting? No. Was it functional? Sorta.
What we can learn from the Toldozer era
Looking back, the Mike Tolbert Buffalo Bills tenure was a signal of intent. It showed that the new regime valued reliability and locker room presence over raw, unrefined upside. It was the "safe" era of Buffalo football that eventually paved the way for the high-octane Josh Allen years.
If you’re a fan or a student of the game, here are the real takeaways from that season:
🔗 Read more: Crown Jewel 2024 Results: What Really Happened In Riyadh
- System fit over star power: Tolbert was a "McDermott guy." Sometimes, coaches prefer a player who knows the system perfectly over a more talented player who is a wildcard.
- The value of a "bridge" veteran: You can't build a winning culture with only rookies. You need the Mike Tolberts of the world to take the heat and set the standard.
- Short-yardage is a team effort: Tolbert got the blame for failed 3rd downs, but the 2017 Bills offensive line was middle-of-the-pack at best in power situations.
Tolbert didn't return for the 2018 season. His time in Buffalo was a one-year cameo that coincided with the end of a 17-year nightmare. He might not have a spot on the Wall of Fame, but he was a brick in the foundation of what the Bills are today.
Your next move: If you want to see how the Bills' run game has evolved since the "heavy fullback" days of 2017, take a look at the current roster’s usage of versatile tight ends compared to the traditional fullback. The "Toldozer" role is extinct, replaced by players who can split out wide, showing just how much the NFL has changed in less than a decade.