Let’s be real for a second. We’ve all been waiting for this. Ever since the first run of Dimension 20’s "Misfits and Magic" wrapped up, the fans have been basically vibrating with anticipation. It wasn't just another D&D clone. It was something weirder, funnier, and—honestly—a little bit more cathartic for those of us who grew up reading about magical boarding schools and thinking, "Wait, this system is actually terrible." Now that Misfits and Magic Season 2 is officially on the horizon, the hype is hitting a fever pitch.
Brennan Lee Mulligan is stepping out from behind the DM screen. That’s the big one.
Usually, Brennan is the guy weaving the world, but for this outing, he’s back as Evan Kelmp. If you remember the first season, Evan was the heart of the show—a kid who was essentially a walking nuclear reactor of dark, ancient magic who just wanted to play basketball and not hurt anyone. Seeing him return as a player while Aabria Iyengar takes the reins again as the Game Master is exactly what the doctor ordered. Aabria has this specific, chaotic energy that challenges the players in ways they don't see coming. She doesn't just ask for rolls; she asks for emotional vulnerability, and then she hits you with a plot twist that makes you want to scream at your monitor.
The Return to Gowpenstow and Why It Matters
Most sequels try to go bigger, but Misfits and Magic Season 2 seems to be going deeper. We aren't just looking at "more spells." We’re looking at what happens when these American "misfits" actually have to live with the consequences of upending a centuries-old British magical institution.
The first season was a "fish out of water" story. This time? The fish have grown legs and they're trying to figure out how to run the aquarium.
The cast remains elite. You’ve got Erika Ishii as Kelmp’s chaotic foil, Danielle Radford bringing that grounded but hilarious perspective, and Lou Wilson—who is, quite frankly, the GOAT of reactionary roleplay. Their chemistry isn't something you can manufacture. It comes from years of playing together at the Dropout tables. When they sit down, it’s not just a professional recording; it feels like a group of friends who are genuinely trying to make each other lose their minds with laughter.
Kids Growing Up in a Broken Magic System
One of the best things about this series is how it pokes fun at the "wizard school" trope.
Think about it. In most stories, the magic school is this prestigious, perfect place. In Misfits and Magic Season 2, we’re likely going to see more of the "Anti-Harry Potter" sentiment that made the first one so relatable. The magic system isn't perfect. The adults are often incompetent or bound by ridiculous traditions. The "Pilot Program" was a mess.
The Kids (as they're affectionately known) are older now. There’s a time jump involved. This matters because the stakes shift from "will I pass my exams?" to "how do I exist in a world that doesn't know what to do with me?"
Brennan’s character, Evan, is the perfect vessel for this. He is a personification of "unwanted power." Watching him navigate a world that is terrified of him while he’s just trying to be a good person is some of the best narrative work Dropout has ever produced. It’s also deeply funny because, well, it’s Brennan Lee Mulligan playing a teenager with the soul of a Victorian ghost.
Using the Kids on Brooms System
It’s worth mentioning the mechanics. They aren't using Dungeons & Dragons.
They use Kids on Brooms.
If you aren't a tabletop nerd, here’s why that’s cool: it’s a "rules-light" system. It focuses on narrative over math. In D&D, you spend twenty minutes calculating modifiers for a fireball. In Kids on Brooms, the system is built to facilitate "failing forward." When a character fails a roll, it doesn't just mean "nothing happens." It means something interesting—and usually disastrous—happens that pushes the story in a new direction.
💡 You might also like: Where Can I Watch Ready Player One: What Most People Get Wrong
This is why Misfits and Magic Season 2 feels so fast-paced. There’s no slog. It’s all character beats and magical mishaps. The dice are there to add tension, not to get in the way of a good joke. For a show that thrives on improvisational comedy, this system is the secret sauce. It allows Aabria to say "yes, and" to the players' wildest ideas without checking a 300-page rulebook.
What We Know About the Plot (So Far)
Dropout is notoriously good at keeping their secrets. They drop trailers that give you the vibe but rarely the whole map.
