Money doesn't buy happiness, but in baseball, it sure buys a lot of October home games. Looking back at the final tallies for MLB teams payroll 2025, the gap between the haves and the have-nots didn't just stay wide—it basically became a canyon. We’re talking about a world where one team's tax bill alone could pay for the entire roster of a small-market rival.
Honestly, the numbers are kind of staggering. If you followed the 2025 season, you saw the Los Angeles Dodgers steamroll their way to a second straight World Series title. They didn't just win; they outspent the field so aggressively it felt like they were playing a different game entirely. But while everyone focuses on the $700 million man, Shohei Ohtani, the real story of 2025 payrolls is hidden in the "luxury tax" math that most fans (and a few owners) still find confusing as heck.
The Massive Divide: Who Spent and Who Saved?
When we talk about payroll, we usually look at the "cash" payroll—what owners actually cut checks for during the season. But the league looks at the Competitive Balance Tax (CBT) number. This is based on the average annual value (AAV) of contracts. In 2025, the base tax threshold sat at $241 million.
Nine teams ended up blowing past that $241 million line. Some just dipped a toe in, like the Texas Rangers, who finished with a tax payroll of $241.38 million. They paid a measly $190,000 in penalties. Compare that to the Dodgers. Their final CBT payroll hit a record-shattering $417.3 million. Because they were "repeat offenders," their tax bill alone was $169.4 million.
To put that in perspective, twelve MLB teams had a total roster payroll lower than just the Dodgers' tax payment.
The Top Spenders of 2025
The New York Mets, led by Steve Cohen, didn't hold back either. After landing Juan Soto in one of the most talked-about free-agent moves in history (a deal worth $62.2 million in 2025 AAV), their payroll surged to $346.6 million. They paid about $91.6 million in luxury tax.
The Philadelphia Phillies and New York Yankees also stayed in the "300 million club." The Phillies, with stars like Zack Wheeler ($42M) and Bryce Harper ($27.5M), finished at $314.3 million. Meanwhile, the Yankees hovered around $319.5 million. It’s a lot of zeros.
On the flip side, you have the "budget" teams. The Miami Marlins finished the 2025 season with the lowest payroll in the big leagues at a mere $86.9 million. Think about that. The Dodgers' tax was nearly double the Marlins' entire roster.
Other bottom-feeders included:
- Chicago White Sox: $91.8 million
- Tampa Bay Rays: $103.4 million
- Pittsburgh Pirates: $108.6 million
- Athletics: $118.1 million
Does Spending More Actually Work?
You’d think the standings would just be a copy-paste of the payroll list. It mostly was, but there were some embarrassing outliers.
The Mets are the obvious "ouch" here. Despite spending nearly $350 million on their roster, they finished 2025 with an 83-79 record and missed the playoffs entirely. That's a lot of money to spend to watch the postseason from a couch.
Then you have the Toronto Blue Jays. They spent big ($286 million) and it actually paid off. They roared back from a mediocre 2024 to win the AL East and make it all the way to the World Series, eventually losing to the Dodgers. They’re the poster child for "strategic spending." They didn't just buy stars; they filled holes.
The Efficiency Kings
The Milwaukee Brewers continue to be the weirdest team in baseball. They had a payroll of just $143.5 million—well below the league average—yet they won 97 games. That’s essentially $1.47 million per win. Compare that to the Mets, who paid about $4.17 million for every victory they secured.
The Ohtani Effect and Deferrals
You can't talk about MLB teams payroll 2025 without mentioning the "Ohtani Loophole." Shohei Ohtani’s contract is famously backloaded. He gets $2 million a year now and $68 million a year later.
👉 See also: Golden State Warriors Standings 2025: Why Most People Get the Record Wrong
For payroll purposes, the league calculates this differently to reflect the "present value." In 2025, Ohtani’s tax hit was roughly $46 million. It’s still a huge number, but it’s what allowed the Dodgers to go out and sign guys like Kyle Tucker (who they grabbed for $240 million over four years) while Ohtani was still on the books.
Why This Matters for 2026 and Beyond
We're already seeing the fallout. Owners of small-market teams are getting louder. Dick Monfort of the Rockies has been vocal about wanting a salary cap. They look at the Dodgers' $2.1 billion in total guaranteed commitments and realize they can't compete in a bidding war.
But the players' union (MLBPA) hates the idea of a cap. They see the luxury tax as a "soft cap" already. In 2025, the league collected over $400 million in tax money. That money doesn't just vanish; it goes toward player benefits and a fund that gets redistributed. Basically, the Dodgers and Yankees are subsidizing the rest of the league.
Takeaways for the Informed Fan
If you're trying to figure out if your team has a chance in the upcoming 2026 season, don't just look at the total cash. Look at where they sit relative to the CBT threshold.
📖 Related: Razorback Football Score Now: Why the 2025 Disaster Still Hurts
- Watch the "Threshold": The base tax for 2026 is moving up to $244 million. Teams like the Braves and Tigers are currently hovering just below it. If they want to make a mid-season trade, they have to decide if the tax penalty is worth the player.
- Age Matters: The Phillies and Rangers had the oldest rosters in 2025. When you pay a lot for older players, the "injury risk" cost is higher than the actual salary.
- The Draft Penalty: It's not just money. If a team goes $40 million over the threshold (like the Dodgers, Mets, and Yankees did), their top draft pick gets pushed back 10 spots. That's how you kill a farm system in the long run.
The 2025 season proved that while you can't guarantee a trophy with a $400 million check, you can certainly buy enough chances to eventually trip over one. For everyone else, the goal remains the same: be smarter, not richer.
To stay ahead of the curve, you should track the "Arbitration Estimates" for your favorite team's younger players. These are the hidden payroll spikes that often force small-market teams to trade away their stars before they get too expensive. Check sites like MLB Trade Rumors or Cot's Contracts to see which teams are approaching a "financial cliff" in the next twelve months.