Here is what we can piece together:
- The Time Jump: The characters have matured. They aren't the wide-eyed outsiders anymore. They have a reputation.
- The Setting: We are going back to the UK, but the scope feels wider. It’s not just the hallways of the school; it’s the magical society at large.
- The Conflict: There’s a lingering sense that the "peace" established at the end of season one was fragile. You don't just break a magical world's traditions and expect everyone to be cool with it.
Expect more cultural clashes. The American vs. British magical tropes provided about 40% of the comedy in the first season, and there’s still plenty of meat on that bone. Whether it’s the way magic is taught or just the sheer absurdity of magical bureaucracy, the show is at its best when it’s punching up at stuffy institutions.
Why Dimension 20 Continues to Win
Dropout (formerly CollegeHumor) has found a goldmine with Dimension 20. But Misfits and Magic Season 2 represents something specific: the power of the "side quest."
While the "main" seasons like Fantasy High are great, these shorter, four-to-six episode arcs allow for experimental storytelling. They can take risks. They can bring in different GMs. Aabria Iyengar’s rise as a household name in the TTRPG space is largely thanks to her work here. She brings a "cool teacher" energy that can turn into a "terrifying god" in a split second.
The production value has also jumped. If you look at the set for the new season, the lighting and the physical table design are more immersive than ever. It’s a far cry from the early days of Zoom recordings during the pandemic. They’re using physical props, incredible minis, and lighting cues that change based on the mood of the scene. It’s high-budget "actual play" that still feels like a basement game.
Addressing the Fandom Expectations
There is a lot of pressure here. "Misfits and Magic" is often cited as the "gateway drug" for people who find D&D too intimidating. It’s short, it’s funny, and the barrier to entry is low.
📖 Related: Why Superstore Season 2 Is Still The Smartest Comedy On Television
Fans are looking for the same "found family" vibes. We want to see Evan, K, Sam, and Whitney just... being together. In a world that feels increasingly polarized and stressful, there is something deeply comforting about watching four people support each other while accidentally setting a magical library on fire.
The "misunderstandings" are the highlight. The way the characters interpret magical lore through the lens of modern internet culture or American sports is a recurring bit that never really gets old. It’s the kind of humor that feels very "of the moment" but stays grounded in the characters.
How to Prepare for the Premiere
If you’re planning on diving into Misfits and Magic Season 2, there are a few things you should probably do to get the most out of it.
- Rewatch the "Holiday Special": A lot of people missed the one-off episode they did between seasons. It bridges some of the character development and reminds you exactly where everyone's head is at.
- Brush up on the "Kids on Brooms" mechanics: You don't need to know the rules to enjoy the show, but understanding how "Exploding Dice" work makes the high-stakes moments much more exciting. Basically, if you roll the max number on a die, you keep rolling and adding. It leads to those "impossible" successes that make the table go wild.
- Check the Dropout Schedule: They usually release episodes weekly. If you're the type who likes to binge, you might want to wait a month so you can watch a few in a row, because the cliffhangers Aabria writes are genuinely painful.
- Pay attention to the background details: The production team at Dimension 20 hides a lot of "Easter eggs" in the set design and the character sheets.
The most important thing to remember is that this show isn't about winning a game. It’s about telling a story. When Brennan or Lou make a "bad" tactical move, they’re doing it because it’s what their character would do. That’s the magic of this specific cast. They prioritize the "bit" and the "heart" over the "win."
Keep an eye on the official Dropout social media channels for the exact drop dates and potential live-watch events. This season is shaping up to be a defining moment for Aabria's era of D20, and honestly, the magical world isn't ready for what Evan Kelmp and the rest of the crew are about to do to it. This isn't just a sequel; it's a victory lap for a group of creators who redefined what a "magic school" story can look like in 2026.
Check your subscription, clear your Wednesday nights, and get ready for some truly questionable magical decisions. It’s going to be a wild ride.